Concept albums, technical fireworks, and emotional depth across three decades of progressive metal — there's never a dull moment but there's always a debate. Cast your vote.
1Images and WordsDream Theater's 1992 breakthrough album featuring the iconic 'Pull Me Under.'1000pts
2Metropolis Pt. 2: Scenes from a MemoryDream Theater's 1999 concept album follow-up to 'Metropolis Pt. 1', considered a prog metal masterpiece.814pts
3Six Degrees of Inner TurbulenceDream Theater's 2002 double album with a 42-minute title track suite.639pts
4Systematic ChaosDream Theater's 2007 album blending progressive metal with modern heaviness.552pts
5Train of ThoughtDream Theater's 2003 heaviest album inspired by Metallica's Black Album.500pts
6Distance over TimeDream Theater's 2019 album returning to their progressive metal roots.500pts
7Black Clouds & Silver LiningsDream Theater's 2009 double album showcasing full instrumental and compositional range.500pts
8OctavariumDream Theater's 2005 concept album built around the number eight.417pts
9When Dream and Day UniteDream Theater's 1989 debut album featuring original vocalist Charlie Dominici.417pts
10Falling into InfinityDream Theater's 1997 label-pressured album with commercial aspirations.417pts
11Dream TheaterThe band's self-titled 2013 album, the second with drummer Mike Mangini, closes with the 22-minute suite Illumination Theory and earned a Grammy nomination for The Enemy Inside.417pts
12AwakeDream Theater's 1994 heavier and darker album showing expanded musical range.417pts
13A Dramatic Turn of EventsDream Theater's 2011 first album with drummer Mike Mangini.0pts
14The AstonishingSpread across 34 tracks and some 130 minutes, this 2016 rock opera is set in a future empire where machines called NOMACs make all the music.0pts
15A View from the Top of the WorldRecorded at the band's own DTHQ studio during the pandemic, this 2021 album ends with a 20-minute title track and won a Grammy for the single The Alien.0pts
16ParasomniaMike Portnoy's first album back in the band since 2009, Parasomnia is a 2025 concept record about sleep disorders told across eight tracks and about 71 minutes.0pts
Photo credits
- Images and Words cover — Atco Records, rights holder
- Metropolis Pt. 2: Scenes from a Memory cover — Elektra Records, rights holder
- Six Degrees of Inner Turbulence cover — Elektra Records, rights holder
- Systematic Chaos cover — Roadrunner Records, rights holder
- Distance over Time cover — Inside Out Music, rights holder
- When Dream and Day Unite cover — Mechanic Records, rights holder
- Dream Theater (2013 album) cover — Roadrunner Records, rights holder
- Awake cover — East West Records, rights holder
- A Dramatic Turn of Events cover — Roadrunner Records, rights holder
- The Astonishing cover — Roadrunner Records, rights holder
- A View from the Top of the World cover — Inside Out Music, rights holder
- Parasomnia cover — Inside Out Music, rights holder































