You Pick BestYouPickBest

Top 24 Benedict Cumberbatch Performances of All Time

By YPB Team

Whether playing a cold genius, a wounded romantic, or a supernatural guardian of the universe, the depth and range here is hard to argue with. Which performance stands alone?

  1. Sherlock — ranked #11
    Sherlock
    The BBC hit series (2010-2017) in which Cumberbatch's hyper-rational, sardonic Sherlock Holmes became a global phenomenon.
    1000pts
  2. The Power of the Dog — ranked #22
    The Power of the Dog
    The 2021 Jane Campion psychological Western in which Cumberbatch delivers a riveting portrayal of a repressed Montana rancher.
    981pts
  3. Avengers: Infinity War — ranked #33
    Avengers: Infinity War
    The 2018 Marvel crossover in which Doctor Strange faces the impossible choice of saving the universe from Thanos.
    763pts
  4. Star Trek Into Darkness — ranked #44
    Star Trek Into Darkness
    The 2013 J.J. Abrams sci-fi sequel in which Cumberbatch plays the ruthless superhuman terrorist revealed to be Khan.
    722pts
  5. The Courier — ranked #55
    The Courier
    The 2020 Cold War spy thriller in which Cumberbatch plays Greville Wynne, an ordinary British businessman who became an unlikely CIA spy.
    611pts
  6. The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug — ranked #66
    The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug
    The 2013 Peter Jackson sequel in which Cumberbatch voices and performs through motion capture the dragon Smaug, guarding the treasure of Erebor.
    559pts
  7. Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy — ranked #77
    Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy
    The 2011 Cold War thriller in which Cumberbatch plays Peter Guillam, George Smiley's loyal lieutenant, sent to steal files from inside the Circus.
    500pts
  8. The Hollow Crown: Richard III — ranked #88
    The Hollow Crown: Richard III
    The 2016 BBC Shakespeare adaptation in which Cumberbatch plays Richard III, the scheming, charismatic king who murders his way to the English throne.
    500pts
  9. Patrick Melrose — ranked #99
    Patrick Melrose
    The 2018 Sky Atlantic miniseries in which Cumberbatch gives a harrowing portrayal of a British aristocrat battling addiction and childhood trauma.
    500pts
  10. 1917 — ranked #1010
    1917
    The 2019 Sam Mendes single-take WWI epic in which Cumberbatch plays General Erinmore, who dispatches two soldiers on a critical mission.
    433pts
  11. The Fifth Estate — ranked #1111
    The Fifth Estate
    The 2013 drama in which Cumberbatch plays WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange, capturing his accent, white hair and restless intensity.
    433pts
  12. Frankenstein — ranked #1212
    Frankenstein
    Danny Boyle's 2011 National Theatre production in which Cumberbatch alternated as the Creature and Victor Frankenstein with Jonny Lee Miller, sharing an Olivier Award.
    433pts
  13. Brexit: The Uncivil War — ranked #1313
    Brexit: The Uncivil War
    The 2019 Channel 4 and HBO film in which Cumberbatch plays strategist Dominic Cummings, the mind behind the Vote Leave campaign.
    433pts
  14. Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness — ranked #1414
    Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness
    The 2022 Marvel horror-tinged sequel in which Strange navigates parallel universes to confront evil versions of himself.
    357pts
  15. The Imitation Game — ranked #1515
    The Imitation Game
    The 2014 biopic in which Cumberbatch plays Alan Turing, the genius mathematician who cracked the Enigma code during WWII.
    357pts
  16. August: Osage County — ranked #1616
    August: Osage County
    The 2013 ensemble drama in which Cumberbatch plays the troubled Little Charles Aiken amid a dysfunctional Oklahoma family reunion.
    357pts
  17. Atonement — ranked #1717
    Atonement
    The 2007 Joe Wright period drama in which Cumberbatch plays Paul Marshall, a wealthy chocolate heir with menacing intentions.
    357pts
  18. Doctor Strange — ranked #1818
    Doctor Strange
    The 2016 Marvel origin story in which Cumberbatch plays a brilliant but arrogant surgeon who becomes the Sorcerer Supreme.
    357pts
  19. Hawking — ranked #1919
    Hawking
    The 2004 BBC television film in which a young Cumberbatch plays Stephen Hawking at Cambridge as motor neurone disease takes hold, his first major leading role.
    269pts
  20. Eric — ranked #2020
    Eric
    The 2024 Netflix limited series in which Cumberbatch plays Vincent, a troubled New York puppeteer in the 1980s whose son goes missing.
    167pts
  21. 12 Years a Slave — ranked #2121
    12 Years a Slave
    The 2013 Steve McQueen historical drama in which Cumberbatch plays William Ford, a slaveholder with a tormented conscience.
    167pts
  22. The Electrical Life of Louis Wain — ranked #2222
    The Electrical Life of Louis Wain
    The 2021 biographical film in which Cumberbatch plays Louis Wain, the eccentric artist famous for his whimsical cat illustrations.
    167pts
  23. The Mauritanian — ranked #2323
    The Mauritanian
    The 2021 legal drama in which Cumberbatch plays military prosecutor Stuart Couch, who refuses to build a case on testimony extracted by torture at Guantánamo.
    167pts
  24. Parade's End — ranked #2424
    Parade's End
    The 2012 BBC and HBO miniseries in which Cumberbatch plays Christopher Tietjens, a rigidly principled Tory aristocrat whose world collapses around the First World War.
    167pts

Photo credits

Comments 1

Into Darkness took $228.8 million in North America, behind only the 2009 film, and the casting is argued over to this day: https://youpick.best/articles/star-trek-ranked-many-ways

YP
ypb-team
Aug 21