Spanning nearly a century of the sport, this lineup pits legendary major winners against modern dominant forces — each with a legitimate claim to the throne. Cast your vote!
1Jack NicklausThe Golden Bear won 18 major championships — the most of any golfer in history — along with 73 PGA Tour victories.1000pts
2Tiger WoodsWidely regarded as the most dominant golfer of his era, Woods holds 15 major titles and 82 PGA Tour wins.804pts
3Vijay SinghThe Fijian who won three majors and 34 PGA Tour titles, and took the world number one ranking from Tiger Woods in 2004.800pts
4Raymond FloydWon four majors across three decades, from the 1969 PGA Championship to the 1986 US Open at the age of 43.772pts
5Mickey WrightWon 82 LPGA events and 13 majors, and her swing was called the best ever by Ben Hogan.738pts
6Rory McIlroyThe Northern Irish star completed the career Grand Slam at the 2025 Masters and defended the green jacket in 2026 for his sixth major title.738pts
7Jimmy DemaretThree-time Masters champion of the 1940s and 1950s who won 31 PGA Tour events with a famously colourful wardrobe.676pts
8Greg NormanThe Great White Shark spent 331 weeks as world number one and won 2 Open Championships during his dominant 1980s run.658pts
9Jon RahmSpanish star who won the 2021 US Open and the 2023 Masters and reached world number one with a powerful, compact swing.658pts
10Babe Didrikson ZahariasThe Olympic champion turned golfer who co-founded the LPGA and won ten majors, including the 1954 US Women's Open after cancer surgery.611pts
11Lorena OchoaMexican star who won 27 LPGA Tour events and two majors and spent 158 consecutive weeks as women's world number one before retiring at 28.567pts
12Scottie SchefflerThe dominant world number one of the 2020s, with four majors: the Masters in 2022 and 2024 and the PGA Championship and Open in 2025.559pts
13Dustin JohnsonTwo-time major champion and 24-time PGA Tour winner who won the 2020 Masters with a record score of 20 under par.559pts
14Sam SneadOwner of 82 PGA Tour wins and 7 majors, Snead's silky swing is still considered one of the purest in golf history.559pts
15Peter ThomsonThe Australian who won five Open Championships between 1954 and 1965, including three in a row.559pts
16Ben HoganKnown as the greatest ball-striker ever, Hogan claimed 9 major championships and set the standard for precision and practice.559pts
17Pádraig HarringtonThe Irishman who won three majors in 13 months, the 2007 and 2008 Opens and the 2008 PGA Championship.559pts
18Tom WatsonWatson won 8 majors including 5 Open Championships, and was widely considered the best player in the world from 1977 to 1985.500pts
19Arnold PalmerPalmer won 7 majors and 62 PGA Tour events while transforming golf into a mainstream spectator sport through his charismatic style.500pts
20Ernie ElsThe South African 'Big Easy' who won two US Opens and two Open Championships with one of the smoothest swings in the game.500pts
21James BraidThe Scot who won five Open Championships between 1901 and 1910 as part of golf's Great Triumvirate with Vardon and Taylor.500pts
22Nick FaldoThe Englishman won 6 majors, including three Masters and three Open Championships, and was world number one for 97 weeks.433pts
23Annika SörenstamThe Swede who won 72 LPGA Tour events and ten majors, and became the first woman to shoot 59 in competition.433pts
24Hale IrwinWon three US Opens, the last in 1990 at 45, and dominated the senior tour with 45 victories.433pts
25Payne StewartThree-time major champion known for his plus-fours, who won the 1999 U.S. Open months before his death in a plane crash.433pts
26Harry VardonHolds the record of six Open Championships, won the 1900 US Open and gave his name to the overlapping grip most golfers still use.357pts
27Gary PlayerSouth African who won nine majors, completed the career Grand Slam in 1965 and claimed more than 160 professional titles around the world.357pts
28Gene SarazenWon seven majors and became the first player to complete the career Grand Slam, sealed by his famous double eagle at the 1935 Masters.357pts
29Old Tom MorrisWon four of the first eight Open Championships in the 1860s and shaped St Andrews as its long-serving keeper of the green.357pts
30Walter HagenA pioneering professional golfer who won 11 majors and helped elevate the social standing of pro golfers in the 1920s.269pts
31Jordan SpiethWon the 2015 Masters and US Open at 21 and added the 2017 Open Championship, three legs of the career Grand Slam.269pts
32Young Tom MorrisWon the Open Championship four times in a row from 1868, the first at 17, before dying at just 24.269pts
33Byron NelsonWon five majors and set a record that still stands with 18 PGA Tour wins in 1945, including 11 in a row.269pts
34Bernhard LangerThe German who won the Masters in 1985 and 1993, then set the record for wins on the over-50 PGA Tour Champions.269pts
35Phil MickelsonLefty won 6 majors including 3 Masters titles and is celebrated for his creative shotmaking and crowd-pleasing style.269pts
36J.H. TaylorWon five Open Championships between 1894 and 1913 and helped found the British professional golfers' association.269pts
37Brooks KoepkaA five-time major champion known for his exceptional performance under pressure at the game's biggest tournaments.167pts
38Billy CasperWon 51 PGA Tour events and three majors, including the 1966 US Open after overturning a seven-shot deficit to Arnold Palmer.167pts
39Cary MiddlecoffThe dentist turned golfer who won 39 PGA Tour events and three majors, including two US Opens, in the 1940s and 1950s.167pts
40Lee TrevinoThe Merry Mex won 6 majors and was renowned for his natural flair, wit, and unconventional swing.167pts
41Lloyd MangrumDecorated World War II veteran who won the 1946 U.S. Open and 36 PGA Tour events, a total few players have matched.0pts
42Seve BallesterosThe charismatic Spaniard won 5 majors and is credited with inspiring a generation of European golfers.0pts
Photo credits
- Vijay Singh — Brian J, CC BY 2.0
- Rory McIlroy — TourProGolfClubs, CC BY 2.0
- Greg Norman — Great White Shark Enterprises, CC BY-SA 4.0
- Jon Rahm — Bryan Berlin, CC BY-SA 4.0
- Lorena Ochoa — Roman Gomez, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Dustin Johnson — JazzyJoeyD, CC BY-SA 4.0
- Pádraig Harrington — Pablo Herrero, CC BY 2.0
- Ernie Els — Bluedogtn, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Nick Faldo — Lindsay M Faldo, CC BY-SA 4.0
- Annika Sörenstam — Keith Allison, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Hale Irwin — Ted Van Pelt from Mechanicsburg, PA, USA, CC BY 2.0
- Jordan Spieth — Bryan Berlin, CC BY-SA 4.0
- Bernhard Langer — Keith Allison, CC BY-SA 2.0
- Brooks Koepka — Idz93, CC BY-SA 4.0
- Billy Casper — Dave Hogg from Royal Oak, MI, USA, CC BY 2.0
- Lee Trevino — Keith Allison, CC BY-SA 2.0
Comments 1
Eighteen professional majors have stood untouched since 1986, which is what makes this fifteen-name question so hard on everyone else on it: https://youpick.best/articles/rory-mcilroy-ranked-many-ways
YP
ypb-teamSep 6























