What is the best CW teen drama?

Vampires, small-town secrets, murder mysteries, and superhero origins collide here, spanning the soapy, the supernatural, and the surprisingly heartfelt. Which one wins?

1

Gossip Girl

The glossy 2007 saga of Manhattan's privileged Upper East Side teenagers and their secrets.

1000pts

2

The Vampire Diaries

A supernatural romance about a young woman caught between two vampire brothers.

876pts

3

One Tree Hill

A long-running drama about two half-brothers, basketball, and small-town life.

733pts

4

Veronica Mars

A teen-noir mystery about a sharp-witted high-school student moonlighting as a private eye.

733pts

5

All American

A sports drama inspired by the life of NFL player Spencer Paysinger.

733pts

6

90210

The 2008 reboot of Beverly Hills, 90210 following a new generation of West Beverly High students.

681pts

7

Nikita

An action drama about a rogue assassin waging war against the agency that trained her.

619pts

8

Riverdale

A dark, stylized reimagining of the Archie Comics characters in a murder-mystery town.

619pts

9

Smallville

The origin-story series following a young Clark Kent before he became Superman.

619pts

10

The Originals

A Vampire Diaries spin-off centered on the original vampire family in New Orleans.

545pts

11

The Secret Circle

A supernatural teen drama about a girl who discovers she belongs to a coven of witches.

454pts

12

Hart of Dixie

A charming small-town dramedy about a New York doctor relocating to rural Alabama.

454pts

13

Supernatural

Two brothers hunt demons and monsters across America in this long-running cult favorite.

454pts