You Pick BestYouPickBest

What is the best baseball city in America?

By YPB Team

Ballpark pedigree, pennant history and sheer fan devotion all count here. Old brick parks, new downtown stadiums, and one or two towns where the whole city plans around first pitch.

  1. St. Louis — ranked #11
    St. Louis
    One team, 11 World Series titles for the Cardinals, and a famously knowledgeable crowd at Busch Stadium.
    1000pts
  2. Cleveland — ranked #22
    Cleveland
    A loyal Guardians following with a long history, from Bob Feller to the 1948 title and the near-miss 2016 Series.
    944pts
  3. San Francisco — ranked #33
    San Francisco
    Giants baseball on the bay at Oracle Park, from Willie Mays to three titles in the 2010s.
    881pts
  4. Boston — ranked #44
    Boston
    Red Sox country, where Fenway Park has stood since 1912 and the 2004 curse-breaking title is civic scripture.
    852pts
  5. Kansas City — ranked #55
    Kansas City
    Royals fans backed back-to-back pennants in 2014 and 2015 and a 1985 title in a small, passionate market.
    809pts
  6. Baltimore — ranked #66
    Baltimore
    Camden Yards launched the retro ballpark era, and the Orioles gave the city Cal Ripken Jr. and the Iron Man streak.
    787pts
  7. Seattle — ranked #77
    Seattle
    The Mariners drew huge crowds at T-Mobile Park, with Ken Griffey Jr. and Ichiro as city icons.
    713pts
  8. Cincinnati — ranked #88
    Cincinnati
    The home of the first professional team, the 1869 Red Stockings, and the Big Red Machine of the 1970s.
    629pts
  9. Philadelphia — ranked #99
    Philadelphia
    Phillies fans fill Citizens Bank Park with some of the loudest, hardest-to-please crowds in the sport.
    533pts
  10. Atlanta — ranked #1010
    Atlanta
    The Braves' 14 straight division titles in the 1990s and 2021 World Series win built a Southern baseball town.
    533pts
  11. Chicago — ranked #1111
    Chicago
    Two teams, the Cubs at Wrigley Field and the White Sox on the South Side, and a ballpark culture older than most leagues.
    533pts
  12. New York — ranked #1212
    New York
    Home of the Yankees and Mets, with 27 Yankees titles and a century of subway series.
    532pts
  13. Houston — ranked #1313
    Houston
    The Astros turned a hot, football-first city into a pennant-winning baseball market.
    532pts
  14. Detroit — ranked #1414
    Detroit
    Tigers baseball since 1901, from Ty Cobb to Al Kaline, played at Comerica Park downtown.
    420pts
  15. Milwaukee — ranked #1515
    Milwaukee
    Brewers fans tailgate harder than anyone at American Family Field, and the city has loved baseball since the Braves arrived in 1953.
    286pts
  16. San Diego — ranked #1616
    San Diego
    Padres baseball under the sun at Petco Park, with Tony Gwynn as the city's enduring hero.
    286pts
  17. Pittsburgh — ranked #1717
    Pittsburgh
    The Pirates, PNC Park's skyline view and Roberto Clemente's legacy keep a rust belt town devoted to baseball.
    286pts
  18. Los Angeles — ranked #1818
    Los Angeles
    Dodger Stadium, Vin Scully and Fernando-mania make the Dodgers the West Coast's biggest baseball draw.
    0pts

Photo credits

Comments