What is the best Carrie Underwood album?

Debut blockbusters, dark storytelling turns, and heartfelt detours map her whole journey so far. Which era stands tallest?

1

Some Hearts

Her blockbuster 2005 debut featuring 'Jesus, Take the Wheel' and 'Before He Cheats.'

1000pts

2

Blown Away

Her acclaimed 2012 album with the dramatic title track and 'Two Black Cadillacs.'

888pts

3

Storyteller

Her 2015 album featuring 'Smoke Break' and 'Church Bells.'

721pts

4

My Gift

Her 2020 Christmas album of holiday classics and originals.

721pts

5

Carnival Ride

Her chart-topping 2007 sophomore album with hits like 'So Small.'

577pts

6

Cry Pretty

Her bold 2018 album as co-producer, led by the soaring title track.

577pts

7

My Savior

Her 2021 gospel album of beloved hymns.

577pts

8

Denim & Rhinestones

Her glittering 2022 return to upbeat country-pop.

577pts