You Pick BestYouPickBest

Top 24 Most Overrated Rappers of All Time

By YPB Team5 votes

Sales, skill and reputation almost never line up in rap, and this is where the gap gets loud. Some names here sold diamond; some are here because a rival ended them.

  1. Drake — ranked #11
    Drake
    The streaming era's biggest star, and the one critics accuse of chasing every trend.
    1000pts
  2. Travis Scott — ranked #22
    Travis Scott
    A stadium-filling performer whose rapping is often called secondary to his production, ad-libs and spectacle.
    784pts
  3. Machine Gun Kelly — ranked #33
    Machine Gun Kelly
    The Cleveland rapper who pivoted to pop-punk after a very public losing beef.
    763pts
  4. J. Cole — ranked #44
    J. Cole
    A respected lyricist whose critics call his albums safe and his songwriting preachy despite his huge sales.
    756pts
  5. Post Malone — ranked #55
    Post Malone
    A genre-blurring hitmaker whose place inside hip-hop is argued every year.
    689pts
  6. Nicki Minaj — ranked #66
    Nicki Minaj
    A record-breaking rapper whose pop crossovers split opinion about her rap legacy.
    606pts
  7. Logic — ranked #77
    Logic
    A technically fluent MC whose reputation among critics never matched his sales.
    600pts
  8. Kanye West — ranked #88
    Kanye West
    A producer-turned-rapper whose production is rarely questioned and whose rapping often is.
    600pts
  9. Iggy Azalea — ranked #99
    Iggy Azalea
    The Australian rapper whose chart peak drew persistent questions about authenticity.
    555pts
  10. Lil Wayne — ranked #1010
    Lil Wayne
    The mixtape-era phenomenon whose late catalogue divides even loyal fans.
    504pts
  11. Jay-Z — ranked #1111
    Jay-Z
    The business blueprint of rap, and a frequent target of the argument that longevity is not the same as peak.
    504pts
  12. Waka Flocka Flame — ranked #1212
    Waka Flocka Flame
    Trap pioneer whose energy and influence, critics say, far outweigh his verbal skill.
    497pts
  13. Lil Pump — ranked #1313
    Lil Pump
    A viral SoundCloud-era figure whose fame far outran his catalogue.
    462pts
  14. Eminem — ranked #1414
    Eminem
    Detroit's technical benchmark, and the name that starts the loudest argument about whether skill equals greatness.
    462pts
  15. Big Sean — ranked #1515
    Big Sean
    Detroit hitmaker with a long run of chart singles whose punchlines are often mocked as corny.
    449pts
  16. Lil Yachty — ranked #1616
    Lil Yachty
    The self-styled 'King of the Teens' whose early mumble-rap hits made him a lightning rod in debates over lyricism.
    449pts
  17. 2 Chainz — ranked #1717
    2 Chainz
    Atlanta veteran whose punchline-heavy hits have long been questioned by lyric-focused critics.
    449pts
  18. Vanilla Ice — ranked #1818
    Vanilla Ice
    A single enormous hit built on a borrowed bassline, and little else.
    414pts
  19. Soulja Boy — ranked #1919
    Soulja Boy
    The 'Crank That' star who pioneered internet self-promotion in rap, while critics say his music never matched his boasts.
    392pts
  20. Tupac Shakur — ranked #2020
    Tupac Shakur
    Hip-hop's most mythologized figure, whose posthumous legend some critics argue has outgrown the albums he actually released.
    392pts
  21. Lil Uzi Vert — ranked #2121
    Lil Uzi Vert
    Emo-rap star whose melodic hits drew devoted fans and skeptics of his lyrics in equal measure.
    392pts
  22. Ja Rule — ranked #2222
    Ja Rule
    An early-2000s hitmaker whose run ended when a rival dismantled his reputation.
    359pts
  23. Jeezy — ranked #2323
    Jeezy
    Atlanta trap figurehead often named in debates as repetitive in subject matter and delivery.
    0pts
  24. Cardi B — ranked #2424
    Cardi B
    Record-setting chart star whose critics argue her personality and social-media fame outweigh her rapping.
    0pts

Photo credits

Comments 1

Being on this one requires being rated highly first, which is why Drake, Jay-Z and Lil Wayne share it with Vanilla Ice and Lil Pump: https://youpick.best/articles/eminem-ranked-many-ways

YP
ypb-team
Aug 21