You Pick BestYouPickBest

What is the greatest Cleveland Guardians team of all time?

By YPB Team

Two champions, several October heartbreaks and a few clubs that simply won a lot of baseball. Pick the season you would send back for another shot.

  1. 1954 Cleveland Indians — ranked #11
    1954 Cleveland Indians
    Team that set an American League record with 111 wins before the New York Giants swept it in the World Series.
    1000pts
  2. 2016 Cleveland Indians — ranked #22
    2016 Cleveland Indians
    Terry Francona's team that won the AL pennant and lost Game 7 of the World Series to the Chicago Cubs in extra innings.
    999pts
  3. 1995 Cleveland Indians — ranked #33
    1995 Cleveland Indians
    Team that went 100-44 in a strike-shortened season and lost the World Series to the Atlanta Braves in six games.
    950pts
  4. 1948 Cleveland Indians — ranked #44
    1948 Cleveland Indians
    Lou Boudreau's team that won a one-game playoff in Boston and then beat the Boston Braves in the World Series.
    896pts
  5. 1997 Cleveland Indians — ranked #55
    1997 Cleveland Indians
    Team that reached the World Series and lost Game 7 to the Florida Marlins in 11 innings.
    750pts
  6. 2007 Cleveland Indians — ranked #66
    2007 Cleveland Indians
    Team that won 96 games and led the ALCS 3-1 before losing to the Boston Red Sox in seven games.
    625pts
  7. 2017 Cleveland Indians — ranked #77
    2017 Cleveland Indians
    Team that won 102 games and put together a 22-game winning streak, an American League record.
    625pts
  8. 1996 Cleveland Indians — ranked #88
    1996 Cleveland Indians
    Team that won 99 games and a second straight AL Central title before losing the ALDS to Baltimore.
    624pts
  9. 1920 Cleveland Indians — ranked #99
    1920 Cleveland Indians
    Tris Speaker's team that beat the Brooklyn Robins to win the franchise's first World Series.
    492pts
  10. 2025 Cleveland Guardians — ranked #1010
    2025 Cleveland Guardians
    Team that came back from more than 15 games behind Detroit in July to win the AL Central.
    433pts
  11. 2022 Cleveland Guardians — ranked #1111
    2022 Cleveland Guardians
    First team under the Guardians name, which won the AL Central and a Wild Card Series against Tampa Bay.
    0pts
  12. 1999 Cleveland Indians — ranked #1212
    1999 Cleveland Indians
    Team that won 97 games and scored over 1,000 runs before losing the ALDS to Boston.
    0pts
  13. 2024 Cleveland Guardians — ranked #1313
    2024 Cleveland Guardians
    Stephen Vogt's first team, which won the AL Central and reached the ALCS against the New York Yankees.
    0pts

Photo credits

Comments