You Pick BestYouPickBest

The 29 Greatest Modal Jazz Albums of All Time

By YPB Team

Modal jazz replaced chord changes with scales and modes, opening vast new spaces for improvisation. From Kind of Blue to Maiden Voyage, these records permanently changed how musicians think about harmony.

  1. Kind of Blue — ranked #11
    Kind of Blue
    Miles Davis's 1959 album — the Rosetta Stone of modal jazz.
    1000pts
  2. A Love Supreme — ranked #22
    A Love Supreme
    John Coltrane's 1964 modal spiritual suite — the genre's ultimate statement.
    694pts
  3. Milestones — ranked #33
    Milestones
    Miles Davis's 1958 album with his sextet, including Cannonball Adderley and John Coltrane, whose title track was his first full step into modal jazz.
    661pts
  4. Search for the New Land — ranked #44
    Search for the New Land
    Lee Morgan recorded this session in 1964, before The Sidewinder came out, but Blue Note shelved it for two years; the modal title track runs over 15 minutes.
    535pts
  5. Journey in Satchidananda — ranked #55
    Journey in Satchidananda
    Alice Coltrane's 1971 album with Pharoah Sanders, Cecil McBee and Rashied Ali sets her harp over drones and modal vamps inspired by her spiritual teacher.
    480pts
  6. Speak No Evil — ranked #66
    Speak No Evil
    Wayne Shorter's 1964 modal post-bop classic with Herbie Hancock and Freddie Hubbard.
    480pts
  7. Night Dreamer — ranked #77
    Night Dreamer
    Wayne Shorter's 1964 Blue Note album, with trumpeter Lee Morgan, features six of his originals, including the modal waltz that gives the record its name.
    480pts
  8. Rosewood — ranked #88
    Rosewood
    Woody Shaw's major-label debut, recorded in 1977 and released by Columbia in 1978, brought his fourths-based, post-Coltrane modal trumpet style to a wider audience.
    480pts
  9. Blackstone Legacy — ranked #99
    Blackstone Legacy
    Woody Shaw's 1970 modal jazz masterpiece — post-Coltrane trumpet at its boldest.
    480pts
  10. Karma — ranked #1010
    Karma
    Pharoah Sanders' 1969 Impulse! album is built around the 32-minute modal chant 'The Creator Has a Master Plan' and became a founding record of spiritual jazz.
    416pts
  11. My Favorite Things — ranked #1111
    My Favorite Things
    John Coltrane's 1961 album reimagining the Broadway tune as modal exploration.
    416pts
  12. Live at the Village Vanguard — ranked #1212
    Live at the Village Vanguard
    John Coltrane's 1961 live recordings — modal jazz stretching into new dimensions.
    416pts
  13. Sketches of Spain — ranked #1313
    Sketches of Spain
    Miles Davis and arranger Gil Evans recorded this 1960 album of Spanish-inspired music, including the Concierto de Aranjuez, with static, scale-based harmonies that extend Kind of Blue.
    416pts
  14. Unity — ranked #1414
    Unity
    Organist Larry Young's 1966 Blue Note album with Woody Shaw, Joe Henderson and Elvin Jones applied Coltrane-style modal playing to the Hammond B-3.
    341pts
  15. Juju — ranked #1515
    Juju
    Wayne Shorter's 1965 Blue Note album sets his tenor against McCoy Tyner, Reggie Workman and Elvin Jones, all veterans of John Coltrane's bands, on hypnotic modal originals.
    341pts
  16. Everybody Digs Bill Evans — ranked #1616
    Everybody Digs Bill Evans
    Bill Evans's 1959 Riverside trio album includes 'Peace Piece', a solo improvisation over two repeated chords that foreshadowed the mood of Kind of Blue.
    341pts
  17. Explorations — ranked #1717
    Explorations
    Bill Evans Trio's 1961 modal piano trio triumph with Scott LaFaro.
    341pts
  18. The Real McCoy — ranked #1818
    The Real McCoy
    McCoy Tyner's 1967 Blue Note debut, made after he left Coltrane's quartet, with Joe Henderson, Ron Carter and Elvin Jones.
    340pts
  19. Empyrean Isles — ranked #1919
    Empyrean Isles
    Herbie Hancock's 1964 Blue Note quartet date with Freddie Hubbard, Ron Carter and Tony Williams includes 'Cantaloupe Island' and the open-ended modal workout 'The Egg'.
    250pts
  20. Maiden Voyage — ranked #2020
    Maiden Voyage
    Herbie Hancock's 1965 Blue Note — modal jazz at its most beautiful.
    250pts
  21. Out to Lunch! — ranked #2121
    Out to Lunch!
    Eric Dolphy's 1964 avant-modal masterpiece — unlike anything before or since.
    250pts
  22. Mode for Joe — ranked #2222
    Mode for Joe
    Joe Henderson's 1966 Blue Note — modal hard bop with his distinctive twist.
    250pts
  23. Sahara — ranked #2323
    Sahara
    McCoy Tyner's first Milestone album, recorded in January 1972, adds African and Eastern colour to modal jazz, with Tyner also playing koto, flute and percussion.
    250pts
  24. Africa/Brass — ranked #2424
    Africa/Brass
    John Coltrane's first Impulse! album (1961) places his quartet inside a 21-piece band with French horns and euphonium, centred on the 16-minute modal piece 'Africa'.
    250pts
  25. Inner Urge — ranked #2525
    Inner Urge
    Recorded in November 1964 and issued in 1966, Joe Henderson's quartet date with McCoy Tyner and Elvin Jones opens with its brooding modal title track.
    0pts
  26. In a Silent Way — ranked #2626
    In a Silent Way
    Recorded in one February 1969 session and edited by producer Teo Macero, Miles Davis's album floats long, static grooves and is widely seen as his first fusion record.
    0pts
  27. Ezz-thetics — ranked #2727
    Ezz-thetics
    George Russell's 1961 Riverside sextet album with Eric Dolphy puts his Lydian Chromatic Concept into practice on pieces such as 'Lydiot' and Miles Davis's 'Nardis'.
    0pts
  28. Crescent — ranked #2828
    Crescent
    John Coltrane's classic quartet recorded this 1964 Impulse! album of originals, a calmer prelude to A Love Supreme, with Jimmy Garrison's long bass solo on 'Lonnie's Lament'.
    0pts
  29. Impressions — ranked #2929
    Impressions
    Released in 1963, this Impulse! album mixes Village Vanguard live recordings and studio tracks, led by John Coltrane's long solo on the modal title tune.
    0pts

Photo credits
  • Search for the New Land cover — Blue Note, rights holder
  • Journey in Satchidananda cover — Impulse!, rights holder
  • Night Dreamer cover — Blue Note, rights holder
  • Rosewood cover — Columbia, rights holder
  • Karma cover — impulse!, rights holder
  • My Favorite Things cover — Atlantic, rights holder
  • Sketches of Spain cover — Columbia, rights holder
  • Unity cover — Blue Note, rights holder
  • Juju cover — Blue Note, rights holder
  • Everybody Digs Bill Evans cover — Riverside, rights holder
  • Empyrean Isles cover — Blue Note, rights holder
  • Sahara cover — Milestone, rights holder
  • Africa/Brass cover — impulse!, rights holder
  • Inner Urge cover — Blue Note, rights holder
  • In a Silent Way cover — Columbia, rights holder
  • Ezz-thetics cover — Riverside, rights holder
  • Crescent cover — impulse!, rights holder
  • Impressions cover — impulse!, rights holder

Comments 1

Milestones traded chord sequences for a scale and a lot of room in 1958; My Favorite Things used the same freedom to run fourteen minutes: https://youpick.best/articles/miles-davis-vs-john-coltrane-ranked

YP
ypb-team
Sep 6