What is the best Silent Hill game of all time?

Silent Hill set the gold standard for psychological horror with its fog-drenched streets and deeply unsettling storytelling. Which entry in the series haunted you most?

1

Silent Hill: Shattered Memories

A bold 2009 reimagining for Wii and PSP praised for its psychological profiling system and emotionally resonant storytelling.

1000pts

2

Silent Hill 2

The 2001 psychological horror masterpiece following James Sunderland's journey into a fog-shrouded town, widely regarded as the greatest horror game ever made.

928pts

3

Silent Hill

The 1999 original that established the franchise with its dense atmosphere, creeping paranoia, and iconic Otherworld transitions.

507pts

4

Silent Hill 3

A visually stunning 2003 sequel following Heather Mason into the nightmarish cult-filled town, often cited for its intense horror imagery.

507pts

5

Silent Hill: Origins

A 2007 PSP prequel following trucker Travis Grady through the events before the original game, praised for expanding lore.

428pts

6

Silent Hill: Downpour

The 2012 entry offering an open-world approach to Silent Hill's foggy streets with prisoner protagonist Murphy Pendleton.

428pts

7

Silent Hill f

The 2025 Japan-set entry praised as one of the best horror games of the year, dripping with terrifying atmosphere.

428pts

8

Silent Hill 4: The Room

The divisive 2004 entry that changed the formula by trapping protagonist Henry Townshend in his own apartment.

190pts

9

Silent Hill: Homecoming

The 2008 Western-developed entry following soldier Alex Shepherd returning to his hometown, noted for its intense combat.

0pts

10

Silent Hill 2 Remake

Bloober Team's acclaimed 2024 remake that modernizes the classic with stunning visuals while preserving its psychological depth.

0pts