What is the best season of Only Murders in the Building?

A polished debut mystery, a Broadway showstopper and a Hollywood caper all make their case in this run of cases. Which season comes out on top?

1

Season 1

The 2021 debut that introduced the trio's first podcast case in the Arconia, praised as the show's most polished mystery.

1000pts

2

Season 3

The 2023 Broadway-set season, a musical extravaganza guest-starring Meryl Streep and Paul Rudd.

887pts

3

Season 4

The 2024 season that takes the trio to Hollywood as their story gets adapted into a film.

750pts

4

Season 2

The 2022 follow-up centered on Bunny Folger's murder, home to the series' most memorable reveal.

614pts

5

Season 5

The 2025 season digging into a new Arconia death tied to the building's doorman.

450pts