Modest Mouse built one of indie rock's most distinctive catalogs, from desolate Pacific Northwest road trips to alt-rock radio breakthroughs. Which album do you consider their best?
1The Moon & AntarcticaThe celebrated 2000 masterpiece, an ambitious concept album about death and the cosmos widely considered their best.1000pts
2Good News for People Who Love Bad NewsThe 2004 breakthrough album featuring Float On, bringing Modest Mouse to mainstream radio success.636pts
3This Is a Long Drive for Someone with Nothing to Think AboutModest Mouse's sprawling 1996 debut, a desolate and hypnotic indie rock road trip across the American West.621pts
4We Were Dead Before the Ship Even SankThe 2007 No. 1 album featuring Johnny Marr, expanding the sound with folk, prog, and even big band elements.538pts
5The Golden CasketThe 2021 album blending synths, guitars, and Isaac Brock's anxious absurdism in a polished mid-career statement.440pts
6Strangers to OurselvesThe 2015 return after an eight-year gap, psychedelic and restless, wrestling with modern alienation.323pts
7An Eraser and a MazeModest Mouse's eighth studio album, released in June 2026 after a five-year gap, with producers including Jacknife Lee and singles like Look How Far.323pts
8The Lonesome Crowded WestThe 1997 album sharpening their jagged indie rock with sardonic wit and frenzied energy.0pts











