You Pick BestYouPickBest

Dallas Cowboys: Greatest NFL Franchise Ever? 5 Rings, 12 Lists

By YPB Team · Published November 16, 2026

Dallas Cowboys end zone and the giant video board inside AT&T Stadium in Arlington, Texas
The Dallas Cowboys' end zone at AT&T Stadium, December 2021. Photo: All-Pro Reels, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

The Dallas Cowboys host the Philadelphia Eagles on Thanksgiving, November 26, 2026, at 4:30 p.m. ET on FOX.1 Dallas has owned the late holiday slot since 1966, when general manager Tex Schramm wanted the national exposure, and the last Thanksgiving without the Cowboys was 1977.2

Twelve rankings on YouPickBest hold the franchise, one of its seasons, its coach, its building or its badge. They range from the greatest NFL franchise and the greatest dynasty in sport to the most hated team in America and the NFL's biggest underachievers.

Every Cowboys case worth making was closed by January 1996; the star, the money and the hatred have kept growing since.

Cowboys vs Steelers: the greatest NFL franchise of all time

This ranking puts all of the league's storied franchises in one bracket, from the Green Bay Packers and Chicago Bears to the New England Patriots and the Philadelphia Eagles.

The Dallas Cowboys bring a résumé that the Canton museum lists plainly: in the NFL since 1960, Super Bowls VI, XII, XXVII, XXVIII and XXX, eight NFC championships and 32 Hall of Famers.3

The Pittsburgh Steelers have the cleaner trophy answer. Pittsburgh won six Super Bowls and in 2008 became the first team to reach that total.4 One of those six, Super Bowl XIII after the 1978 season, came against Dallas.

The Cowboys' reply is breadth. They won titles in two separate eras under two different owners, and few franchises have been relevant for as many decades.

Five Super Bowls against six, and a Super Bowl XIII loss between them. Play it →

Dallas Cowboys vs Boston Celtics: America's richest team among its greatest

Widen the field to every American league and the Cowboys share a bracket with the Boston Celtics, the New York Yankees, the Los Angeles Lakers, the Montreal Canadiens and Alabama football.

Money is where Dallas leads everyone. Forbes valued the Cowboys at $17 billion in September 2026, up 31% in a year, on nearly $1.28 billion of revenue, and named them the NFL's most valuable team for the 20th straight year.5

Value is a poor proxy for greatness, and the Celtics show why. Boston built its case on banners hanging in an arena, while the Cowboys' last title banner went up in 1996.

The NFL's richest club against the NBA's banner collectors. Play it →

1992 Cowboys vs 1972 Dolphins: the greatest single NFL season

This list judges individual seasons, so the Cowboys enter as one team: the 1992 side that won Super Bowl XXVII with a young core of Troy Aikman, Emmitt Smith and Michael Irvin.

The 1972 Miami Dolphins hold the one record nobody else has. They finished 17-0, the NFL's only perfect season, capped by Super Bowl VII.6

The company is heavy. The 1985 Chicago Bears, the 1989 San Francisco 49ers and the 2007 New England Patriots share this bracket, and so do the 1978 Pittsburgh Steelers.

The 1992 Cowboys have youth on their side. That roster was the first of three championship teams in four seasons, a claim the other champions here cannot make about their own cores.

The start of a three-title run against the only perfect season. Play it →

The 1990s Cowboys and the 49ers: a dynasty measured against the world

The greatest-dynasty ranking reaches far past football: the 1957–1969 Boston Celtics, the 1991–1998 Chicago Bulls, Real Madrid's European Cup run of 1956 to 1960 and Australia's cricket team of 1995–2007.

The 1990s Cowboys qualify on three Super Bowls in four seasons, won after the 1992, 1993 and 1995 campaigns.

The San Francisco 49ers are the closer football comparison and the harder one for Dallas. The 49ers won five Super Bowls between the 1981 and 1994 seasons, according to the Hall of Fame.7 The two clubs spent the early 1990s blocking each other's path in the NFC.

The counter-case for Dallas is concentration. The 49ers needed fourteen seasons for their five; the Cowboys packed their three into four years, and the 2001–2019 Patriots on the same list needed nearly two decades.

Two NFC dynasties that kept running into each other. Play it →

1992 vs 1977: which Cowboys team was best

This ranking asks the franchise to judge itself: every option is one of nine Dallas seasons.

Five of them won a title: 1971, 1977, 1992, 1993 and 1995. The 1977 team had rookie Tony Dorsett and the Doomsday Defense and beat Denver in Super Bowl XII; the 1992 team opened the Jimmy Johnson era's run.

The other four seasons are there for a different reason. The 1975 team lost Super Bowl X, while the 2007, 2014 and 2016 teams were regular-season powers that went no further than the divisional round. That gap between September and January is the modern Cowboys in miniature.

Two championship rings, fifteen years apart. Play it →

Emmitt Smith vs Roger Staubach: the 30 greatest Cowboys

Thirty players make this list, from Bob Lilly and Randy White in the Doomsday years to Dak Prescott, Micah Parsons and CeeDee Lamb.

Emmitt Smith carries the numbers no other Cowboy can match. He ran for 18,355 yards and an NFL-record 164 rushing touchdowns, passed Walter Payton as the league's career rushing leader on October 27, 2002, and was MVP of Super Bowl XXVIII, a 30-13 win over Buffalo.8

Roger Staubach has the older claim. He quarterbacked both Landry-era titles and gave the franchise its reputation for late comebacks.

Troy Aikman and Michael Irvin complete the 1990s triangle, and Tony Romo is the reminder that some of the most gifted Cowboys never reached a conference final.

The rushing record against the original Captain America. Play it →

Tom Landry vs Bill Walsh: the fedora among the greatest coaches

The coaches ranking holds 30 names, two of them from Dallas: Tom Landry and Jimmy Johnson.

Landry is the longer story. He coached the Cowboys for 29 seasons, from the expansion year of 1960 through 1988, strung together 20 straight winning seasons, took Dallas to five Super Bowls and won two, VI and XII, finishing with 270 wins including playoffs.9 The Flex Defense and the hat made him the most recognizable figure on any sideline of his era.

Bill Walsh offers the sharpest contrast. His West Coast offense won the 49ers their first three Super Bowls in the 1980s, a faster peak than Landry's long plateau.

With Vince Lombardi, Don Shula and Bill Belichick also in the bracket, Landry's case rests on endurance more than rings.

Twenty-nine seasons in one job against the man who rewrote offense. Play it →

AT&T Stadium vs Lambeau Field: Jerry Jones's building

The stadium ranking sets Arlington against the league's newest palaces, SoFi Stadium and Allegiant Stadium, and its oldest shrine, Lambeau Field.

AT&T Stadium is Jerry Jones's monument. Jones took over the Cowboys in 1989, won Super Bowls XXVII, XXVIII and XXX, and drove the building that opened in 2009 and can hold more than 100,000 people; Canton enshrined him with the class of 2017.10

Lambeau has what money cannot build. The Green Bay Packers are a community-owned club in a small city, and their stadium predates most of the teams in the league.

The Cowboys' stadium case is the retractable roof and the video board hanging over midfield. The Packers' case is everything that happened in the snow.

Arlington's retractable roof against Green Bay's frozen tundra. Play it →

The Cowboys star vs the Yankees' NY

Five points, one color, no lettering. The Dallas Cowboys star is the plainest design in a bracket where it meets Nike's Swoosh, Michael Jordan's Jumpman, the five Olympic rings and the horse on every Ferrari.

The New York Yankees' interlocking NY is its nearest rival as a team logo that people wear without caring about the sport.

A lone star against two interlocking letters. Play it →

Cowboys Thanksgiving throwback vs Eagles Kelly Green

The throwback ranking is where the holiday shows up in the clothes. Dallas wore its 1960s throwbacks with the white helmet on Thanksgiving until a 38-31 loss to Washington in 2012, then brought the look back for the 2022 Thanksgiving game against the Giants, its first appearance in a decade.11

The Eagles Kelly Green set is on the same list. Philadelphia wore that shade before switching to midnight green, and the Eagles are this year's Thanksgiving opponent.

Other nostalgia picks keep both honest: the Buccaneers' creamsicle orange, the Chargers' powder blue and the Houston Oilers set the Titans revived.

Thursday's two teams, both dressed as their younger selves. Play it →

Dallas Cowboys vs New England Patriots: the most hated team in America

This is the inverted ranking, and the Cowboys qualify for the reason they top the money tables: everyone has an opinion about them.

The nickname "America's Team" invites the backlash by itself. Fans of the Eagles, Giants and Commanders have spent decades hearing a rival described as the whole country's club.

The New England Patriots are the modern challenger, with the Brady-Belichick run, Spygate and Deflategate behind them. The New York Yankees, the Duke Blue Devils and the Golden State Warriors complete a field of teams that won too much, or were told about it too often.

America's Team against the team America got tired of. Play it →

Cowboys vs Browns: the NFL's great underachievers

The underachiever ranking measures what a franchise had against what it won, and that is where the last three decades cost Dallas.

The Cowboys have not played in an NFC Championship Game since the 1995 season. Troy Aikman called the drought "hard to fathom" in August 2026 and added: "It's just unacceptable."12

The Cleveland Browns are the other extreme: four NFL championships before the merger and no trip to a Super Bowl since. The Minnesota Vikings, Buffalo Bills and Detroit Lions carry their own near-misses into this bracket.

Dallas has the strongest defense here. No other team on the list owns five Super Bowl trophies.

Thirty years since a conference final, measured against Cleveland's longer wait. Play it →

Thirty Thanksgivings since the last ring

The Cowboys earned their place on the history lists before 1996, under Landry and then under Johnson and Jones. The value, the stadium and the resentment are all newer than the last trophy, and that gap is the franchise's real identity in 2026.

Each of the twelve rankings above is decided by people picking one of two names per matchup, the way a pairwise comparison works. If your own Thanksgiving table argues about something else, build a ranking for it before the turkey goes cold.

More rankings, more angles

Sources

  1. NBC DFW — NFL Thanksgiving schedule 2026, Eagles at Cowboys, 4:30 p.m. ET on FOX: nbcdfw.com (checked 2026-11-16)
  2. NBC Sports — NFL Thanksgiving Day games: history, origin and traditions (Cowboys since 1966, last absence 1977): nbcsports.com (checked 2026-11-16)
  3. Pro Football Hall of Fame — Dallas Cowboys team page (founding, Super Bowl and NFC titles, Hall of Famers): profootballhof.com (checked 2026-11-16)
  4. Pro Football Hall of Fame — Pittsburgh Steelers team page (six Super Bowls): profootballhof.com (checked 2026-11-16)
  5. Reuters via The Star — Forbes 2026 NFL valuations, Cowboys $17 billion: thestar.com.my (checked 2026-11-16)
  6. Pro Football Hall of Fame — Miami Dolphins team page (1972 perfect season): profootballhof.com (checked 2026-11-16)
  7. Pro Football Hall of Fame — San Francisco 49ers team page (Super Bowl titles): profootballhof.com (checked 2026-11-16)
  8. Pro Football Hall of Fame — Emmitt Smith (rushing record, Super Bowl XXVIII MVP): profootballhof.com (checked 2026-11-16)
  9. Pro Football Hall of Fame — Tom Landry (seasons, winning streak, wins): profootballhof.com (checked 2026-11-16)
  10. Pro Football Hall of Fame — Jerry Jones (ownership, AT&T Stadium, 2017 class): profootballhof.com (checked 2026-11-16)
  11. NBC Sports / ProFootballTalk — Cowboys bring back white-helmet throwbacks for Thanksgiving: nbcsports.com (checked 2026-11-16)
  12. NBC Sports / ProFootballTalk — Troy Aikman on the Cowboys' championship drought (August 17, 2026): nbcsports.com (checked 2026-11-16)