You Pick BestYouPickBest

What is the best Maggie Smith role of all time?

By YPB Team

Oscar winner, BAFTA legend, and the most beloved scene-stealer in British cinema — from Jean Brodie to Violet Crawley, her withering put-downs are a national treasure. Which Maggie is your Maggie?

  1. Othello — ranked #11
    Othello
    A 1965 film adaptation where Smith plays Desdemona alongside Laurence Olivier, earning her first Academy Award nomination.
  2. The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie — ranked #22
    The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie
    A 1969 drama where Smith plays Jean Brodie, a charismatic Edinburgh schoolteacher with fascist sympathies, winning the Academy Award for Best Actress.
  3. California Suite — ranked #33
    California Suite
    A 1978 Neil Simon comedy where Smith plays Diana Barrie, a British actress attending the Oscars with her gay husband, earning her second Academy Award.
  4. A Room with a View — ranked #44
    A Room with a View
    A 1985 Merchant Ivory adaptation where Smith plays Charlotte Bartlett, the prim chaperone who tries to manage her free-spirited niece in Florence.
  5. Hook — ranked #55
    Hook
    A 1991 Steven Spielberg fantasy where Smith plays the elderly Wendy Darling, who implores a grown-up Peter Pan to remember who he was.
  6. Sister Act — ranked #66
    Sister Act
    A 1992 comedy where Smith plays the uptight Mother Superior who must accept Whoopi Goldberg's show-stopping singer into her convent.
  7. Tea with Mussolini — ranked #77
    Tea with Mussolini
    A 1999 Franco Zeffirelli film where Smith plays Lady Hester Random, a formidable expatriate Englishwoman living in Fascist Florence.
  8. Gosford Park — ranked #88
    Gosford Park
    A 2001 Robert Altman murder mystery where Smith plays Lady Constance Trentham, the acerbic, cash-strapped aristocrat who provides some of the film's sharpest wit.
  9. Harry Potter Series — ranked #99
    Harry Potter Series
    The 2001–2011 fantasy franchise where Smith plays Professor Minerva McGonagall, the stern but loyal deputy headmistress of Hogwarts.
  10. Downton Abbey — ranked #1010
    Downton Abbey
    A 2010–2015 ITV period drama where Smith plays Violet Crawley, the razor-tongued Dowager Countess whose withering one-liners became iconic.
  11. The Best Exotic Marigold Hotel — ranked #1111
    The Best Exotic Marigold Hotel
    A 2012 comedy-drama where Smith plays Muriel Donnelly, a prejudiced housekeeper who travels to India for hip surgery and undergoes an unexpected transformation.
  12. The Lady in the Van — ranked #1212
    The Lady in the Van
    A 2015 biopic where Smith plays Miss Mary Shepherd, a cantankerous homeless woman who parks her van in Alan Bennett's driveway for 15 years.

Comments 1

Obituaries in September 2024 led with Jean Brodie and Downton Abbey and reached Hogwarts third, which is roughly this ranking in miniature: https://youpick.best/articles/harry-potter-ranked-many-ways

YP
ypb-team
Aug 21