Leading laps at Indianapolis is not the same as winning it, and this list is made entirely of the difference.
1Michael AndrettiLed more laps at Indianapolis than any driver who never won it, across 16 starts.1000pts
2Mario AndrettiWon in 1969 on his fifth attempt, then went 0-for-24, including a 1981 victory handed back four months later.935pts
3Roberto GuerreroRookie runner-up in 1984, then spun on the warm-up lap from pole in 1992.686pts
4Lloyd RubyEighteen starts, five races led, and a torn fuel tank in 1969 while running down the leader.632pts
5Marco AndrettiLost the 2006 race to Sam Hornish Jr. by 0.0635 seconds as a rookie teenager.570pts
6Paul TracyBelieved he had won the 2002 race, and lost it to a caution-flag ruling.570pts
7J.R. HildebrandCrashed in the final corner of the final lap in 2011 while leading.500pts
8Robby GordonRan out of fuel while leading with nine laps left in 1999.417pts
9Rex MaysFour poles and two runner-up finishes in fifteen starts without a victory.417pts
10Scott GoodyearBeaten by 0.043 seconds in 1992 and penalised out of the lead in 1995.417pts
11Tony BettenhausenFourteen starts, no win, and died testing a friend's car at the Speedway in 1961.364pts
12Ted HornFinished fourth or better nine straight times at Indianapolis and never won.364pts
13Duke NalonStarted from pole twice and survived a fiery crash in the 1949 race.364pts
14Danny OngaisLed comfortably in 1981 before a crash that nearly cost him his life.0pts
15Ed CarpenterThree Indianapolis poles as an owner-driver and never better than second.0pts
Photo credits
- Paul Tracy — Zach Catanzareti Photo, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Robby Gordon — Emanuel Agustin Lorenzoni Macchi, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Scott Goodyear — Manningmbd, CC BY-SA 3.0

























