You Pick BestYouPickBest

The 12 Greatest Manchester City Managers of All Time

By YPB Team

From the swinging sixties to the Guardiola era, Manchester City's history spans brilliant mavericks and tactical masterminds. Which manager left the deepest mark on the club that became the most dominant force in English football?

  1. Pep Guardiola — ranked #11
    Pep Guardiola
    Spanish tactician who transformed City into a global superpower, winning 6 Premier League titles, the 2023 Champions League, and 15+ trophies between 2016 and 2026.
    1000pts
  2. Roberto Mancini — ranked #22
    Roberto Mancini
    Italian manager who ended City's 44-year wait for the English league title with a last-second 2012 championship, also winning the 2011 FA Cup.
    738pts
  3. Joe Mercer — ranked #33
    Joe Mercer
    Beloved manager of the late 1960s who led City to the league title in 1968, plus the FA Cup, League Cup, and European Cup Winners' Cup.
    706pts
  4. Kevin Keegan — ranked #44
    Kevin Keegan
    Charismatic manager who stabilized Manchester City in the early 2000s, gaining promotion to the Premier League and providing top-half finishes.
    683pts
  5. Mark Hughes — ranked #55
    Mark Hughes
    Former City player who managed the club from 2008–2009, helping transition the squad in the early months of Abu Dhabi ownership with notable signings.
    531pts
  6. Peter Reid — ranked #66
    Peter Reid
    Gritty midfielder-turned-manager who kept City afloat in the early 1990s, eventually losing his job after a run of poor results but stabilizing the club.
    474pts
  7. Manuel Pellegrini — ranked #77
    Manuel Pellegrini
    Chilean manager who guided City to the 2014 Premier League title and two League Cups, serving as the bridge into the modern trophy era.
    474pts
  8. Stuart Pearce — ranked #88
    Stuart Pearce
    Passionate former defender who managed City from 2005–2007, developing youth talent and keeping the club competitive on a limited budget.
    474pts
  9. Sven-Göran Eriksson — ranked #99
    Sven-Göran Eriksson
    Swedish manager who became the first high-profile appointment under the new Thaksin era, finishing ninth in 2007–08 with some eye-catching results.
    414pts
  10. Billy McNeill — ranked #1010
    Billy McNeill
    Celtic legend who managed City from 1983 to 1986, rebuilding the side after relegation and leading it back to the First Division in 1985 on a limited budget.
    414pts
  11. Tony Book — ranked #1111
    Tony Book
    Former captain turned manager who led City through the mid-1970s, capturing the League Cup in 1976 and developing promising young talent.
    0pts
  12. Malcolm Allison — ranked #1212
    Malcolm Allison
    Visionary tactician who co-managed the club during the golden Mercer era, later returning solo and known for flamboyant personality and bold tactics.
    0pts

Photo credits

Comments