You Pick BestYouPickBest

The 29 Greatest Italian-American Athletes of All Time

By YPB Team

Baseball diamonds, boxing gyms, football sidelines and one racing car. The only thing connecting them is a surname.

  1. Joe DiMaggio — ranked #11
    Joe DiMaggio
    Yankee Clipper with a 56-game hitting streak that still stands.
    1000pts
  2. Joe Montana — ranked #22
    Joe Montana
    Four Super Bowl titles and no interceptions in any of them.
    883pts
  3. Mario Andretti — ranked #33
    Mario Andretti
    Born near Trieste, raised in Nazareth, Pennsylvania, and the only driver to win Indianapolis, Daytona and the Formula 1 title.
    773pts
  4. Vince Lombardi — ranked #44
    Vince Lombardi
    Won five NFL championships in seven years and gave the Super Bowl trophy its name.
    773pts
  5. Rocky Marciano — ranked #55
    Rocky Marciano
    The only heavyweight champion to retire undefeated, at 49-0.
    722pts
  6. Brian Boitano — ranked #66
    Brian Boitano
    Won Olympic figure-skating gold in Calgary in 1988 with the Battle of the Brians.
    703pts
  7. Franco Harris — ranked #77
    Franco Harris
    Four Super Bowl rings and the Immaculate Reception.
    615pts
  8. Phil Rizzuto — ranked #88
    Phil Rizzuto
    Yankees shortstop, 1950 MVP, then four decades in the broadcast booth.
    615pts
  9. Tony La Russa — ranked #99
    Tony La Russa
    Won three World Series as a manager and reinvented bullpen strategy.
    615pts
  10. Tommy Lasorda — ranked #1010
    Tommy Lasorda
    Managed the Los Angeles Dodgers for twenty seasons and won the World Series in 1981 and 1988.
    615pts
  11. Mike Eruzione — ranked #1111
    Mike Eruzione
    Captain of the 1980 US Olympic hockey team who scored the winning goal against the Soviet Union in the Miracle on Ice.
    562pts
  12. Mike Piazza — ranked #1212
    Mike Piazza
    The most productive hitting catcher in baseball history, drafted in the 62nd round.
    562pts
  13. Hank Luisetti — ranked #1313
    Hank Luisetti
    Stanford star of the 1930s who popularised the one-handed running shot and changed how basketball was played.
    500pts
  14. Dan Marino — ranked #1414
    Dan Marino
    Threw for more yards than anyone before him and reshaped the passing game.
    500pts
  15. Jake LaMotta — ranked #1515
    Jake LaMotta
    The Bronx Bull, middleweight champion and subject of Raging Bull.
    500pts
  16. Joe Torre — ranked #1616
    Joe Torre
    Won the 1971 National League MVP as a player and four World Series as manager of the Yankees.
    500pts
  17. Matt Biondi — ranked #1717
    Matt Biondi
    Won seven medals at the 1988 Seoul Olympics, five of them gold.
    500pts
  18. Tony Lazzeri — ranked #1818
    Tony Lazzeri
    Hall of Fame second baseman of the Murderers' Row Yankees, a five-time World Series winner.
    451pts
  19. Mary Lou Retton — ranked #1919
    Mary Lou Retton
    Scored two perfect tens to become the first American woman to win the Olympic all-around gymnastics title, in Los Angeles in 1984.
    451pts
  20. Yogi Berra — ranked #2020
    Yogi Berra
    Ten World Series rings as a catcher and three American League MVP awards.
    451pts
  21. Rocky Graziano — ranked #2121
    Rocky Graziano
    Middleweight champion of 1947 whose three wars with Tony Zale and life story became the film Somebody Up There Likes Me.
    451pts
  22. Geno Auriemma — ranked #2222
    Geno Auriemma
    Born in Montella, Italy, he built UConn into the most decorated programme in women's college basketball.
    394pts
  23. Willie Mosconi — ranked #2323
    Willie Mosconi
    Won fifteen world pocket-billiards championships.
    394pts
  24. Gene Sarazen — ranked #2424
    Gene Sarazen
    Born Eugenio Saraceni, he won seven majors and became the first player to complete golf's modern career Grand Slam in 1935.
    394pts
  25. Tony Canzoneri — ranked #2525
    Tony Canzoneri
    Won world titles at featherweight, lightweight and light welterweight in the late 1920s and 1930s.
    394pts
  26. Craig Biggio — ranked #2626
    Craig Biggio
    Collected 3,060 hits in twenty seasons, all with the Houston Astros, and entered the Hall of Fame in 2015.
    394pts
  27. Willie Pep — ranked #2727
    Willie Pep
    Born Guglielmo Papaleo, the two-time featherweight champion is regarded as one of the greatest defensive boxers who ever lived.
    0pts
  28. Carmen Basilio — ranked #2828
    Carmen Basilio
    The onion farmer from upstate New York who held the welterweight and middleweight titles and beat Sugar Ray Robinson in 1957.
    0pts
  29. Jennifer Capriati — ranked #2929
    Jennifer Capriati
    Olympic champion at 16 in Barcelona, then three Grand Slam singles titles in a comeback that reached world number one.
    0pts

Photo credits

Comments