What is the best Metallica album of all time?

Thrash blueprints, a genre-defining commercial juggernaut, and return-to-roots moments all make the cut — representing decades of evolution and debate. Cast your vote.

1

Master of Puppets

Metallica's 1986 thrash masterpiece, widely considered one of the greatest metal albums.

2

Ride the Lightning

Metallica's 1984 sophomore album showing dramatic musical growth.

3

...And Justice for All

Metallica's 1988 progressive thrash album famous for its bass-light mix.

4

Metallica

Metallica's 1991 Black Album, their mainstream breakthrough selling over 30 million copies.

5

Kill 'Em All

Metallica's 1983 debut album that launched the thrash metal genre.

6

Death Magnetic

Metallica's 2008 return to thrash form after years of experimentation.

7

Load

Metallica's 1996 blues and hard rock-influenced departure from thrash.

8

Hardwired...to Self-Destruct

Metallica's 2016 double album returning to heavier thrash territory.

9

ReLoad

Metallica's 1997 companion album to Load continuing their experimental phase.

10

St. Anger

Metallica's controversial 2003 album with raw production and snare drum sound.

11

72 Seasons

Metallica's 2023 album exploring childhood trauma through heavy music.