Some wore the C for one dynasty, some carried a franchise for two decades, and one of them guaranteed a win and then delivered it. Vote for the captain you would want on the ice with a series slipping away.
1Mark MessierCaptained both the Oilers and the Rangers to Stanley Cups, and guaranteed one of them.1000pts
2Wayne GretzkyWore the Edmonton C through three of the Oilers' four Cup wins in the 1980s.944pts
3Steve YzermanCaptained Detroit for 19 seasons and turned a scoring team into a three-time champion.833pts
4Joe SakicCaptained Colorado for 17 years, two Cups, and one famous refusal to touch the conference trophy.796pts
5Mario LemieuxCaptained Pittsburgh to back-to-back Cups, then came back and captained the team he owned.667pts
6Ray BourqueBoston's captain for 15 seasons, who finally lifted the Cup in Colorado.666pts
7Jonathan ToewsNicknamed Captain Serious, he had three Cups before turning 27.500pts
8Sidney CrosbyTook the Pittsburgh C at 19 and has won three Cups wearing it.462pts
9Alex OvechkinWashington's captain since 2010 and the man who ended a 44-year wait for the Cup.417pts
10Maurice RichardMontreal's captain for four straight Cups at the end of a combustible career.417pts
11Zdeno CharaAt 6-foot-9 the tallest captain in league history, and a champion in 2011.417pts
12Jean BeliveauLed Montreal to five Cups as captain, and to ten in all as a player.417pts
13Bobby ClarkeCaptained the Broad Street Bullies to the only two Cups in Flyers history.364pts
14Denis PotvinWore the C for all four New York Islanders championships.0pts
15Nicklas LidstromThe first European captain to win the Stanley Cup, in Detroit in 2008.0pts
16Scott StevensNew Jersey's captain through three Cups and the hardest shoulder of his era.0pts
Photo credits
- Steve Yzerman — Don Bigileone, CC BY 2.0
- Joe Sakic — Hakan Dahlstrom (uploader), CC BY-SA 3.0
Comments 1
Ovechkin has worn Washington's C since 2010 and Gretzky captained four Cup winners, yet Mark Messier is why neither of Ovechkin and Gretzky is the obvious pick.
YP
ypb-teamAug 21



















