You Pick BestYouPickBest

The 28 Most Controversial Video Games of All Time

By YPB Team4 votes

Senate hearings, retail recalls, refused classifications: every entry here made somebody demand a ban.

  1. Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas — ranked #11
    Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas
    The 2005 Hot Coffee minigame forced an Adults Only re-rating and pulled the game from shelves.
    1000pts
  2. The Last of Us Part II — ranked #22
    The Last of Us Part II
    Plot leaks weeks before release and a user review-bombing campaign followed the 2020 sequel, even as it won Game of the Year at The Game Awards.
    859pts
  3. Hotline Miami — ranked #33
    Hotline Miami
    A 2012 indie whose stylised massacres made critics argue about whether the player was in on the joke.
    831pts
  4. Star Wars Battlefront II — ranked #44
    Star Wars Battlefront II
    Its 2017 loot-box economy triggered government gambling inquiries in several countries.
    764pts
  5. Cyberpunk 2077 — ranked #55
    Cyberpunk 2077
    Launched in 2020 so broken on last-generation consoles that Sony pulled it from the PlayStation store.
    757pts
  6. Grand Theft Auto V — ranked #66
    Grand Theft Auto V
    An interactive torture scene in the mission By the Book drew condemnation from anti-torture charities, and Target Australia pulled the game after a 2014 petition.
    739pts
  7. Hogwarts Legacy — ranked #77
    Hogwarts Legacy
    Calls to boycott it over J.K. Rowling's views on transgender people did not stop it becoming the best-selling game of 2023 in the US.
    686pts
  8. Mortal Kombat — ranked #88
    Mortal Kombat
    Its 1992 fatalities triggered the US Senate hearings that created the ESRB.
    686pts
  9. Manhunt — ranked #99
    Manhunt
    Rockstar's stealth game scored players on brutal executions, and British papers wrongly tied it to a 2004 murder in Leicester, leading some retailers to pull it.
    632pts
  10. Doom — ranked #1010
    Doom
    Blamed by 1990s commentators for school violence and banned outright in several countries.
    632pts
  11. Hatred — ranked #1111
    Hatred
    A 2015 isometric shooter about a mass murderer that Valve pulled from Steam Greenlight, until Gabe Newell restored it a day later.
    500pts
  12. Grand Theft Auto III — ranked #1212
    Grand Theft Auto III
    Its 3D city let players kill anyone, including sex workers to take back money paid, and a 2003 Tennessee highway shooting led to a lawsuit against Rockstar.
    500pts
  13. Fallout 76 — ranked #1313
    Fallout 76
    Bethesda's online 2018 launch arrived full of bugs, and the canvas bag promised in its $200 Power Armor Edition turned out to be cheap nylon.
    462pts
  14. No Man's Sky — ranked #1414
    No Man's Sky
    Hello Games launched it in 2016 without features Sean Murray had described, and Britain's advertising watchdog investigated its Steam page before clearing it.
    417pts
  15. Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 — ranked #1515
    Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2
    The skippable 'No Russian' airport massacre mission drew international condemnation in 2009.
    417pts
  16. Death Race — ranked #1616
    Death Race
    Exidy's 1976 arcade game had players run down stick figures that turned into gravestones, prompting the first nationwide outcry over violence in video games.
    417pts
  17. Postal 2 — ranked #1717
    Postal 2
    Running With Scissors' 2003 sandbox let the Postal Dude kill anyone during a week of errands, and New Zealand banned it as objectionable.
    364pts
  18. Carmageddon — ranked #1818
    Carmageddon
    Points for running over pedestrians led British censors to refuse it a certificate, so the 1997 release swapped people for green-blooded zombies until an appeal restored them.
    364pts
  19. Wolfenstein 3D — ranked #1919
    Wolfenstein 3D
    id Software's 1992 shooter, with swastikas on the walls and Hitler as the final boss, was confiscated and banned in Germany in 1994.
    364pts
  20. Six Days in Fallujah — ranked #2020
    Six Days in Fallujah
    A recreation of a real 2004 battle, dropped by its publisher after veteran and press backlash.
    364pts
  21. Night Trap — ranked #2121
    Night Trap
    The full-motion-video horror game held up at the same 1993 Senate hearings as Mortal Kombat.
    364pts
  22. Manhunt 2 — ranked #2222
    Manhunt 2
    Rockstar's stealth-murder sequel was refused classification in Britain and initially banned.
    364pts
  23. Phantasmagoria — ranked #2323
    Phantasmagoria
    Roberta Williams' full-motion-video horror game for Sierra included a rape scene, leading Australia to refuse it classification and some US chains to refuse to stock it.
    364pts
  24. Medal of Honor (2010) — ranked #2424
    Medal of Honor (2010)
    Letting players fight as the Taliban in multiplayer drew a call for a ban from Britain's defence secretary, and EA renamed the side Opposing Force before launch.
    0pts
  25. Bully — ranked #2525
    Bully
    Before anyone had played it, Rockstar's boarding-school game was attacked as a school-violence simulator, and attorney Jack Thompson went to court to stop its release.
    0pts
  26. Mass Effect — ranked #2626
    Mass Effect
    A 2008 Fox News segment claimed BioWare's space RPG showed full nudity, and Singapore briefly banned it over a same-sex scene.
    0pts
  27. Resident Evil 5 — ranked #2727
    Resident Evil 5
    Its 2007 trailer, showing a white hero gunning down infected Black villagers in a fictional African region, set off a long argument about racism in games.
    0pts
  28. Duke Nukem 3D — ranked #2828
    Duke Nukem 3D
    Strip clubs and an adult cinema drew censorship abroad, and Brazil banned Duke Nukem 3D in 1999 after a gunman opened fire in a São Paulo cinema.
    0pts

Photo credits

Comments 1

The unflattering list, and the one Grand Theft Auto has been on longer than any other.

YP
ypb-team
Aug 25