You Pick BestYouPickBest

The 16 Greatest Hart Trophy Winners in NHL History

By YPB Team

The Hart goes to the player judged most valuable to his team, which is not the same thing as the best player alive. Nine of them went to one man; a goalie has not won it in a decade. Pick the winner whose season you would take.

  1. Gordie Howe — ranked #11
    Gordie Howe
    Six Harts spread across 15 years, the last at 35.
    1000pts
  2. Wayne Gretzky — ranked #22
    Wayne Gretzky
    Won the MVP award nine times, eight of them in a row.
    962pts
  3. Mario Lemieux — ranked #33
    Mario Lemieux
    Three MVP awards, one of them the season he came back from cancer treatment.
    727pts
  4. Alex Ovechkin — ranked #44
    Alex Ovechkin
    Three Harts in six seasons at the start of a 20-year scoring run.
    694pts
  5. Connor McDavid — ranked #55
    Connor McDavid
    Three Harts before turning 27, from the fastest player of his generation.
    679pts
  6. Bobby Orr — ranked #66
    Bobby Orr
    Three straight Harts while redefining what a defenceman was allowed to do.
    635pts
  7. Guy Lafleur — ranked #77
    Guy Lafleur
    Back-to-back MVPs in the middle of Montreal's late-1970s dynasty.
    567pts
  8. Sidney Crosby — ranked #88
    Sidney Crosby
    Two Harts, seven years apart, either side of a concussion that cost him a season.
    500pts
  9. Jean Beliveau — ranked #99
    Jean Beliveau
    Won the Hart in the first season the award and his captaincy overlapped.
    500pts
  10. Jaromir Jagr — ranked #1010
    Jaromir Jagr
    The 1999 MVP, in the middle of five scoring titles in six years.
    459pts
  11. Dominik Hasek — ranked #1111
    Dominik Hasek
    The only goalie to win back-to-back Harts, in 1997 and 1998.
    412pts
  12. Mark Messier — ranked #1212
    Mark Messier
    Two MVPs, one in Edmonton after Gretzky left and one in New York.
    412pts
  13. Eddie Shore — ranked #1313
    Eddie Shore
    A defenceman who won four MVPs in the 1930s, which no defenceman has matched.
    357pts
  14. Howie Morenz — ranked #1414
    Howie Morenz
    Montreal's first superstar and a three-time MVP in the 1920s and 30s.
    357pts
  15. Bobby Clarke — ranked #1515
    Bobby Clarke
    Three Harts for a two-way centre who was told his diabetes would end his career.
    357pts
  16. Carey Price — ranked #1616
    Carey Price
    The last goalie to win it, sweeping the individual awards in 2015.
    357pts

Photo credits

Comments 1

Nine of these MVP awards went to Gretzky and three to Ovechkin, the pair behind Gretzky versus Ovechkin, and the 2025 winner was a goaltender.

YP
ypb-team
Aug 21