You Pick BestYouPickBest

What is the greatest Last Supper painting?

By YPB Team

Seven centuries of painters have set the same table, on refectory walls, in Venetian churches and once in a pop-art silkscreen. A few of these suppers draw queues every day; others hang in museums most visitors walk past.

  1. Leonardo da Vinci — ranked #11
    Leonardo da Vinci
    Leonardo's mural of about 1495–98 in the refectory of Santa Maria delle Grazie, Milan, catches the moment after Jesus says one of the twelve will betray him; a 20-year restoration ended in 1999.
    1000pts
  2. Paolo Veronese — ranked #22
    Paolo Veronese
    Veronese painted it in 1573 as a Last Supper for the Dominicans of Santi Giovanni e Paolo, Venice, and renamed it The Feast in the House of Levi after the Inquisition questioned its jesters and soldiers; it hangs in the Gallerie dell'Accademia.
    712pts
  3. Tintoretto (San Giorgio Maggiore) — ranked #33
    Tintoretto (San Giorgio Maggiore)
    Jacopo Tintoretto's canvas of 1592–94 in the Basilica di San Giorgio Maggiore, Venice, runs the table on a steep diagonal and fills the dark room with servants and ghostly angels.
    680pts
  4. Salvador Dalí — ranked #44
    Salvador Dalí
    Dalí's The Sacrament of the Last Supper, completed in 1955 after nine months of work and given to the National Gallery of Art in Washington, sets a translucent Christ inside a glass dodecahedron above a Catalan bay.
    645pts
  5. Cosimo Rosselli — ranked #55
    Cosimo Rosselli
    Cosimo Rosselli and Biagio d'Antonio painted this 1481–82 fresco on the wall of the Sistine Chapel, with windows behind the table showing the Agony in the Garden, the Arrest and the Crucifixion.
    645pts
  6. Dieric Bouts — ranked #66
    Dieric Bouts
    The central panel of Dieric Bouts's Altarpiece of the Holy Sacrament, 1464–68, back in its chapel at St Peter's Church, Leuven, shows Jesus blessing the host in a Flemish hall.
    645pts
  7. Peter Paul Rubens — ranked #77
    Peter Paul Rubens
    Rubens painted it around 1630–32 for St Rumbold's Cathedral in Mechelen; now in the Pinacoteca di Brera, Milan, it shows Judas turning toward the viewer with a dog at his feet.
    645pts
  8. Ghirlandaio (Ognissanti) — ranked #88
    Ghirlandaio (Ognissanti)
    Domenico Ghirlandaio's 1480 fresco in the refectory of Ognissanti, Florence, seats Judas alone on the near side of the table against a garden full of birds.
    604pts
  9. Andy Warhol — ranked #99
    Andy Warhol
    Warhol's 1986 Last Supper series of silkscreen paintings and prints after Leonardo's mural, his last major body of work, was first shown in Milan in 1987 near Santa Maria delle Grazie.
    604pts
  10. Andrea del Castagno — ranked #1010
    Andrea del Castagno
    Andrea del Castagno's fresco of about 1447 in the former convent of Sant'Apollonia, Florence, places a dark-bearded Judas on the near side of the table before a wall of patterned marble panels.
    556pts
  11. Giotto — ranked #1111
    Giotto
    Giotto's fresco of about 1305 in the Scrovegni Chapel, Padua, part of his Passion cycle, shows the apostles from behind as well as in front and Judas reaching into the same dish as Jesus.
    500pts
  12. Andrea del Sarto — ranked #1212
    Andrea del Sarto
    Andrea del Sarto finished this fresco in the refectory of San Salvi, Florence, in the 1520s; Vasari wrote that in 1529 the men sent to raze the buildings outside the walls wrecked the convent but stopped at this painting.
    500pts
  13. Emil Nolde — ranked #1313
    Emil Nolde
    Emil Nolde's 1909 oil in the National Gallery of Denmark, Copenhagen, packs the apostles' mask-like faces in raw colour around Jesus holding the cup.
    500pts
  14. Pietro Lorenzetti — ranked #1414
    Pietro Lorenzetti
    Pietro Lorenzetti's fresco of about 1320 in the Lower Basilica of San Francesco, Assisi, puts the meal in a hexagonal loggia next to a kitchen where a dog licks the last scraps from a plate and a cat dozes by the fire.
    500pts
  15. Philippe de Champaigne — ranked #1515
    Philippe de Champaigne
    Philippe de Champaigne's canvas of about 1652 for the high altar of Port-Royal-des-Champs abbey, now in the Louvre, sets the apostles against a plain dark wall with a ewer and basin in front.
    500pts
  16. Ghirlandaio (San Marco) — ranked #1616
    Ghirlandaio (San Marco)
    Ghirlandaio's second Florentine Last Supper, frescoed around 1486 in the guest refectory of the San Marco convent, repeats the Ognissanti layout with Judas set apart and adds a cat sitting at his side.
    500pts
  17. Jacopo Bassano — ranked #1717
    Jacopo Bassano
    Jacopo Bassano's canvas of about 1546–48 in the Galleria Borghese, Rome, crowds barefoot, sunburnt apostles round a table with a lamb's head on the platter.
    500pts
  18. Juan de Juanes — ranked #1818
    Juan de Juanes
    Juan de Juanes's panel of about 1562, painted in Valencia and now in the Prado, shows Jesus raising the host above a chalice modelled on the Holy Chalice of Valencia Cathedral.
    440pts
  19. Hans Holbein the Younger — ranked #1919
    Hans Holbein the Younger
    Holbein's panel of about 1524–25 in the Kunstmuseum Basel was hacked apart in the Basel iconoclasm of 1529 and glued back together, so only nine apostles remain.
    440pts
  20. Tintoretto (San Marcuola) — ranked #2020
    Tintoretto (San Marcuola)
    Tintoretto's 1547 canvas in the Venetian church of San Marcuola, one of his first Last Suppers, flanks the table with female figures of Faith and Charity.
    440pts
  21. Duccio — ranked #2121
    Duccio
    A panel from the back of Duccio's Maestà altarpiece, commissioned by Siena in 1308 and now in the Museo dell'Opera del Duomo, with John asleep against Jesus and five apostles seated with their backs to the viewer.
    440pts
  22. Titian (El Escorial) — ranked #2222
    Titian (El Escorial)
    Titian and his workshop painted it in 1557–64 for Philip II, and it reached the monastery of El Escorial in 1565, where it still hangs.
    440pts
  23. Plautilla Nelli — ranked #2323
    Plautilla Nelli
    Sister Plautilla Nelli painted this canvas of about seven metres for the refectory of her Dominican convent of Santa Caterina, Florence; restored in the 2010s, it hangs in the Santa Maria Novella museum.
    0pts
  24. Giorgio Vasari — ranked #2424
    Giorgio Vasari
    Giorgio Vasari painted this panel in 1546 for the Florentine convent of Le Murate; kept at Santa Croce, it spent hours under water in the 1966 flood and went back on show there after a restoration completed in 2016.
    0pts
  25. Taddeo Gaddi — ranked #2525
    Taddeo Gaddi
    Taddeo Gaddi's fresco of the mid-1300s fills the end wall of the old refectory of Santa Croce, Florence, beneath his Tree of Life.
    0pts
  26. Stanley Spencer — ranked #2626
    Stanley Spencer
    Stanley Spencer's 1920 canvas, which hangs in the Stanley Spencer Gallery, Cookham, sets the meal in a malthouse in his village, with the apostles' bare feet stretched out under the table.
    0pts
  27. Lucas Cranach the Elder — ranked #2727
    Lucas Cranach the Elder
    The central panel of the Wittenberg Altarpiece by Lucas Cranach the Elder and his son, unveiled in 1547 in St Mary's Church, Wittenberg, places Martin Luther among the apostles.
    0pts

Photo credits

Comments