Second acts that buried the original, from quietly tightened classics to total reinventions.
1The Witcher 3: Wild HuntThe third Geralt game, and the one that made CD Projekt a household name.1000pts
2The Elder Scrolls V: SkyrimThe fifth Elder Scrolls game dropped players into a frozen northern province full of dragons and shouts, and sold more than 60 million copies across its many re-releases.933pts
3Half-Life 2Valve's 2004 sequel, which made physics a storytelling tool.895pts
4Red Dead Redemption 2A prequel-sequel that slowed the western down until every chore mattered.890pts
5Baldur's Gate 3Larian revived the series 23 years after Baldur's Gate II, and its Dungeons & Dragons role-playing took best-game honors at The Game Awards, the DICE Awards and BAFTA.882pts
6Super Mario Bros. 3The 1988 sequel that rebuilt the platformer with a world map and power-up suits.855pts
7Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake EaterA Cold War prequel widely held to be the series' best-told story.847pts
8Portal 2Valve's 2011 follow-up added a full co-op campaign, Stephen Merchant's Wheatley and J.K. Simmons' Cave Johnson to the original's portal-gun puzzles.789pts
9Halo 2Bungie's 2004 follow-up to Combat Evolved added dual wielding, the Arbiter's half of the story and online play over Xbox Live, and became the best-selling original Xbox game.729pts
10The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the PastNintendo's 1991 Super Nintendo follow-up to Zelda II returned to a top-down view and introduced the split Light and Dark Worlds that later Zelda games kept borrowing.662pts
11The Legend of Zelda: Majora's MaskA darker, stranger follow-up built in a year on Ocarina of Time's engine.645pts
12Street Fighter IIThe sequel that created the modern fighting game and the arcade boom around it.644pts
13God of War (2018)Santa Monica Studio moved Kratos from Greek myth to Norse lands, recast him as a grieving father to Atreus and won Game of the Year at The Game Awards 2018.587pts
14Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 (2009)Infinity Ward's sequel to Call of Duty 4 earned 550 million dollars in its first five days and made customizable killstreaks a staple of console multiplayer.587pts
15Super MetroidThe 1994 sequel that defined an entire genre's map design.584pts
16Resident Evil 4Reinvented survival horror as an over-the-shoulder action game in 2005.576pts
17Mass Effect 2Cut the first game's tedium and added a cast worth dying for.500pts
18Grand Theft Auto: San AndreasTook Vice City's formula and stretched it across three cities and an entire state.500pts
19Super Smash Bros. MeleeThe 2001 GameCube sequel to the Nintendo 64 original kept every fighter, added newcomers such as Fire Emblem's Marth and Roy, and sold over seven million copies.500pts
20Batman: Arkham CityRocksteady moved Batman out of Arkham Asylum's corridors and into a walled-off district of Gotham, keeping the free-flow combat and adding an open city to glide over.500pts
21Titanfall 2Respawn added a single-player campaign to the online-only original, and levels like Effect and Cause made its mech-and-pilot shooter one of 2016's most praised games.500pts
22Super Mario Galaxy 2Built from ideas left over from the first Galaxy, the 2010 Wii sequel added Yoshi plus cloud and drill power-ups and scored 97 on Metacritic.500pts
23Uncharted 2: Among ThievesThe sequel that turned a solid adventure series into a system seller.467pts
24Assassin's Creed IIUbisoft swapped the first game's repetitive missions for Ezio Auditore's life story across Renaissance Florence and Venice, with tombs, a family villa and Leonardo da Vinci's gadgets.462pts
25Grand Theft Auto: Vice CityRockstar followed Grand Theft Auto III with a neon 1986 pastiche of Miami, a voiced lead in Ray Liotta's Tommy Vercetti and a radio full of real '80s hits.462pts
26Star Fox 64Made after Star Fox 2 was shelved, the 1997 Nintendo 64 follow-up to the SNES original added branching routes, full voice acting and multiplayer dogfights.462pts
27Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year DoorIntelligent Systems' 2004 GameCube sequel kept the papercraft look and timed-hit battles for a theatrical adventure around Rogueport, and Nintendo remade it for Switch in 2024.462pts
28Doom Eternalid Software's follow-up to the 2016 reboot turned combat into a resource puzzle of chainsaw ammo, glory kills and flame belches, all set to Mick Gordon's metal score.462pts
29Red Dead RedemptionRockstar's follow-up to Red Dead Revolver sent former outlaw John Marston across the fading frontier of 1911 to hunt down his old gang for the government.417pts
30Silent Hill 2Team Silent's 2001 sequel dropped the first game's cult plot for widower James Sunderland's search for his dead wife, and it remains the series' most acclaimed entry.417pts
31Borderlands 2Gearbox gave its loot shooter a real villain in Handsome Jack, sharper jokes and four new Vault Hunters, sending them back to Pandora for billions of procedurally generated guns.417pts
32Fallout: New VegasObsidian built it in about 18 months on Fallout 3's engine, and its faction-driven Mojave story is now often rated above the game it followed.417pts
33Team Fortress 2Valve's sequel to the Quake mod Team Fortress turned nine character classes into cartoon personalities and has run as a free-to-play shooter with a hat economy since 2011.364pts
34Pikmin 2Nintendo's 2004 sequel scrapped the first game's 30-day limit and added a second captain, Louie, plus purple and white Pikmin for treasure hunts in underground caves.364pts
35Donkey Kong Country 2: Diddy's Kong QuestRare's 1995 Super Nintendo sequel sent Diddy and Dixie Kong to rescue a kidnapped Donkey Kong from Kaptain K. Rool, backed by David Wise's celebrated score.364pts
36Spider-Man 2 (2004)Treyarch's 2004 film tie-in followed the 2002 game with free web-swinging across an open-world Manhattan, where every web line attaches to a real building.364pts
37Burnout 3: TakedownCriterion's 2004 sequel built the series around Takedowns, which fill the boost meter for slamming rivals into crashes, and became one of the highest-rated racing games ever.364pts
38F-Zero GXThe first major collaboration between Nintendo and Sega, this 2003 GameCube follow-up to F-Zero X kept the series' blistering speed and added a Captain Falcon story mode.364pts
39Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of LibertyHideo Kojima's 2001 sequel swapped Solid Snake for newcomer Raiden after the opening tanker chapter and built its plot around the control of information in the digital age.364pts
40Civilization IVThe entry most strategy players still name as the series' peak.333pts
41Guitar Hero IIHarmonix's 2006 sequel expanded the plastic-guitar game with co-op bass and rhythm parts and a tougher setlist that included Rush's YYZ and Lynyrd Skynyrd's Free Bird.0pts
42Bayonetta 2PlatinumGames' 2014 sequel became a Wii U exclusive through a publishing deal with Nintendo, and critics praised its faster combat and new two-player Tag Climax mode.0pts
43Kingdom Come: Deliverance IIWarhorse Studios returned to Henry of Skalitz in 15th-century Bohemia with a larger world around Kuttenberg, and the 2025 sequel sold two million copies in under two weeks.0pts
44Rise of the Tomb RaiderCrystal Dynamics sent Lara Croft to Siberia in search of the Divine Source, adding bigger hubs and proper tomb puzzles to the 2013 reboot's survival shooting.0pts
45Diablo IIRefined the loot-and-click formula so thoroughly that players never really stopped.0pts
Photo credits
- The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim cover — Bethesda Softworks, rights holder
- Half-Life 2 cover — Valve, rights holder
- Baldur's Gate 3 cover — Larian Studios, rights holder
- Portal 2 cover — Valve, rights holder
- Halo 2 North American Xbox box art — Microsoft Game Studios, rights holder
- God of War (2018) cover — Sony Interactive Entertainment, rights holder
- Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 (2009) cover — Activision, rights holder
- Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas cover — Rockstar Games, rights holder
- Super Smash Bros. Melee North American GameCube box art — Nintendo, rights holder
- Batman: Arkham City cover — Warner Bros. Games, rights holder
- Titanfall 2 cover — Electronic Arts, rights holder
- Super Mario Galaxy 2 logo — Throast, CC BY-SA 3.0
- Assassin's Creed II cover — Ubisoft, rights holder
- Grand Theft Auto: Vice City cover — Rockstar Games, rights holder
- Star Fox 64 North American Nintendo 64 box art — Nintendo, rights holder
- Doom Eternal cover — Bethesda Softworks, rights holder
- Red Dead Redemption cover — Rockstar Games, rights holder
- Silent Hill 2 North American PlayStation 2 box art — Konami, rights holder
- Borderlands 2 cover — 2K, rights holder
- Fallout: New Vegas cover — Bethesda Softworks, rights holder
- Team Fortress 2 cover — Valve, rights holder
- Pikmin 2 North American GameCube box art — Nintendo, rights holder
- Spider-Man 2 (2004) PlayStation 2 box art — Activision, rights holder
- Burnout 3: Takedown North American PlayStation 2 box art — Electronic Arts, rights holder
- F-Zero GX North American GameCube box art — Nintendo, rights holder
- Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty cover — Konami, rights holder
- Civilization IV cover — 2K, rights holder
- Bayonetta 2 North American Wii U box art — Nintendo, rights holder
- Kingdom Come: Deliverance II cover — Deep Silver, rights holder
- Rise of the Tomb Raider cover — Square Enix, rights holder
Comments 1
Every entry here outgrew the game before it, which is exactly the claim San Andreas makes for Grand Theft Auto.
YP
ypb-teamAug 25


















