You Pick BestYouPickBest

The 16 Best Comeback Seasons in NHL History

By YPB Team

Cancer, wrecked bodies, retirements that didn't stick: every season here is built around a setback that could have ended a career.

  1. Mario Lemieux 1992–93 — ranked #11
    Mario Lemieux 1992–93
    Mario Lemieux missed nearly two months for radiation treatment of Hodgkin's lymphoma and still won the Art Ross, Hart and Masterton trophies with 160 points in 60 games for Pittsburgh.
    1000pts
  2. Cam Neely 1993–94 — ranked #22
    Cam Neely 1993–94
    Cam Neely, limited to 22 games over the two previous seasons by a thigh injury and knee surgery, scored 50 goals in 44 games for Boston and won the Masterton Trophy.
    857pts
  3. Mario Lemieux 1995–96 — ranked #33
    Mario Lemieux 1995–96
    After sitting out the entire 1994–95 season with back problems and fatigue from cancer treatment, Lemieux returned to score 69 goals and 161 points and win the Art Ross and Hart trophies.
    714pts
  4. Gordie Howe 1979–80 — ranked #44
    Gordie Howe 1979–80
    Gordie Howe, who had left Detroit in 1971 and returned in 1973 for six WHA seasons, the last two with the New England Whalers, came back to the NHL with Hartford at 51 and played all 80 games, scoring 15 goals.
    714pts
  5. Mario Lemieux 2000–01 — ranked #55
    Mario Lemieux 2000–01
    Lemieux came out of a three-and-a-half-year retirement in December 2000 as the Penguins' owner-player and scored 76 points in 43 games.
    500pts
  6. Peter Forsberg 2002–03 — ranked #66
    Peter Forsberg 2002–03
    Peter Forsberg missed the entire 2001–02 regular season after spleen removal and foot surgery, then won the Art Ross and Hart trophies with 106 points for Colorado.
    500pts
  7. Teemu Selänne 2005–06 — ranked #77
    Teemu Selänne 2005–06
    Teemu Selänne returned to Anaheim after knee surgery and a 16-goal season in Colorado, scored 40 goals and 90 points, and won the Masterton Trophy.
    500pts
  8. Brian Elliott 2011–12 — ranked #88
    Brian Elliott 2011–12
    Signed by St. Louis to a one-year, $600,000 contract after a poor 2010–11, Brian Elliott led the NHL with a 1.56 goals-against average and .940 save percentage.
    455pts
  9. Devan Dubnyk 2014–15 — ranked #99
    Devan Dubnyk 2014–15
    Devan Dubnyk, who had passed through Edmonton, Nashville, Montreal's system and Arizona in barely a year, went 27-9-2 with a .936 save percentage after a trade to Minnesota and won the Masterton Trophy.
    455pts
  10. Saku Koivu 2002–03 — ranked #1010
    Saku Koivu 2002–03
    A year after his non-Hodgkin's lymphoma diagnosis, Montreal captain Saku Koivu played all 82 games and set a career high at the time with 71 points.
    455pts
  11. Erik Karlsson 2022–23 — ranked #1111
    Erik Karlsson 2022–23
    After several injury-hit seasons in San Jose, Erik Karlsson scored 101 points, the first 100-point season by a defenseman since 1991–92, and won his third Norris Trophy.
    455pts
  12. Sidney Crosby 2013–14 — ranked #1212
    Sidney Crosby 2013–14
    In his first full season after concussion problems sidelined him for most of 2011 and the 2011–12 season, Sidney Crosby scored 104 points and won the Art Ross and Hart trophies.
    400pts
  13. Tim Thomas 2010–11 — ranked #1313
    Tim Thomas 2010–11
    Tim Thomas lost the Boston starting job and had hip surgery in 2010, then set a then-NHL record .938 save percentage, won the Vezina and Conn Smythe trophies and the Stanley Cup.
    0pts
  14. Gary Roberts 1995–96 — ranked #1414
    Gary Roberts 1995–96
    Gary Roberts came back from career-threatening neck surgery in January 1996 and scored 22 goals in 35 games for Calgary, earning the Masterton Trophy.
    0pts
  15. Robin Lehner 2018–19 — ranked #1515
    Robin Lehner 2018–19
    After treatment for addiction and bipolar disorder, Robin Lehner posted a .930 save percentage for the Islanders, shared the Jennings Trophy and won the Masterton.
    0pts
  16. Marc-André Fleury 2020–21 — ranked #1616
    Marc-André Fleury 2020–21
    Months after Vegas made Robin Lehner its playoff starter, 36-year-old Marc-André Fleury went 26-10-0 with a 1.98 goals-against average and won his first Vezina Trophy.
    0pts

Photo credits

Comments