You Pick BestYouPickBest

What is the best hot dog topping?

By YPB Team

Classic squeeze-bottle staples square off against regional cult favorites and a few toppings that start real arguments at the grill. Where do you stand?

  1. Sauerkraut — ranked #11
    Sauerkraut
    Tangy fermented cabbage that adds sharp crunch, the signature topping of the New York deli-style dog.
    1000pts
  2. Bacon — ranked #22
    Bacon
    Crispy strips or a full bacon wrap adding smoky, salty crunch to every bite.
    667pts
  3. Diced Onions — ranked #33
    Diced Onions
    Sharp raw white onion scattered on top for a pungent bite that cuts through the rich sausage.
    577pts
  4. Ketchup — ranked #44
    Ketchup
    The sweet tomato standby beloved by kids and controversial among purists who insist it has no place on a hot dog.
    577pts
  5. Sweet Relish — ranked #55
    Sweet Relish
    Bright, chopped sweet-pickle relish — the neon-green condiment that defines a proper Chicago dog.
    577pts
  6. Jalapeños — ranked #66
    Jalapeños
    Sliced pickled or fresh jalapeños delivering a spicy kick for heat-seekers.
    500pts
  7. Coleslaw — ranked #77
    Coleslaw
    Creamy shredded cabbage slaw piled on top, the hallmark of Southern slaw dogs.
    500pts
  8. Pickle Spear — ranked #88
    Pickle Spear
    A cool, crunchy dill pickle spear laid alongside the frank, a Chicago dog essential.
    500pts
  9. Chili — ranked #99
    Chili
    A hearty ladle of bean-free meat chili that turns a plain frank into a knife-and-fork chili dog.
    454pts
  10. Melted Cheese — ranked #1010
    Melted Cheese
    A gooey blanket of nacho or cheddar cheese for a rich, indulgent cheese dog.
    454pts
  11. Chopped Tomato — ranked #1111
    Chopped Tomato
    Fresh tomato wedges or slices adding juicy brightness, part of the garden-dragged Chicago dog.
    400pts
  12. Cream Cheese — ranked #1212
    Cream Cheese
    A smear of cream cheese with grilled onions, the unmistakable base of the Seattle-style dog.
    0pts
  13. Sport Peppers — ranked #1313
    Sport Peppers
    Small, tangy pickled hot peppers that bring vinegary heat to the classic Chicago dog.
    0pts
  14. Grilled Onions — ranked #1414
    Grilled Onions
    Sweet, caramelized griddled onions that add savory depth over the top of the dog.
    0pts

Comments 1

Chicago's hot dog takes mustard, relish, onion, tomato and sport peppers, and refuses ketchup. Fourteen toppings, two of them cheese, one from Seattle.

YP
ypb-team
Aug 21