Each chapter drops you into a new Midwestern crime story drenched in black comedy and moral ambiguity — from beloved fan favorites to sleeper picks. Which season had you hooked? Cast your vote!
1Season 1The 2014 debut chapter starring Billy Bob Thornton as the chilling hitman Lorne Malvo and Martin Freeman as a hapless insurance salesman pulled into a spiral of violence in Bemidji, Minnesota.1000pts
2Season 4The 2020 chapter set in 1950 Kansas City starring Chris Rock as the patriarch of a Black crime syndicate locked in a brutal turf war with the Italian Fadda family.409pts
3Season 5The 2023 chapter featuring Juno Temple as a suburban Minnesota housewife with a dangerous hidden past who is targeted by a relentless bounty hunter played by Jon Hamm.300pts
4Season 3The 2017 chapter set in 2010-2011 featuring Ewan McGregor in a dual role as feuding brothers whose rivalry is exploited by the sinister V.M. Varga, played by David Thewlis.0pts
