You Pick BestYouPickBest

The 38 Greatest Garth Brooks Songs of All Time

By YPB Team

From arena-shaking honky-tonk anthems to tender heartbreak ballads, Garth Brooks built one of country music's deepest catalogs across four decades. Which song defines him best? Cast your vote!

  1. If Tomorrow Never Comes — ranked #11
    If Tomorrow Never Comes
    Brooks' first-ever No. 1 hit, a tender ballad about telling loved ones how much they mean to you.
    1000pts
  2. The Dance — ranked #22
    The Dance
    A poignant ballad about accepting loss for the sake of love, considered one of country music's most poetic songs.
    888pts
  3. Rodeo — ranked #33
    Rodeo
    A rousing tribute to the rodeo lifestyle and the men who chase it despite the toll it takes.
    764pts
  4. Ain't Goin' Down ('Til the Sun Comes Up) — ranked #44
    Ain't Goin' Down ('Til the Sun Comes Up)
    The breakneck lead single of In Pieces, a 1993 No. 1 that races through a young couple's night out in a rapid-fire vocal.
    734pts
  5. What She's Doing Now — ranked #55
    What She's Doing Now
    Co-written with Pat Alger, this Ropin' the Wind ballad about a man who still wonders about his old flame spent four weeks at No. 1 in 1992.
    700pts
  6. The Beaches of Cheyenne — ranked #66
    The Beaches of Cheyenne
    A haunting story-ballad about a rodeo rider's widow, co-written by Brooks, that became his 15th No. 1 in March 1996.
    660pts
  7. The River — ranked #77
    The River
    Written with Victoria Shaw, the 1992 No. 1 compares chasing a dream to steering a boat down a river and closed out the Ropin' the Wind singles.
    660pts
  8. Standing Outside the Fire — ranked #88
    Standing Outside the Fire
    An arena-ready anthem urging listeners to take risks and live boldly rather than watch life from the sidelines.
    615pts
  9. Shameless — ranked #99
    Shameless
    Brooks turned a Billy Joel album track from Storm Front into a power ballad on Ropin' the Wind, and it became his seventh country No. 1 in late 1991.
    615pts
  10. Callin' Baton Rouge — ranked #1010
    Callin' Baton Rouge
    Dennis Linde's road song, first recorded by New Grass Revival, became a fiddle-driven No. 2 hit for Brooks in 1994.
    615pts
  11. Unanswered Prayers — ranked #1111
    Unanswered Prayers
    A reflective story-song about running into an old flame and realizing some prayers are better left unanswered.
    615pts
  12. The Thunder Rolls — ranked #1212
    The Thunder Rolls
    A dramatic, chart-topping ballad about infidelity, famous for its storm-as-metaphor imagery and controversial music video.
    615pts
  13. In Another's Eyes — ranked #1313
    In Another's Eyes
    His first major duet with Trisha Yearwood, years before they married, reached No. 2 and won the 1998 Grammy for Best Country Collaboration with Vocals.
    562pts
  14. That Summer — ranked #1414
    That Summer
    A 1993 No. 1 from The Chase, co-written with Pat Alger and Sandy Mahl, about a teenage farmhand's summer with a lonely widow.
    562pts
  15. More Than a Memory — ranked #1515
    More Than a Memory
    The lead single of The Ultimate Hits made history in 2007 as the first song to debut at No. 1 on Billboard's Hot Country Songs chart.
    562pts
  16. Two Piña Coladas — ranked #1616
    Two Piña Coladas
    A breezy 1998 single from Sevens about drowning heartbreak in tropical drinks, which topped the Billboard country chart.
    500pts
  17. American Honky-Tonk Bar Association — ranked #1717
    American Honky-Tonk Bar Association
    Bryan Kennedy and Jim Rushing's salute to working people unwinding at the local bar topped the country chart in 1993 as the second In Pieces single.
    500pts
  18. It's Midnight Cinderella — ranked #1818
    It's Midnight Cinderella
    Brooks, Kent Blazy and Kim Williams built this playful Fresh Horses single on a fairy-tale hook, and it reached No. 5 in 1996.
    500pts
  19. Learning to Live Again — ranked #1919
    Learning to Live Again
    Don Schlitz and Stephanie Davis wrote this 1993 ballad from The Chase about a nervous man's first date after heartbreak, and it peaked at No. 2.
    500pts
  20. Wild Horses — ranked #2020
    Wild Horses
    Recorded for No Fences in 1990 but not released as a single until 2000, when a re-sung version reached No. 7; it is not the Rolling Stones song.
    500pts
  21. One Night a Day — ranked #2121
    One Night a Day
    Gary Burr and Pete Wasner's jazzy piano-and-saxophone ballad from In Pieces, about getting over a breakup one night at a time, reached No. 7 in 1994.
    500pts
  22. Longneck Bottle — ranked #2222
    Longneck Bottle
    Steve Wariner co-wrote and played guitar on this barroom shuffle, the first Sevens single, which reached No. 1 at the end of 1997.
    500pts
  23. Two of a Kind, Workin' on a Full House — ranked #2323
    Two of a Kind, Workin' on a Full House
    Brooks took this card-table pun, first cut by co-writer Dennis Robbins in 1987, to No. 1 in 1991 as a rollicking single from No Fences.
    500pts
  24. She's Every Woman — ranked #2424
    She's Every Woman
    Written with Victoria Shaw, the lead single from Fresh Horses became his 14th No. 1 in October 1995.
    500pts
  25. Wrapped Up in You — ranked #2525
    Wrapped Up in You
    Wayne Kirkpatrick wrote this cheerful love song from Scarecrow, a No. 5 country hit in 2002 that also made the Hot 100.
    440pts
  26. Friends in Low Places — ranked #2626
    Friends in Low Places
    Brooks' signature honky-tonk anthem that spent four weeks at No. 1 and won Single of the Year at the CMA and ACM Awards.
    440pts
  27. To Make You Feel My Love — ranked #2727
    To Make You Feel My Love
    Brooks recorded Bob Dylan's ballad for the 1998 film Hope Floats, and his version became a country No. 1 that year.
    440pts
  28. Somewhere Other Than the Night — ranked #2828
    Somewhere Other Than the Night
    Written by Brooks and Kent Blazy, this tender 1992 single from The Chase about a farm couple's daytime romance put him back at No. 1.
    440pts
  29. Papa Loved Mama — ranked #2929
    Papa Loved Mama
    A darkly comic, up-tempo tale of a jealous truck driver and a marriage gone fatally wrong.
    440pts
  30. We Shall Be Free — ranked #3030
    We Shall Be Free
    The gospel-tinged plea for tolerance that opened The Chase in 1992 stalled at No. 12 when some radio stations refused to play it.
    440pts
  31. Not Counting You — ranked #3131
    Not Counting You
    Reportedly the first song he ever recorded, this up-tempo track from his 1989 debut album peaked at No. 2 in 1990.
    440pts
  32. Good Ride Cowboy — ranked #3232
    Good Ride Cowboy
    A rowdy 2005 tribute to his late friend Chris LeDoux, the rodeo champion turned singer, which reached No. 3 from The Lost Sessions.
    0pts
  33. Ask Me How I Know — ranked #3333
    Ask Me How I Know
    Mitch Rossell wrote this Gunslinger single, which in 2017 became Brooks's first new No. 1 since More Than a Memory a decade earlier.
    0pts
  34. Much Too Young (To Feel This Damn Old) — ranked #3434
    Much Too Young (To Feel This Damn Old)
    His 1989 debut single, co-written with Randy Taylor, follows a worn-out rodeo cowboy on the road and reached No. 8.
    0pts
  35. That Ol' Wind — ranked #3535
    That Ol' Wind
    The sixth and final Fresh Horses single, a story-song by Brooks and Leigh Reynolds about a love that returns with the wind, peaked at No. 4 in 1996.
    0pts
  36. She's Gonna Make It — ranked #3636
    She's Gonna Make It
    A wry 1998 Sevens single about a man watching his ex get over him far faster than he can get over her; it peaked at No. 2.
    0pts
  37. It's Your Song — ranked #3737
    It's Your Song
    The only single from Double Live, written by Pam Wolfe and Benita Hill, reached No. 9 in 1998 and crossed over to the Hot 100.
    0pts
  38. You Move Me — ranked #3838
    You Move Me
    Brooks covered this Gordon Kennedy and Pierce Pettis love song, first recorded by Susan Ashton, and took it to No. 3 in 1998.
    0pts

Photo credits

Comments