You Pick BestYouPickBest

The 37 Most Legendary Kentucky Derby Winners of All Time

By YPB Team

The Kentucky Derby has been run since 1875, producing legendary champions who captured hearts worldwide. Which Derby winner is the greatest racehorse in the history of the Run for the Roses?

  1. Secretariat — ranked #11
    Secretariat
    The greatest racehorse in history who set the still-standing 1973 Derby record of 1:59 2/5 en route to the Triple Crown.
    1000pts
  2. Donerail — ranked #22
    Donerail
    At odds of 91-1, Donerail won the 1913 Derby in record time and remains the longest-priced winner in the race's history.
    882pts
  3. Zev — ranked #33
    Zev
    Zev won the 1923 Derby and Belmont, then beat English Derby winner Papyrus in a $100,000 match race at Belmont Park.
    882pts
  4. Sir Barton — ranked #44
    Sir Barton
    The very first Triple Crown winner in 1919, though the concept was not formally recognized for another decade.
    802pts
  5. Northern Dancer — ranked #55
    Northern Dancer
    The 1964 Derby winner who became the most influential sire in modern Thoroughbred history, reshaping racing forever.
    778pts
  6. Gallant Fox — ranked #66
    Gallant Fox
    Earl Sande rode him to the 1930 Triple Crown, and he later sired Omaha, making them the only father and son who both won it.
    694pts
  7. War Admiral — ranked #77
    War Admiral
    A powerful 1937 Triple Crown champion immortalized by his legendary match race defeat against Seabiscuit.
    694pts
  8. Citation — ranked #88
    Citation
    Calumet Farm's 1948 Triple Crown winner under Eddie Arcaro won 16 races in a row and became the first racehorse to earn $1 million.
    694pts
  9. Alysheba — ranked #99
    Alysheba
    Alysheba nearly fell after clipping heels in the 1987 Derby stretch but recovered to win, and later retired as the world's richest racehorse.
    694pts
  10. Aristides — ranked #1010
    Aristides
    Aristides won the first Kentucky Derby in 1875, ridden by Black jockey Oliver Lewis and trained by Black horseman Ansel Williamson.
    629pts
  11. Big Brown — ranked #1111
    Big Brown
    Unbeaten Big Brown won the 2008 Derby from post 20, then was eased in the Belmont and finished last with the Triple Crown on the line.
    555pts
  12. Smarty Jones — ranked #1212
    Smarty Jones
    The unbeaten Pennsylvania-bred took the 2004 Derby and Preakness, but Birdstone caught him in the Belmont before a record crowd of 120,139.
    555pts
  13. American Pharoah — ranked #1313
    American Pharoah
    The first Triple Crown winner in 37 years, ending a drought in 2015 with an electrifying performance at the Belmont.
    555pts
  14. Regret — ranked #1414
    Regret
    Regret became the first filly to win the Derby in 1915, leading from start to finish in her first race as a three-year-old.
    555pts
  15. Old Rosebud — ranked #1515
    Old Rosebud
    Old Rosebud won the 1914 Derby by eight lengths in a record 2:03 2/5, a winning margin that has been equaled but never beaten.
    555pts
  16. Seattle Slew — ranked #1616
    Seattle Slew
    The first horse to sweep the Triple Crown while still unbeaten, in 1977, a feat matched only by Justify in 2018.
    470pts
  17. Rich Strike — ranked #1717
    Rich Strike
    An extraordinary 80-to-1 long shot who delivered the second-biggest upset in Derby history in 2022.
    470pts
  18. Twenty Grand — ranked #1818
    Twenty Grand
    Twenty Grand set a Derby record of 2:01 4/5 in 1931 and added the Belmont, Travers and Jockey Club Gold Cup that year.
    470pts
  19. Funny Cide — ranked #1919
    Funny Cide
    Bought for $75,000 by a group of high-school friends, the gelding won the 2003 Derby and Preakness as the first New York-bred Derby winner.
    470pts
  20. I'll Have Another — ranked #2020
    I'll Have Another
    I'll Have Another came from post 19 to win the 2012 Derby and took the Preakness, but a tendon injury forced him out the day before the Belmont.
    470pts
  21. Mine That Bird — ranked #2121
    Mine That Bird
    Mine That Bird came from last at 50-1 to win the 2009 Derby by six and three-quarter lengths, a run that inspired the film 50 to 1.
    470pts
  22. Whirlaway — ranked #2222
    Whirlaway
    A popular and flashy 1941 Triple Crown winner known for his free-running style and distinctive long flowing tail.
    470pts
  23. Spectacular Bid — ranked #2323
    Spectacular Bid
    One of the greatest horses to win the Derby and Preakness (1979), narrowly missing the Triple Crown in the Belmont.
    470pts
  24. Genuine Risk — ranked #2424
    Genuine Risk
    One of only three fillies to ever win the Kentucky Derby (1980), becoming an enduring fan favorite.
    470pts
  25. California Chrome — ranked #2525
    California Chrome
    Bred from an $8,000 mare by two first-time owners, the California-bred colt won the 2014 Derby and Preakness and was twice voted Horse of the Year.
    370pts
  26. Sunday Silence — ranked #2626
    Sunday Silence
    Sunday Silence won the 1989 Derby and an epic Preakness duel with Easy Goer, then was Japan's leading sire for 13 years running.
    370pts
  27. Barbaro — ranked #2727
    Barbaro
    Barbaro won the 2006 Derby by six and a half lengths unbeaten, then shattered a leg in the Preakness and fought for eight months before laminitis ended his life.
    370pts
  28. Assault — ranked #2828
    Assault
    King Ranch's Assault, who had a misshapen right front hoof, won the 1946 Derby by eight lengths on the way to the Triple Crown.
    252pts
  29. Justify — ranked #2929
    Justify
    The 2018 unbeaten Triple Crown champion who incredibly never raced as a two-year-old before sweeping the Crown.
    0pts
  30. Affirmed — ranked #3030
    Affirmed
    Affirmed beat Alydar in all three 1978 Triple Crown races, the last by a head in the Belmont, with 18-year-old Steve Cauthen riding.
    0pts
  31. Count Fleet — ranked #3131
    Count Fleet
    The 1943 Triple Crown winner took the Belmont by 25 lengths, a record until Secretariat, and was never beaten as a three-year-old.
    0pts
  32. Silver Charm — ranked #3232
    Silver Charm
    The grey colt held off Captain Bodgit in the 1997 Derby and won the Preakness, but Touch Gold denied him the Triple Crown in the Belmont.
    0pts
  33. Omaha — ranked #3333
    Omaha
    The third Triple Crown winner, in 1935, Omaha later shipped to England and was beaten a short head in the Ascot Gold Cup; he is buried in Omaha, Nebraska.
  34. Swaps — ranked #3434
    Swaps
    The 'California Comet' beat Nashua in the 1955 Derby, lost their famous match race in Chicago that August and went on to set five world records.
  35. Majestic Prince — ranked #3535
    Majestic Prince
    A record $250,000 yearling, he beat Arts and Letters by a neck in the 1969 Derby and a head in the Preakness, then lost the Belmont to him.
  36. Riva Ridge — ranked #3636
    Riva Ridge
    Penny Chenery's colt won the 1972 Derby and Belmont, and his earnings helped save Meadow Stable a year before his stablemate Secretariat swept the Triple Crown.
  37. Winning Colors — ranked #3737
    Winning Colors
    Only the third filly ever to win the Derby, she went wire to wire in 1988 for trainer D. Wayne Lukas and jockey Gary Stevens, holding off the colts.

Photo credits

Comments