You Pick BestYouPickBest

What is the best Andy Garcia movie?

By YPB Team

Mobsters, cops and casino bosses fill most of this list, but there is room for a musical, a painter biopic and a Havana story he directed himself. Some earned him awards talk; others became cable-TV staples.

  1. Confidence — ranked #11
    Confidence
    James Foley's 2003 con-artist thriller with Garcia as federal agent Gunther Butan.
    1000pts
  2. The Godfather Part III — ranked #22
    The Godfather Part III
    Francis Ford Coppola's 1990 sequel in which Garcia plays Vincent Mancini, a role that earned him an Oscar nomination.
    953pts
  3. Modigliani — ranked #33
    Modigliani
    Mick Davis's 2004 biopic with Garcia in the title role of painter Amedeo Modigliani in 1919 Paris.
    900pts
  4. Ocean's Eleven — ranked #44
    Ocean's Eleven
    Steven Soderbergh's 2001 heist film with Garcia as Las Vegas casino owner Terry Benedict.
    900pts
  5. Things to Do in Denver When You're Dead — ranked #55
    Things to Do in Denver When You're Dead
    Gary Fleder's 1995 crime film with Garcia as ex-gangster Jimmy the Saint, pulled back for one last job.
    812pts
  6. Smokin' Aces — ranked #66
    Smokin' Aces
    Joe Carnahan's 2006 action thriller with Garcia as FBI deputy director Stanley Locke.
    811pts
  7. City Island — ranked #77
    City Island
    Raymond De Felitta's 2009 family comedy with Garcia as Bronx corrections officer Vince Rizzo, which he also produced.
    750pts
  8. Ocean's Thirteen — ranked #88
    Ocean's Thirteen
    Steven Soderbergh's 2007 sequel in which Garcia's Terry Benedict teams up with Danny Ocean's crew.
    680pts
  9. Mamma Mia! Here We Go Again — ranked #99
    Mamma Mia! Here We Go Again
    Ol Parker's 2018 musical sequel with Garcia as hotel manager Fernando Cienfuegos opposite Cher.
    680pts
  10. The Untouchables — ranked #1010
    The Untouchables
    Brian De Palma's 1987 Prohibition drama with Garcia as sharpshooting agent George Stone alongside Kevin Costner and Sean Connery.
    600pts
  11. Desperate Measures — ranked #1111
    Desperate Measures
    Barbet Schroeder's 1998 thriller with Garcia as a San Francisco cop whose son needs a bone marrow donor played by Michael Keaton.
    600pts
  12. 8 Million Ways to Die — ranked #1212
    8 Million Ways to Die
    Hal Ashby's 1986 crime thriller in which Garcia plays drug dealer Angel Maldonado opposite Jeff Bridges.
    600pts
  13. Black Rain — ranked #1313
    Black Rain
    Ridley Scott's 1989 thriller set in Osaka with Garcia as detective Charlie Vincent, partner to Michael Douglas.
    508pts
  14. When a Man Loves a Woman — ranked #1414
    When a Man Loves a Woman
    Luis Mandoki's 1994 drama with Garcia as airline pilot Michael Green, husband of Meg Ryan's alcoholic school counselor.
    508pts
  15. Book Club — ranked #1515
    Book Club
    Bill Holderman's 2018 comedy with Garcia as pilot Mitchell, who romances Diane Keaton's character.
    508pts
  16. Jennifer 8 — ranked #1616
    Jennifer 8
    Bruce Robinson's 1992 thriller with Garcia as detective John Berlin hunting a serial killer, co-starring Uma Thurman.
    507pts
  17. Hero — ranked #1717
    Hero
    Stephen Frears's 1992 comedy with Garcia as John Bubber, a drifter who takes credit for Dustin Hoffman's character's rescue.
    507pts
  18. For Greater Glory — ranked #1818
    For Greater Glory
    Dean Wright's 2012 historical drama with Garcia as General Enrique Gorostieta in Mexico's Cristero War.
    400pts
  19. The Lost City — ranked #1919
    The Lost City
    Garcia's 2005 first fiction feature as director, in which he also stars as a Havana nightclub owner during the Cuban Revolution.
    400pts
  20. Ocean's Twelve — ranked #2020
    Ocean's Twelve
    Steven Soderbergh's 2004 sequel in which Garcia's Terry Benedict demands his stolen money back.
    400pts
  21. Dead Again — ranked #2121
    Dead Again
    Kenneth Branagh's 1991 mystery thriller with Garcia as reporter Gray Baker.
    273pts
  22. Father of the Bride — ranked #2222
    Father of the Bride
    Gary Alazraki's 2022 remake with Garcia as Billy Herrera, a Cuban-American architect facing his daughter's wedding.
    273pts
  23. Night Falls on Manhattan — ranked #2323
    Night Falls on Manhattan
    Sidney Lumet's legal drama with Garcia as a former cop turned New York assistant district attorney.
    0pts
  24. Internal Affairs — ranked #2424
    Internal Affairs
    Mike Figgis's 1990 thriller with Garcia as LAPD internal affairs investigator Raymond Avila pursuing Richard Gere's corrupt cop.
    0pts
  25. Hoodlum — ranked #2525
    Hoodlum
    Bill Duke's 1997 gangster film in which Garcia plays Lucky Luciano opposite Laurence Fishburne.
    0pts

Comments