You Pick BestYouPickBest

Top 37 MLB Players of the 1940s

By YPB Team

Wartime absences, a broken color line and batting races settled by a fraction of a point shaped this decade. Several stars here gave up whole seasons to military service; others filled the gap.

  1. Ted Williams — ranked #11
    Ted Williams
    Boston Red Sox left fielder who hit .406 in 1941, won the Triple Crown in 1942 and 1947 and won AL MVP awards in 1946 and 1949.
    1000pts
  2. Stan Musial — ranked #22
    Stan Musial
    St. Louis Cardinals star who won NL MVP awards and NL batting titles in 1943, 1946 and 1948.
    889pts
  3. Frank McCormick — ranked #33
    Frank McCormick
    Cincinnati Reds first baseman who won the 1940 NL MVP with 127 RBI as the Reds won the World Series.
    722pts
  4. Lou Boudreau — ranked #44
    Lou Boudreau
    Cleveland shortstop and player-manager who won the 1948 AL MVP as the Indians won the World Series.
    615pts
  5. Johnny Sain — ranked #55
    Johnny Sain
    Boston Braves right-hander who led the NL with 24 wins in 1948 and finished second in that year's MVP vote.
    568pts
  6. Johnny Pesky — ranked #66
    Johnny Pesky
    Boston Red Sox infielder who led the AL in hits in 1942, 1946 and 1947, batting .331 as a rookie and .335 in 1946.
    515pts
  7. Dolph Camilli — ranked #77
    Dolph Camilli
    Brooklyn Dodgers first baseman who won the 1941 NL MVP after leading the league with 34 home runs and 120 RBI.
    515pts
  8. Dixie Walker — ranked #88
    Dixie Walker
    Brooklyn Dodgers right fielder who won the 1944 NL batting title at .357 and led the NL with 124 RBI in 1945.
    515pts
  9. Bob Lemon — ranked #99
    Bob Lemon
    Cleveland right-hander who won 20 games for the 1948 World Series champions and 22 games in 1949.
    515pts
  10. Joe Gordon — ranked #1010
    Joe Gordon
    Second baseman who won the 1942 AL MVP with the Yankees and hit 32 home runs for the 1948 champion Cleveland Indians.
    515pts
  11. Enos Slaughter — ranked #1111
    Enos Slaughter
    St. Louis Cardinals right fielder who led the NL with 130 RBI in 1946 and scored the winning run in Game 7 of that year's World Series.
    515pts
  12. Bobby Doerr — ranked #1212
    Bobby Doerr
    Boston Red Sox second baseman who drove in more than 100 runs in 1942, 1946 and 1948 and was elected to the Hall of Fame in 1986.
    454pts
  13. Warren Spahn — ranked #1313
    Warren Spahn
    Boston Braves left-hander who won 21 games in both 1947 and 1949 and led the NL with a 2.33 ERA in 1947.
    454pts
  14. Phil Cavarretta — ranked #1414
    Phil Cavarretta
    Chicago Cubs first baseman who won the 1945 NL MVP and the NL batting title with a .355 average.
    454pts
  15. Pete Reiser — ranked #1515
    Pete Reiser
    Brooklyn Dodgers outfielder who won the 1941 NL batting title at .343 and led the NL in stolen bases in 1942 and 1946.
    454pts
  16. Hank Greenberg — ranked #1616
    Hank Greenberg
    Detroit Tigers slugger who won the 1940 AL MVP and led the AL in home runs and RBI in both 1940 and 1946.
    454pts
  17. Tommy Henrich — ranked #1717
    Tommy Henrich
    New York Yankees outfielder and first baseman who drove in 100 runs in 1948 and hit a walk-off home run in Game 1 of the 1949 World Series.
    384pts
  18. George Kell — ranked #1818
    George Kell
    Detroit Tigers third baseman who won the 1949 AL batting title at .343, edging Ted Williams by a fraction of a point.
    384pts
  19. Joe DiMaggio — ranked #1919
    Joe DiMaggio
    New York Yankees center fielder who hit in 56 straight games in 1941 and won AL MVP awards that year and in 1947.
    384pts
  20. Spud Chandler — ranked #2020
    Spud Chandler
    New York Yankees right-hander who won the 1943 AL MVP after going 20-4 with a league-leading 1.64 ERA.
    384pts
  21. Walker Cooper — ranked #2121
    Walker Cooper
    Catcher who won World Series titles with the Cardinals in 1942 and 1944, finished second in the 1943 NL MVP vote and hit 35 home runs for the New York Giants in 1947.
    384pts
  22. Hal Newhouser — ranked #2222
    Hal Newhouser
    Detroit Tigers left-hander who won back-to-back AL MVP awards in 1944 and 1945 after going 29-9 and 25-9.
    384pts
  23. Mort Cooper — ranked #2323
    Mort Cooper
    St. Louis Cardinals right-hander who won the 1942 NL MVP after going 22-7 with a league-leading 1.78 ERA.
    384pts
  24. Larry Doby — ranked #2424
    Larry Doby
    Cleveland outfielder who became the American League's first Black player in July 1947 and won the World Series with the Indians in 1948.
    384pts
  25. Phil Rizzuto — ranked #2525
    Phil Rizzuto
    New York Yankees shortstop who debuted in 1941 and finished second in the 1949 AL MVP vote.
    384pts
  26. Bob Feller — ranked #2626
    Bob Feller
    Cleveland right-hander who led the AL in wins in 1940, 1941, 1946 and 1947 and struck out 348 batters in 1946.
    303pts
  27. Charlie Keller — ranked #2727
    Charlie Keller
    New York Yankees left fielder who hit 33 home runs with 122 RBI in 1941 and 30 home runs in 1946.
    303pts
  28. Luke Appling — ranked #2828
    Luke Appling
    Chicago White Sox shortstop who won the 1943 AL batting title with a .328 average and finished second in that year's MVP vote.
    303pts
  29. Mel Ott — ranked #2929
    Mel Ott
    New York Giants right fielder and player-manager who led the NL with 30 home runs in 1942 and hit his 500th home run in 1945.
    303pts
  30. Pee Wee Reese — ranked #3030
    Pee Wee Reese
    Brooklyn Dodgers shortstop who led the NL with 132 runs scored in 1949 and finished in the top eight of the MVP vote four times from 1946 to 1949.
    303pts
  31. 31
    Bob Elliott
    Third baseman who won the 1947 NL MVP with the Boston Braves after hitting .317 with 113 RBI.
    303pts
  32. Marty Marion — ranked #3232
    Marty Marion
    St. Louis Cardinals shortstop who won the 1944 NL MVP and played on pennant winners in 1942, 1943, 1944 and 1946.
    206pts
  33. Vern Stephens — ranked #3333
    Vern Stephens
    Shortstop who led the AL in RBI for the 1944 St. Louis Browns and drove in 159 runs for the Red Sox in 1949, tying Ted Williams for the AL lead.
    206pts
  34. Ralph Kiner — ranked #3434
    Ralph Kiner
    Pittsburgh Pirates outfielder who led the NL in home runs every season from 1946 to 1949, including 54 in 1949.
    206pts
  35. Jackie Robinson — ranked #3535
    Jackie Robinson
    Brooklyn Dodgers infielder who broke MLB's color line in 1947, won that year's Rookie of the Year and won the 1949 NL MVP and batting title.
    0pts
  36. Johnny Mize — ranked #3636
    Johnny Mize
    First baseman who led the NL with 43 home runs for the Cardinals in 1940 and tied Ralph Kiner for the NL lead with 51 for the New York Giants in 1947.
    0pts
  37. Dom DiMaggio — ranked #3737
    Dom DiMaggio
    Boston Red Sox center fielder who hit .316 in 1946 and made All-Star teams in 1941, 1942, 1946 and 1949.
    0pts

Photo credits

Comments