You Pick BestYouPickBest

Who is the most overrated figure in history?

By YPB Team

Reputations built on other people's work, other people's poems and a few well-placed memoirs. Nobody here is a nobody, which is what makes it an argument.

  1. Christopher Columbus — ranked #11
    Christopher Columbus
    Credited with a discovery he did not make, in a place he misidentified until he died.
    1000pts
  2. Thomas Edison — ranked #22
    Thomas Edison
    Held over a thousand patents and a reputation for taking credit earned in his own workshops.
    600pts
  3. Ferdinand Magellan — ranked #33
    Ferdinand Magellan
    Credited with the first circumnavigation despite dying less than halfway round.
    551pts
  4. Marie Antoinette — ranked #44
    Marie Antoinette
    Remembered for a sentence she never said and a frivolity her letters do not support.
    494pts
  5. Cleopatra — ranked #55
    Cleopatra
    Famous for a beauty no contemporary described and remembered mostly through Roman propaganda.
    494pts
  6. Alexander the Great — ranked #66
    Alexander the Great
    Inherited the best army in the world from his father and is rarely asked to share the credit.
    350pts
  7. Paul Revere — ranked #77
    Paul Revere
    One of several riders that night, and the only one Longfellow put in a poem.
    257pts
  8. Richard the Lionheart — ranked #88
    Richard the Lionheart
    England's warrior-king icon who spent about six months of a ten-year reign in the country.
    257pts
  9. Napoleon Bonaparte — ranked #99
    Napoleon Bonaparte
    Brilliant at sixty battles and remembered less for the two that finished him.
    257pts
  10. Nikola Tesla — ranked #1010
    Nikola Tesla
    A genuinely great engineer turned into an internet saint who supposedly invented everything.
    257pts
  11. Julius Caesar — ranked #1111
    Julius Caesar
    Wrote the definitive account of his own campaigns, which is one way to secure a reputation.
    257pts
  12. Henry Ford — ranked #1212
    Henry Ford
    Did not invent the car or the assembly line, but got his name on both.
    257pts
  13. Winston Churchill — ranked #1313
    Winston Churchill
    Topped a national poll of greatest Britons, and remains the subject of the fiercest reputational argument of any of them.
    0pts
  14. Amelia Earhart — ranked #1414
    Amelia Earhart
    A real pioneer whose fame rests more on how she disappeared than on what she flew.
    0pts

Comments 1

Gallipoli cost him the Admiralty by May 1915, and a 2019 study blamed the 1943 Bengal famine on policy rather than on drought: https://youpick.best/articles/winston-churchill-ranked-many-ways

YP
ypb-team
Aug 21