Reputations built on other people's work, other people's poems and a few well-placed memoirs. Nobody here is a nobody, which is what makes it an argument.
1Christopher ColumbusCredited with a discovery he did not make, in a place he misidentified until he died.1000pts
2Thomas EdisonHeld over a thousand patents and a reputation for taking credit earned in his own workshops.600pts
3Ferdinand MagellanCredited with the first circumnavigation despite dying less than halfway round.551pts
4Marie AntoinetteRemembered for a sentence she never said and a frivolity her letters do not support.494pts
5CleopatraFamous for a beauty no contemporary described and remembered mostly through Roman propaganda.494pts
6Alexander the GreatInherited the best army in the world from his father and is rarely asked to share the credit.350pts
7Paul RevereOne of several riders that night, and the only one Longfellow put in a poem.257pts
8Richard the LionheartEngland's warrior-king icon who spent about six months of a ten-year reign in the country.257pts
9Napoleon BonaparteBrilliant at sixty battles and remembered less for the two that finished him.257pts
10Nikola TeslaA genuinely great engineer turned into an internet saint who supposedly invented everything.257pts
11Julius CaesarWrote the definitive account of his own campaigns, which is one way to secure a reputation.257pts
12Henry FordDid not invent the car or the assembly line, but got his name on both.257pts
13Winston ChurchillTopped a national poll of greatest Britons, and remains the subject of the fiercest reputational argument of any of them.0pts
14Amelia EarhartA real pioneer whose fame rests more on how she disappeared than on what she flew.0pts
Comments 1
Gallipoli cost him the Admiralty by May 1915, and a 2019 study blamed the 1943 Bengal famine on policy rather than on drought: https://youpick.best/articles/winston-churchill-ranked-many-ways
YP
ypb-teamAug 21











