You Pick BestYouPickBest

What is the greatest Oakland Athletics team of all time?

By YPB Team

Mustachioed dynasty clubs, Bash Brothers power and Moneyball overachievers all wore green and gold in Oakland. Decide which single season tops the rest.

  1. 1972 Oakland Athletics — ranked #11
    1972 Oakland Athletics
    First Oakland title: 93–62, then a seven-game World Series win over Cincinnati with Gene Tenace named Series MVP after four home runs.
    1000pts
  2. 1989 Oakland Athletics — ranked #22
    1989 Oakland Athletics
    99–63 champions who swept the Giants in the Bay Bridge World Series, which was halted for ten days by the Loma Prieta earthquake; Dave Stewart was Series MVP.
    913pts
  3. 1973 Oakland Athletics — ranked #33
    1973 Oakland Athletics
    Repeat champions at 94–68 who beat the Mets in seven games; Reggie Jackson won both the AL MVP and World Series MVP.
    753pts
  4. 1974 Oakland Athletics — ranked #44
    1974 Oakland Athletics
    Third straight championship, 90–72 and a five-game Series win over the Dodgers, with Catfish Hunter's Cy Young and Rollie Fingers as Series MVP.
    704pts
  5. 1988 Oakland Athletics — ranked #55
    1988 Oakland Athletics
    104–58 pennant winners with MVP Jose Canseco, the first 40-homer, 40-steal player, and Rookie of the Year Walt Weiss; the Dodgers took the World Series in five.
    583pts
  6. 1975 Oakland Athletics — ranked #66
    1975 Oakland Athletics
    Fifth consecutive AL West title with a 98–64 record, ended by a three-game ALCS sweep against Boston.
    583pts
  7. 2012 Oakland Athletics — ranked #77
    2012 Oakland Athletics
    94–68 surprise champions who clinched the AL West on the final day against Texas after trailing by 13 games in late June; Bob Melvin was Manager of the Year.
    583pts
  8. 1990 Oakland Athletics — ranked #88
    1990 Oakland Athletics
    A 103–59 pennant winner with MVP Rickey Henderson and 27-game winner Bob Welch, the Cy Young recipient; Cincinnati swept the World Series.
    583pts
  9. 2001 Oakland Athletics — ranked #99
    2001 Oakland Athletics
    102–60 wild card that led the Yankees 2–0 in the ALDS before losing in five, a series remembered for Derek Jeter's flip play.
    458pts
  10. 1992 Oakland Athletics — ranked #1010
    1992 Oakland Athletics
    96–66 division champions with Dennis Eckersley taking both the MVP and Cy Young after 51 saves; Toronto won the ALCS in six.
    458pts
  11. 2002 Oakland Athletics — ranked #1111
    2002 Oakland Athletics
    The "Moneyball" team: 103–59 with a then-AL-record 20-game winning streak, MVP Miguel Tejada and Cy Young winner Barry Zito; lost the ALDS to Minnesota.
    403pts
  12. 2000 Oakland Athletics — ranked #1212
    2000 Oakland Athletics
    91–70 AL West winners led by MVP Jason Giambi, beaten by the Yankees in a five-game ALDS.
    403pts
  13. 2006 Oakland Athletics — ranked #1313
    2006 Oakland Athletics
    93–69 AL West winners who swept Minnesota for the club's first postseason series win since 1990, then were swept by Detroit in the ALCS.
    403pts
  14. 2018 Oakland Athletics — ranked #1414
    2018 Oakland Athletics
    97–65 wild card with Khris Davis's MLB-leading 48 home runs and Matt Chapman at third; lost the Wild Card Game at Yankee Stadium.
    403pts
  15. 2020 Oakland Athletics — ranked #1515
    2020 Oakland Athletics
    36–24 AL West champions of the 60-game season, with AL Reliever of the Year Liam Hendriks closing, who beat the White Sox for a first series win since 2006 before losing the ALDS to Houston.
    403pts
  16. 1971 Oakland Athletics — ranked #1616
    1971 Oakland Athletics
    A 101–60 division winner powered by Vida Blue's MVP and Cy Young season (24 wins, 1.82 ERA); Baltimore swept them in the ALCS.
    403pts
  17. 2003 Oakland Athletics — ranked #1717
    2003 Oakland Athletics
    96–66 division champions with the Hudson-Mulder-Zito rotation, eliminated by Boston after winning the first two ALDS games.
    0pts
  18. 1981 Oakland Athletics — ranked #1818
    1981 Oakland Athletics
    Billy Martin's "Billyball" club opened 11–0, won the first-half AL West, swept Kansas City in the ALDS and lost the ALCS to the Yankees.
    0pts
  19. 2019 Oakland Athletics — ranked #1919
    2019 Oakland Athletics
    A second straight 97–65 season and wild-card berth, ended by a home Wild Card Game loss to Tampa Bay.
    0pts
  20. 2013 Oakland Athletics — ranked #2020
    2013 Oakland Athletics
    Repeat division champions at 96–66, with Josh Donaldson at third base, again eliminated by Detroit in a five-game ALDS.
    0pts

Photo credits

Comments