You Pick BestYouPickBest

The 18 Best Golden Age Detective Novels

By YPB Team

Country houses, church bells, a bedside investigation of Richard III. The genre wrote its rules here, then broke them on purpose.

  1. The Murder of Roger Ackroyd — ranked #11
    The Murder of Roger Ackroyd
    Christie's 1926 novel, the book that showed how far a detective writer could push the reader.
  2. And Then There Were None — ranked #22
    And Then There Were None
    Christie's 1939 island thriller, her best-selling title.
  3. Murder on the Orient Express — ranked #33
    Murder on the Orient Express
    Christie's 1934 closed-carriage mystery.
  4. The Nine Tailors — ranked #44
    The Nine Tailors
    Dorothy L. Sayers' 1934 fen-country mystery built around church bells.
  5. Gaudy Night — ranked #55
    Gaudy Night
    Sayers' 1935 Oxford novel, as much a love story as a mystery.
  6. The Hollow Man — ranked #66
    The Hollow Man
    John Dickson Carr's 1935 locked-room novel, containing the famous locked-room lecture.
  7. The Poisoned Chocolates Case — ranked #77
    The Poisoned Chocolates Case
    Anthony Berkeley's 1929 novel in which six amateurs solve the same crime six ways.
  8. Malice Aforethought — ranked #88
    Malice Aforethought
    Francis Iles' 1931 novel that tells you the murderer on page one.
  9. Trent's Last Case — ranked #99
    Trent's Last Case
    E.C. Bentley's 1913 novel, often called the first modern detective novel.
  10. The Red House Mystery — ranked #1010
    The Red House Mystery
    A.A. Milne's 1922 country-house mystery, written before Winnie-the-Pooh.
  11. The Beast Must Die — ranked #1111
    The Beast Must Die
    Nicholas Blake's 1938 revenge novel told partly as a murderer's diary.
  12. Murder Must Advertise — ranked #1212
    Murder Must Advertise
    Sayers' 1933 novel set in the advertising agency where she once worked.
  13. Green for Danger — ranked #1313
    Green for Danger
    Christianna Brand's 1944 wartime mystery set in a military hospital.
  14. The Franchise Affair — ranked #1414
    The Franchise Affair
    Josephine Tey's 1948 novel about two women accused of abducting a girl.
  15. Whose Body? — ranked #1515
    Whose Body?
    Sayers' 1923 debut, introducing Lord Peter Wimsey.
  16. The Body in the Library — ranked #1616
    The Body in the Library
    Christie's 1942 Miss Marple novel, a deliberate cliche turned inside out.
  17. Death of a Ghost — ranked #1717
    Death of a Ghost
    Margery Allingham's 1934 Albert Campion novel set in the London art world.
  18. The Case of the Velvet Claws — ranked #1818
    The Case of the Velvet Claws
    Erle Stanley Gardner's 1933 debut for Perry Mason.

Comments 1

Her own era, and four of these eighteen books came off her typewriter, more than Sayers, Carr or Allingham managed: https://youpick.best/articles/agatha-christie-ranked-many-ways

YP
ypb-team
Aug 21