You Pick BestYouPickBest

What is the best Criminal Minds season?

By YPB Team

Criminal Minds ran for 15 seasons plus a revival, following the FBI's Behavioral Analysis Unit as they hunted serial killers across America. Which season was the most compelling chapter of the series?

  1. Season 5 — ranked #11
    Season 5
    The acclaimed 2009 season centered on the terrifying Reaper storyline, consistently ranked by fans as one of the series' all-time best.
    1000pts
  2. Season 9 — ranked #22
    Season 9
    The 2013–14 season featuring the milestone 200th episode, in which JJ is abducted, and ending with Alex Blake's departure after Reid is shot.
    868pts
  3. Season 7 — ranked #33
    Season 7
    The 2011–12 season that brought back JJ and Emily Prentiss after her faked death, ending with a two-part bank heist finale and Prentiss's farewell.
    813pts
  4. Season 3 — ranked #44
    Season 3
    The 2007 season introducing fan-favorite David Rossi (Joe Mantegna) and tackling some of the series' most disturbing criminal cases.
    750pts
  5. Season 2 — ranked #55
    Season 2
    The 2006 season delivering standout episodes and deepening character backstories while cementing the show's reputation for chilling unsubs.
    721pts
  6. Season 14 — ranked #66
    Season 14
    The penultimate 2018 season with a tight 15-episode order, led by unit chief Emily Prentiss and opening with the milestone 300th episode.
    583pts
  7. Season 1 — ranked #77
    Season 1
    The 2005 debut season establishing the BAU team's dynamic and groundbreaking criminal profiling format that made the show a cultural phenomenon.
    583pts
  8. Season 8 — ranked #88
    Season 8
    The 2012 season introducing Alex Blake (Jeanne Tripplehorn) and pitting the BAU against the Replicator, a stalker whose campaign ends with Erin Strauss's death.
    583pts
  9. Season 11 — ranked #99
    Season 11
    The 2015–16 season introducing Tara Lewis (Aisha Tyler), pitting the team against the elusive Mr. Scratch and marking Shemar Moore's farewell as Derek Morgan.
    500pts
  10. Season 6 — ranked #1010
    Season 6
    The 2010 season navigating cast changes with the departure of Prentiss and the arrival of Ashley Seaver, featuring the shocking 'Lauren' episode.
    462pts
  11. Season 4 — ranked #1111
    Season 4
    The 2008–09 season opening with the aftermath of a bomb blast that hits the BAU team and introducing the Boston Reaper in the episode 'Omnivore'.
    417pts
  12. Season 15 — ranked #1212
    Season 15
    The 2020 final CBS season of just ten episodes, closing the original run as the BAU hunts the serial killer known as the Chameleon, Everett Lynch.
    417pts
  13. Season 13 — ranked #1313
    Season 13
    The 2017–18 season with Emily Prentiss leading the unit after Hotchner's exit, Daniel Henney joining as Matt Simmons, and Reid back from prison.
    417pts
  14. Season 16 (Evolution) — ranked #1414
    Season 16 (Evolution)
    The 2022–23 revival on Paramount+ reuniting the BAU team to track a network of serial killers built by Elias Voit during pandemic isolation.
    417pts
  15. Season 17 — ranked #1515
    Season 17
    The 2024 second Evolution season on Paramount+, in which imprisoned killer Elias Voit helps the BAU while a hidden serial-killer conspiracy called Gold Star surfaces.
    364pts
  16. Season 19 — ranked #1616
    Season 19
    The 2026 fourth Evolution season, which premiered on Paramount+ on May 28 as the BAU faced new killers, with a 20th season already ordered.
    364pts
  17. Season 10 — ranked #1717
    Season 10
    The 2014–15 season adding Jennifer Love Hewitt as agent Kate Callahan and launching the Criminal Minds: Beyond Borders spin-off through a backdoor pilot episode.
    364pts
  18. Season 12 — ranked #1818
    Season 12
    The 2016 season following Derek Morgan's exit and the arrival of new agent Luke Alvez, with Dr. Reid imprisoned on drug charges in Mexico.
    0pts
  19. Season 18 — ranked #1919
    Season 18
    The 2025 third Evolution season on Paramount+, continuing the BAU's pursuit of the Gold Star network of serial killers that grew out of Elias Voit's crimes.
    0pts

Comments