What is the best Tobey Maguire movie?

From web-slinging blockbusters to quiet indie dramas and awards-season heavyweights, his range stretches far beyond the mask. Which performance tops your list?

1

Spider-Man 2

The 2004 superhero sequel widely hailed as one of the greatest comic-book films, with Maguire's most acclaimed turn as Peter Parker.

1000pts

2

Spider-Man: No Way Home

The 2021 multiverse event where Maguire reprised his Peter Parker alongside two other Spider-Men.

816pts

3

Brothers

The 2009 war drama that earned Maguire a Golden Globe nomination for a haunted returning soldier.

799pts

4

Pawn Sacrifice

The 2014 biopic with Maguire as chess legend Bobby Fischer at the 1972 World Championship.

753pts

5

Ride with the Devil

Ang Lee's 1999 Civil War drama with Maguire as a young Confederate bushwhacker.

753pts

6

Seabiscuit

The 2003 Depression-era horse-racing drama in which Maguire plays jockey Red Pollard.

699pts

7

The Ice Storm

Ang Lee's acclaimed 1997 suburban drama that first drew Hollywood's attention to Maguire.

699pts

8

Pleasantville

The 1998 fantasy in which two teens are transported into a black-and-white sitcom world.

635pts

9

Wonder Boys

Curtis Hanson's 2000 dramedy where Maguire plays a gifted, troubled writing student.

635pts

10

The Great Gatsby

Baz Luhrmann's lavish 2013 adaptation with Maguire as narrator Nick Carraway.

559pts

11

The Cider House Rules

The 1999 coming-of-age drama, an ensemble Oscar winner, with Maguire as orphan Homer Wells.

559pts

12

Spider-Man

Sam Raimi's genre-defining 2002 blockbuster that made Maguire an icon as the web-slinger.

466pts

13

Babylon

Damien Chazelle's 2022 epic of early Hollywood excess featuring Maguire in a chilling supporting role.

466pts