You Pick BestYouPickBest

What is the best Super Mario video game of all time?

By YPB Team

Side-scrolling classics meet open-world adventures — every era of Mario is represented here. Cast your vote!

  1. Super Mario Bros. 3 — ranked #11
    Super Mario Bros. 3
    The NES masterpiece with diverse worlds, power-ups, and the iconic Tanooki Suit.
    1000pts
  2. Super Mario 64 — ranked #22
    Super Mario 64
    The groundbreaking 3D platformer that revolutionized gaming on the Nintendo 64.
    717pts
  3. Super Mario Maker 2 — ranked #33
    Super Mario Maker 2
    The 2019 Switch sequel added slopes, a Super Mario 3D World style, a story mode of more than 100 courses and online play to the course-building formula.
    685pts
  4. Super Mario World — ranked #44
    Super Mario World
    The beloved SNES classic that introduced Yoshi and set the standard for 2D platformers.
    671pts
  5. Super Mario Odyssey — ranked #55
    Super Mario Odyssey
    A globe-trotting 3D adventure featuring Mario's sentient cap companion Cappy.
    644pts
  6. Super Mario Bros. Wonder — ranked #66
    Super Mario Bros. Wonder
    Set in the Flower Kingdom, the 2023 Switch platformer uses Wonder Flowers that warp each level in surprising ways and lets Mario turn into an elephant.
    614pts
  7. Super Mario Sunshine — ranked #77
    Super Mario Sunshine
    A tropical GameCube adventure where Mario cleans up Isle Delfino with his water jetpack.
    614pts
  8. New Super Mario Bros. U — ranked #88
    New Super Mario Bros. U
    A 2012 Wii U launch title, the first high-definition side-scrolling Mario added the Flying Squirrel Suit and returned in 2019 as New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe on Switch.
    580pts
  9. Super Mario Galaxy 2 — ranked #99
    Super Mario Galaxy 2
    The acclaimed sequel with Yoshi and new power-ups across even more creative galaxies.
    543pts
  10. Super Mario 3D World — ranked #1010
    Super Mario 3D World
    A multiplayer-focused 3D adventure with the cat suit power-up on Wii U and Switch.
    543pts
  11. Super Mario Bros. — ranked #1111
    Super Mario Bros.
    The original 1985 classic that saved the video game industry and defined platforming.
    500pts
  12. Super Mario 3D Land — ranked #1212
    Super Mario 3D Land
    Built for the Nintendo 3DS in 2011, this compact adventure blends 3D movement with the short flagpole courses of the 2D games and brings back the Tanooki Suit.
    500pts
  13. Super Mario Galaxy — ranked #1313
    Super Mario Galaxy
    An epic space adventure where Mario explores galaxies to rescue Princess Peach.
    459pts
  14. New Super Mario Bros. — ranked #1414
    New Super Mario Bros.
    Released for the Nintendo DS in 2006, the first new side-scrolling Mario in 14 years added the Mega Mushroom and sold more than 30 million copies.
    459pts
  15. Super Mario Bros. 2 — ranked #1515
    Super Mario Bros. 2
    The 1988 Western sequel, rebuilt from the Japanese game Doki Doki Panic, lets players pluck vegetables as Mario, Luigi, Toad or Princess Peach in the dream world of Subcon.
    412pts
  16. Super Mario Bros.: The Lost Levels — ranked #1616
    Super Mario Bros.: The Lost Levels
    Released in Japan in 1986 as Super Mario Bros. 2, this punishing sequel with poison mushrooms and wind gusts reached the West only in 1993's Super Mario All-Stars.
    412pts
  17. Super Mario Land — ranked #1717
    Super Mario Land
    A 1989 Game Boy launch title in which Mario rescues Princess Daisy in her debut appearance, crossing Sarasaland with submarine and airplane shooter stages along the way.
    412pts
  18. Paper Mario — ranked #1818
    Paper Mario
    A charming RPG with a unique paper-craft art style and witty storytelling.
    412pts
  19. Super Mario Maker — ranked #1919
    Super Mario Maker
    A 2015 Wii U course editor made for the series' 30th anniversary, letting players build and share levels in the styles of four earlier Mario platformers.
    412pts
  20. Super Mario Land 2: 6 Golden Coins — ranked #2020
    Super Mario Land 2: 6 Golden Coins
    The 1992 Game Boy sequel introduced Wario, who seizes Mario's castle and forces him to collect six golden coins across themed zones such as a giant mechanical Mario.
    412pts
  21. New Super Mario Bros. Wii — ranked #2121
    New Super Mario Bros. Wii
    The 2009 Wii entry brought four-player simultaneous co-op to a side-scrolling Mario for the first time, along with the Propeller Mushroom and the Super Guide hint system.
    357pts
  22. Super Mario RPG — ranked #2222
    Super Mario RPG
    A beloved RPG collaboration between Nintendo and Square featuring turn-based combat.
    357pts
  23. New Super Mario Bros. 2 — ranked #2323
    New Super Mario Bros. 2
    The 2012 3DS sequel turns coin collecting into the main goal, with the Gold Flower, a Coin Rush mode and a running tally that aims at one million coins.
    0pts
  24. Super Mario Run — ranked #2424
    Super Mario Run
    Nintendo's first Mario game for smartphones, released in December 2016, is an auto-runner played with one hand, where taps time Mario's jumps across short courses.
    0pts

Photo credits
  • Super Mario Run key art — Nintendo, rights holder

Comments 1

Eleven mainline Super Mario games, no outside competition and still no agreement: Bros. 3 survives every cull and Odyssey has sold 30.50 million on Switch.

YP
ypb-team
Aug 21