You Pick BestYouPickBest

What is the best Elizabeth Strout book?

By YPB Team

A Pulitzer winner, a Booker shortlistee and a quiet debut about a mother and daughter: some of these Maine and Illinois stories run through the same characters for decades.

  1. Amy and Isabelle — ranked #11
    Amy and Isabelle
    Strout's 1998 debut novel about a mother and her teenage daughter in a small New England mill town, shortlisted for the Orange Prize.
  2. Abide with Me — ranked #22
    Abide with Me
    A 2006 novel about a grieving minister and his small Maine congregation in the late 1950s.
  3. Olive Kitteridge — ranked #33
    Olive Kitteridge
    A 2008 novel in thirteen linked stories centred on a retired Maine schoolteacher, winner of the 2009 Pulitzer Prize for Fiction.
  4. The Burgess Boys — ranked #44
    The Burgess Boys
    A 2013 novel about two lawyer brothers from Maine drawn home when their nephew gets into trouble.
  5. My Name Is Lucy Barton — ranked #55
    My Name Is Lucy Barton
    A 2016 novel narrated by a writer recalling her mother's visit to her hospital bed, longlisted for the Man Booker Prize.
  6. Anything Is Possible — ranked #66
    Anything Is Possible
    A 2017 book of linked stories set in Amgash, Illinois, the hometown of Lucy Barton.
  7. Olive, Again — ranked #77
    Olive, Again
    The 2019 sequel to Olive Kitteridge, following Olive into her second marriage and old age.
  8. Oh William! — ranked #88
    Oh William!
    A 2021 novel in which Lucy Barton travels with her ex-husband William to uncover his family's past, shortlisted for the 2022 Booker Prize.
  9. Lucy by the Sea — ranked #99
    Lucy by the Sea
    A 2022 novel in which Lucy Barton leaves New York for coastal Maine with William at the start of the pandemic.
  10. Tell Me Everything — ranked #1010
    Tell Me Everything
    A 2024 novel that brings Olive Kitteridge and Lucy Barton together in the town of Crosby, Maine.
  11. The Things We Never Say — ranked #1111
    The Things We Never Say
    A 2026 novel about Artie Dam, a schoolteacher living with the secrets he and others keep, shortlisted for the 2026 Booker Prize.

Photo credits

Comments