You Pick BestYouPickBest

The 15 Greatest Historians of All Time

By YPB Team

Ancient chroniclers, television dons and one Nobel laureate who wrote history between wars. Two and a half thousand years of people explaining the past to everybody else.

  1. Edward Gibbon — ranked #11
    Edward Gibbon
    Six volumes on the decline and fall of Rome, and English prose has not recovered from the style.
    1000pts
  2. Thucydides — ranked #22
    Thucydides
    Wrote the Peloponnesian War as analysis rather than storytelling and is still on strategy syllabuses.
    733pts
  3. Mary Beard — ranked #33
    Mary Beard
    Cambridge classicist who has made Roman history mainstream television.
    551pts
  4. Herodotus — ranked #44
    Herodotus
    Called the father of history, and the first to treat hearsay as evidence worth weighing.
    466pts
  5. Fernand Braudel — ranked #55
    Fernand Braudel
    Made geography and daily life the engine of history rather than kings and battles.
    466pts
  6. A. J. P. Taylor — ranked #66
    A. J. P. Taylor
    Britain's first television historian, lecturing to camera without notes.
    466pts
  7. Winston Churchill — ranked #77
    Winston Churchill
    Wrote a four-volume life of Marlborough and a history of the English-speaking peoples, and won the Nobel for it.
    363pts
  8. Barbara Tuchman — ranked #88
    Barbara Tuchman
    Won two Pulitzers without a doctorate, and wrote the book Kennedy handed to his staff.
    363pts
  9. Livy — ranked #99
    Livy
    Told Rome's story from its founding across 142 books, most of them now lost.
    363pts
  10. Doris Kearns Goodwin — ranked #1010
    Doris Kearns Goodwin
    Pulitzer-winning presidential historian whose Lincoln book became a film.
    363pts
  11. Simon Schama — ranked #1111
    Simon Schama
    Historian of art, the Dutch republic and Britain, with the television series to match.
    363pts
  12. Eric Hobsbawm — ranked #1212
    Eric Hobsbawm
    His four-volume sweep from 1789 to 1991 defined how a generation read the modern age.
    0pts
  13. Tacitus — ranked #1313
    Tacitus
    Roman senator whose compressed, sceptical account of the early emperors set the tone for imperial history.
    0pts
  14. Ibn Khaldun — ranked #1414
    Ibn Khaldun
    Fourteenth-century North African scholar who effectively invented social history.
    0pts
  15. Antony Beevor — ranked #1515
    Antony Beevor
    The most widely read narrative historian of the Second World War.
    0pts

Comments 1

Barbara Tuchman won two Pulitzers without a doctorate, which is the strongest precedent an amateur has against Gibbon and Thucydides: https://youpick.best/articles/winston-churchill-ranked-many-ways

YP
ypb-team
Aug 21