You Pick BestYouPickBest

What is the best Paul Mescal movie?

By YPB Team

From a quiet indie heartbreaker to a Roman Colosseum epic, Mescal's filmography swings between intimate and spectacular. Which performance wins your vote?

  1. Gladiator II — ranked #11
    Gladiator II
    Ridley Scott's 2024 epic sequel in which Mescal steps into the Colosseum as Lucius, the grandson of Marcus Aurelius, in a high-octane follow-up to the 2000 original.
    1000pts
  2. Aftersun — ranked #22
    Aftersun
    A hauntingly intimate 2022 A24 drama in which Mescal plays a young father on holiday with his daughter, with a devastating emotional undercurrent that announced him as a major talent.
    777pts
  3. All of Us Strangers — ranked #33
    All of Us Strangers
    Andrew Haigh's 2023 supernatural romance in which Mescal and Andrew Scott play two lonely men falling in love while grappling with grief and memory.
    733pts
  4. Foe — ranked #44
    Foe
    A 2023 science-fiction drama set in the near future in which Mescal and Saoirse Ronan play a couple torn apart by a government programme that sends him to an orbiting space station.
    555pts
  5. The Lost Daughter — ranked #55
    The Lost Daughter
    Maggie Gyllenhaal's 2021 directorial debut, in which Mescal plays Will, a young Irish beach attendant who befriends Olivia Colman's solitary professor on a Greek holiday.
    385pts
  6. Hamnet — ranked #66
    Hamnet
    Chloé Zhao's 2025 adaptation of Maggie O'Farrell's novel, with Mescal as William Shakespeare opposite Jessie Buckley as a couple grieving the death of their son.
    385pts
  7. God's Creatures — ranked #77
    God's Creatures
    A 2022 Irish fishing-village drama in which Mescal plays Brian, a son returning home whose mother, played by Emily Watson, lies to protect him from an accusation.
    385pts
  8. The History of Sound — ranked #88
    The History of Sound
    Oliver Hermanus's 2025 romantic drama in which Mescal and Josh O'Connor play music students who travel rural New England recording folk songs after the First World War.
    0pts
  9. Carmen — ranked #99
    Carmen
    Benjamin Millepied's 2022 dance-driven reimagining of the opera, with Mescal as Aidan, a troubled former Marine who flees to Los Angeles with Melissa Barrera's Carmen.
    0pts

Comments