You Pick BestYouPickBest

The 35 Best South American Defenders of All Time

By YPB Team

South America has forged some of the toughest and most gifted defenders in football history. From Cafu to Marcelo, who is the greatest South American defender of all time?

  1. Dani Alves — ranked #11
    Dani Alves
    Brazil's attacking right back and one of the most decorated players in football history, with more than 40 trophies including two Champions Leagues.
    1000pts
  2. Marcelo — ranked #22
    Marcelo
    Brazil's marauding left back who won five Champions Leagues with Real Madrid, one of the most dangerous attacking defenders ever.
    999pts
  3. Roberto Carlos — ranked #33
    Roberto Carlos
    Brazil's rocket-legged left back whose free kick against France in 1997 is one of football's most astonishing moments.
    999pts
  4. Diego Godin — ranked #44
    Diego Godin
    Uruguay's commanding center back who anchored Atlético Madrid's sensational 2013-14 La Liga and Champions League run.
    993pts
  5. Thiago Silva — ranked #55
    Thiago Silva
    Brazil captain and one of the best centre-backs of his generation, who won the 2021 Champions League with Chelsea after starring for Milan and PSG.
    952pts
  6. Cafu — ranked #66
    Cafu
    Brazil's relentless right back who appeared in three World Cup finals and is widely considered the greatest right back of all time.
    907pts
  7. Cristian Romero — ranked #77
    Cristian Romero
    Tottenham captain and Argentina centre-back who won the 2022 World Cup, two Copa Américas and the 2025 Europa League.
    669pts
  8. José María Giménez — ranked #88
    José María Giménez
    Atlético Madrid and Uruguay centre-back who won two La Liga titles and the 2018 Europa League under Diego Simeone.
    590pts
  9. Nicolás Otamendi — ranked #99
    Nicolás Otamendi
    Argentina centre-back who won the 2022 World Cup and two Copa Américas, plus two Premier League titles with Manchester City.
    590pts
  10. Marquinhos — ranked #1010
    Marquinhos
    PSG's long-serving captain and Brazil centre-back who won Olympic gold in 2016 and the 2025 Champions League.
    590pts
  11. Djalma Santos — ranked #1111
    Djalma Santos
    Brazil's right back who won the 1958 and 1962 World Cups and was named in the World Cup All-Star Team three times.
    590pts
  12. Gary Medel — ranked #1212
    Gary Medel
    Chile's 'Pitbull', a fierce defender and midfielder who won two Copa Américas and earned more than 160 caps.
    500pts
  13. Ivan Cordoba — ranked #1313
    Ivan Cordoba
    Colombia's solid and versatile Inter Milan center back who was one of the best defenders in Serie A in the 2000s.
    500pts
  14. Roberto Ayala — ranked #1414
    Roberto Ayala
    Argentina's commanding centre-back with 115 caps, who won two La Liga titles with Valencia and Olympic gold in 2004.
    500pts
  15. Daniel Passarella — ranked #1515
    Daniel Passarella
    Argentina's 1978 World Cup-winning captain and River Plate legend, one of the highest-scoring defenders in football history.
    500pts
  16. Walter Samuel — ranked #1616
    Walter Samuel
    'The Wall', Argentine centre-back who won the Scudetto with Roma in 2001 and five more with Inter, including the 2010 treble.
    462pts
  17. Roberto Perfumo — ranked #1717
    Roberto Perfumo
    'El Mariscal', Racing Club centre-back who won the 1967 Copa Libertadores and Intercontinental Cup, one of Argentina's finest defenders.
    462pts
  18. Silvio Marzolini — ranked #1818
    Silvio Marzolini
    Boca Juniors' elegant left back of the 1960s and a club idol, named in the All-Star Team of the 1966 World Cup.
    462pts
  19. Júnior — ranked #1919
    Júnior
    Flamengo's versatile left back and midfielder who won the 1981 Copa Libertadores and starred in Brazil's celebrated 1982 World Cup side.
    462pts
  20. Carlos Gamarra — ranked #2020
    Carlos Gamarra
    Paraguay's elegant centre-back who played at three World Cups and famously committed no fouls at France 1998.
    462pts
  21. Carlos Alberto Torres — ranked #2121
    Carlos Alberto Torres
    Brazil's 1970 World Cup-winning captain whose thunderous final goal against Italy remains the greatest team goal ever scored.
    462pts
  22. Mario Yepes — ranked #2222
    Mario Yepes
    Colombia's captain and centre-back who won the 2001 Copa América and later won Serie A with AC Milan.
    462pts
  23. Javier Zanetti — ranked #2323
    Javier Zanetti
    Inter's legendary captain who made a club-record 858 appearances, lifted the 2010 treble and earned 145 caps for Argentina.
    462pts
  24. Maicon — ranked #2424
    Maicon
    Brazil's dominant right back who was arguably the world's best in his position during Inter Milan's 2009-10 treble season.
    417pts
  25. Nílton Santos — ranked #2525
    Nílton Santos
    Botafogo's one-club 'Encyclopedia' and pioneering attacking left back who won the 1958 and 1962 World Cups with Brazil.
    417pts
  26. Lúcio — ranked #2626
    Lúcio
    Commanding Brazil centre-back who won the 2002 World Cup, captained his country and lifted the 2010 Champions League in Inter's treble.
    417pts
  27. Hilderaldo Bellini — ranked #2727
    Hilderaldo Bellini
    Vasco da Gama centre-back who captained Brazil to its first World Cup in 1958 and started the tradition of raising the trophy overhead.
    364pts
  28. Branco — ranked #2828
    Branco
    Brazil left back whose thunderous free kick beat the Netherlands in the 1994 World Cup quarter-final on the way to the title.
    364pts
  29. Mauro Ramos — ranked #2929
    Mauro Ramos
    Elegant centre-back who captained Brazil to the 1962 World Cup title and won two Copa Libertadores with Santos.
    364pts
  30. Aldair — ranked #3030
    Aldair
    Brazil's elegant centre-back who won the 1994 World Cup and spent 13 seasons at Roma, winning the 2001 Scudetto.
    0pts
  31. Paolo Montero — ranked #3131
    Paolo Montero
    Uruguay's hard-tackling centre-back who won four Serie A titles with Juventus between 1997 and 2003.
    0pts
  32. Héctor Chumpitaz — ranked #3232
    Héctor Chumpitaz
    Peru's captain and greatest defender, who led his country at the 1970 and 1978 World Cups and won the 1975 Copa América.
    0pts
  33. Elías Figueroa — ranked #3333
    Elías Figueroa
    Chile's three-time South American Footballer of the Year who is widely considered the greatest center back the continent has produced.
    0pts
  34. Oscar Ruggeri — ranked #3434
    Oscar Ruggeri
    Argentina's tough centre-back who won the 1986 World Cup and two Copa Américas and was South American Footballer of the Year in 1991.
    0pts
  35. Diego Lugano — ranked #3535
    Diego Lugano
    Uruguay's captain who led his country to fourth place at the 2010 World Cup and the 2011 Copa América title, and a São Paulo idol.
    0pts

Photo credits

Comments