Ring-collecting quarterbacks share this birth decade with left tackles nobody noticed until Canton called, plus a punter and a kicker who earned their spots. Somewhere between the shutdown corners and the workhorse backs is your top pick.
1Peyton ManningColts and Broncos quarterback (born 1976) with a record five MVP awards, Super Bowl wins XLI and 50, and 55 touchdown passes in 2013.1000pts
2Tom BradyQuarterback born in 1977 who won seven Super Bowls (six with New England, one with Tampa Bay), five Super Bowl MVPs and three league MVPs.870pts
3Ed ReedRavens safety born in 1978, 2004 Defensive Player of the Year with 64 career interceptions and two 100-plus-yard interception returns.809pts
4LaDainian TomlinsonChargers running back born in 1979; 2006 MVP after a record 31 touchdowns, finished with 13,684 rushing yards.787pts
5Drew BreesSaints quarterback born in 1979; Super Bowl XLIV MVP who retired as the NFL career leader in passing yards (80,358).787pts
6Ray LewisBaltimore Ravens middle linebacker born in 1975: two-time Defensive Player of the Year, Super Bowl XXXV MVP, 13 Pro Bowls.719pts
7Tony GonzalezTight end born in 1976 who made 14 Pro Bowls with Kansas City and Atlanta and caught 1,325 passes.719pts
8Terrell OwensReceiver born in 1973 who totaled 15,934 receiving yards and 153 receiving touchdowns for five teams; inducted into Canton in 2018.719pts
9Randy MossReceiver born in 1977 whose 23 touchdown catches for the 2007 Patriots set a single-season record; 156 career receiving TDs.719pts
10Charles WoodsonDefensive back born in 1976; 1997 Heisman winner, 2009 Defensive Player of the Year with Green Bay and 65 interceptions over 18 seasons.719pts
11Walter JonesSeattle Seahawks left tackle born in 1974 with nine Pro Bowl selections over 12 seasons; enshrined in 2014.719pts
12Larry AllenGuard and tackle born in 1971 who earned 11 Pro Bowls, ten of them with Dallas, and won Super Bowl XXX.691pts
13Champ BaileyWashington and Denver cornerback born in 1978, selected to 12 Pro Bowls with 52 interceptions; Hall of Fame class of 2019.691pts
14Curtis MartinPatriots and Jets running back born in 1973 with ten straight 1,000-yard seasons and 14,101 career rushing yards.661pts
15Alan FanecaPittsburgh guard born in 1976 with nine Pro Bowls and a Super Bowl XL title; Hall of Fame class of 2021.661pts
16Donovan McNabbPhiladelphia quarterback born in 1976 with six Pro Bowls, five NFC Championship Game appearances and a start in Super Bowl XXXIX.628pts
17Kurt WarnerUndrafted quarterback born in 1971 who went from stocking grocery shelves to two MVPs and the Super Bowl XXXIV MVP with the Rams.627pts
18Brian UrlacherChicago Bears linebacker born in 1978: 2000 Defensive Rookie of the Year, 2005 Defensive Player of the Year, eight Pro Bowls.590pts
19Jonathan OgdenLeft tackle born in 1974, the first draft pick in Baltimore Ravens history, who made 11 Pro Bowls and entered the Hall of Fame in 2013.590pts
20Warren SappTampa Bay defensive tackle born in 1972; 1999 Defensive Player of the Year with 96.5 career sacks and a Super Bowl XXXVII ring.590pts
21Marshall FaulkRunning back born in 1973 who posted 1,000 rushing and 1,000 receiving yards for the 1999 champion Rams and won the 2000 MVP.548pts
22Will ShieldsKansas City Chiefs guard born in 1971 who made 12 straight Pro Bowls and never missed a game in 14 seasons.548pts
23Derrick BrooksBuccaneers outside linebacker born in 1973 with 11 Pro Bowls and the 2002 Defensive Player of the Year award; returned an interception for a score in Super Bowl XXXVII.548pts
24Michael StrahanNew York Giants defensive end born in 1971 who set the single-season sack record (22.5) in 2001 and won Super Bowl XLII.548pts
25Edgerrin JamesColts running back born in 1978 who won rushing titles as a rookie in 1999 and again in 2000; inducted in 2020.500pts
26Kevin MawaeCenter born in 1971 who made eight Pro Bowls with the Seahawks, Jets and Titans and was inducted into the Hall of Fame in 2019.500pts
27Jason TaylorMiami Dolphins pass rusher born in 1974; 2006 Defensive Player of the Year who finished with 139.5 sacks.500pts
28Reggie WayneColts receiver born in 1978 who won Super Bowl XLI and piled up 14,345 receiving yards over 14 seasons in Indianapolis.500pts
29Torry Holt"Greatest Show on Turf" receiver born in 1976 who led the NFL in receiving yards in 2000 and 2003 and finished with 13,382 receiving yards.500pts
30Isaac BruceRams receiver born in 1972 who caught the winning 73-yard touchdown in Super Bowl XXXIV and finished with 15,208 receiving yards.500pts
31Terrell DavisDenver running back born in 1972; Super Bowl XXXII MVP, then 2,008 rushing yards and the league MVP award in 1998.500pts
32Jerome Bettis"The Bus," a Steelers running back born in 1972, ran for 13,662 yards and retired after winning Super Bowl XL in his hometown of Detroit.500pts
33Steve McNairTitans quarterback born in 1973 who reached Super Bowl XXXIV and shared the 2003 MVP award with Peyton Manning.459pts
34John LynchSafety born in 1971 who made nine Pro Bowls with Tampa Bay and Denver and won Super Bowl XXXVII; later 49ers general manager.459pts
35Brian DawkinsEagles and Broncos safety born in 1973, nine-time Pro Bowler and the first player to record a sack, interception, forced fumble and touchdown catch in one game.459pts
36Bryant YoungSan Francisco defensive tackle born in 1972 who won Super Bowl XXIX, came back from a broken leg to be 1999 Comeback Player of the Year and recorded 89.5 sacks.459pts
37Richard SeymourDefensive lineman born in 1979 who won three Super Bowls with New England, made seven Pro Bowls and entered Canton in 2022.459pts
38Zach ThomasFifth-round pick born in 1973 who became a seven-time Pro Bowl middle linebacker for Miami; inducted in 2023.459pts
39London FletcherUndrafted linebacker born in 1975 who played 256 consecutive games for the Rams, Bills and Washington and won Super Bowl XXXIV.459pts
40Marvin HarrisonIndianapolis receiver born in 1972 whose 143 catches in 2002 set a single-season record at the time; 128 career touchdown receptions.412pts
41Steve HutchinsonGuard born in 1977, a seven-time Pro Bowler with Seattle and Minnesota who was enshrined in Canton in 2020.412pts
42Ty LawNew England cornerback born in 1974 with three Super Bowl rings, a pick-six in Super Bowl XXXVI and two seasons leading the league in interceptions.412pts
43Willie RoafLeft tackle born in 1970, an 11-time Pro Bowler with New Orleans and Kansas City; Hall of Fame class of 2012.412pts
44Ronde BarberTampa Bay cornerback born in 1975, the only player with at least 40 interceptions and 25 sacks; Hall of Fame class of 2023.412pts
45Hines WardPittsburgh receiver born in 1976; Super Bowl XL MVP and the Steelers' career leader with 1,000 receptions.412pts
46Jevon Kearse"The Freak," a defensive end born in 1976, set a rookie record with 14.5 sacks for Tennessee in 1999 and was Defensive Rookie of the Year.412pts
47Orlando PaceNo. 1 overall pick in 1997 (born 1975) who protected the Rams' blind side for 12 seasons, made seven Pro Bowls and won Super Bowl XXXIV.357pts
48Shane LechlerRaiders and Texans punter born in 1976 who retired holding the career record for gross punting average (47.6 yards).357pts
49Steve Smith Sr.Carolina receiver born in 1979 who led or shared the NFL lead in catches, yards and touchdown receptions in 2005; 14,731 career yards.357pts
50Chad JohnsonCincinnati receiver born in 1978 who led the AFC in receiving yards four straight seasons (2003–2006) and made six Pro Bowls.357pts
51Shaun AlexanderSeattle running back born in 1977; 2005 MVP after 1,880 yards and 28 touchdowns, then a start in Super Bowl XL.357pts
52Tiki BarberNew York Giants running back born in 1975, the franchise's career rushing leader with 10,449 yards.357pts
53Eddie GeorgeHeisman winner born in 1973 who became 1996 Offensive Rookie of the Year and ran for 10,441 yards, nearly all for the Oilers and Titans.357pts
54Brian WestbrookEagles running back born in 1979 who led the NFL with 2,104 yards from scrimmage in 2007.357pts
55Rodney HarrisonChargers and Patriots safety born in 1972, the first NFL player with 30 career sacks and 30 interceptions; won two Super Bowls.357pts
56Adam VinatieriKicker born in 1972 who made the winning kicks in Super Bowls XXXVI and XXXVIII and retired as the NFL's career scoring leader with 2,673 points.0pts
57Jeff SaturdayUndrafted center born in 1975 who snapped to Peyton Manning for 13 seasons in Indianapolis, made six Pro Bowls and won Super Bowl XLI.0pts
58Priest HolmesUndrafted back born in 1973 who became 2002 Offensive Player of the Year in Kansas City and scored 27 touchdowns in 2003.0pts
59John AbrahamPass rusher born in 1978 who recorded 133.5 sacks for the Jets, Falcons and Cardinals and made five Pro Bowls.0pts
60Fred TaylorJacksonville running back born in 1976 who rushed for 11,695 yards over 13 seasons.0pts
Photo credits
- Peyton Manning — All-Pro Reels, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Tom Brady — Brad Muckenthaler, CC BY 4.0
- Ed Reed — Gage Skidmore, CC BY-SA 3.0
- LaDainian Tomlinson — User:Blueag9, CC BY 2.0
- Drew Brees — Senate Democrats, CC BY 2.0
- Ray Lewis — Keith Allison, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Tony Gonzalez — Erik Drost, CC BY 2.0
- Terrell Owens — Collision Conf from New Orleans, Louisiana, USA, CC BY 2.0
- Randy Moss — [2] from Baltimore, USA, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Charles Woodson — Paul Cutler, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Walter Jones — User:Blueag9, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Larry Allen — John Martinez Pavliga, CC BY 2.0
- Champ Bailey — Jeffrey Beall, CC BY-SA 3.0
- Curtis Martin — Anthony Quintano, CC BY 2.0
- Donovan McNabb — Kevin Burkett from Philadelphia, Pa., USA, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Kurt Warner — Sean Daly, CC BY-SA 3.0
- Brian Urlacher — US Army Africa from Vicenza, Italy, CC BY 2.0
- Jonathan Ogden — WendyHerr, CC BY-SA 4.0
- Warren Sapp — Anthony Quintano, CC BY 2.0
- Marshall Faulk — Gage Skidmore, CC BY-SA 3.0
- Kevin Mawae — User:Blueag9, CC BY 2.0
- Jason Taylor — Ed Yourdon, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Reggie Wayne — Gage Skidmore, CC BY-SA 3.0
- Torry Holt — User:Blueag9, CC BY 2.0
- Isaac Bruce — Lpdrew, CC BY 2.0
- Jerome Bettis — Veronica Davison, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Steve McNair — Keith Allison from Baltimore, USA, CC BY-SA 2.0
- John Lynch — All-Pro Reels, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Brian Dawkins — Bertolinephotos, CC BY-SA 4.0
- Bryant Young — Sports Spectrum, CC BY 3.0
- Richard Seymour — Jeffrey Beall, CC BY-SA 3.0
- Zach Thomas — Chrisjnelson at en.wikipedia, CC BY 3.0
- London Fletcher — All-Pro Reels, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Marvin Harrison — All-Pro Reels, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Steve Hutchinson — Bobak Ha'Eri, CC BY 3.0
- Ty Law — Jeffrey Beall, CC BY-SA 3.0
- Ronde Barber — Jeffrey Beall, CC BY-SA 3.0
- Hines Ward — FOX SPORTS, CC BY 3.0
- Jevon Kearse — Tennessee Titans, CC BY 3.0
- Orlando Pace — Monica's Dad, CC BY 2.0
- Shane Lechler — Jeffrey Beall, CC BY 4.0
- Steve Smith Sr. — Keith Allison from Baltimore, USA, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Chad Johnson — Jeff Kern, CC BY 2.0
- Shaun Alexander — Tom McDonald, Jason Fierle., CC BY-SA 2.5
- Eddie George — Erica Thomas, CC BY 2.0
- Rodney Harrison — All-Pro Reels, CC BY-SA 2.0

























