You Pick BestYouPickBest

What is the best Dream Theater album of all time?

By YPB Team

Concept albums, technical fireworks, and emotional depth across three decades of progressive metal — there's never a dull moment but there's always a debate. Cast your vote.

  1. Images and Words — ranked #11
    Images and Words
    Dream Theater's 1992 breakthrough album featuring the iconic 'Pull Me Under.'
    1000pts
  2. Metropolis Pt. 2: Scenes from a Memory — ranked #22
    Metropolis Pt. 2: Scenes from a Memory
    Dream Theater's 1999 concept album follow-up to 'Metropolis Pt. 1', considered a prog metal masterpiece.
    814pts
  3. Six Degrees of Inner Turbulence — ranked #33
    Six Degrees of Inner Turbulence
    Dream Theater's 2002 double album with a 42-minute title track suite.
    639pts
  4. Systematic Chaos — ranked #44
    Systematic Chaos
    Dream Theater's 2007 album blending progressive metal with modern heaviness.
    552pts
  5. Train of Thought — ranked #55
    Train of Thought
    Dream Theater's 2003 heaviest album inspired by Metallica's Black Album.
    500pts
  6. Distance over Time — ranked #66
    Distance over Time
    Dream Theater's 2019 album returning to their progressive metal roots.
    500pts
  7. Black Clouds & Silver Linings — ranked #77
    Black Clouds & Silver Linings
    Dream Theater's 2009 double album showcasing full instrumental and compositional range.
    500pts
  8. Octavarium — ranked #88
    Octavarium
    Dream Theater's 2005 concept album built around the number eight.
    417pts
  9. When Dream and Day Unite — ranked #99
    When Dream and Day Unite
    Dream Theater's 1989 debut album featuring original vocalist Charlie Dominici.
    417pts
  10. Falling into Infinity — ranked #1010
    Falling into Infinity
    Dream Theater's 1997 label-pressured album with commercial aspirations.
    417pts
  11. Dream Theater — ranked #1111
    Dream Theater
    The band's self-titled 2013 album, the second with drummer Mike Mangini, closes with the 22-minute suite Illumination Theory and earned a Grammy nomination for The Enemy Inside.
    417pts
  12. Awake — ranked #1212
    Awake
    Dream Theater's 1994 heavier and darker album showing expanded musical range.
    417pts
  13. A Dramatic Turn of Events — ranked #1313
    A Dramatic Turn of Events
    Dream Theater's 2011 first album with drummer Mike Mangini.
    0pts
  14. The Astonishing — ranked #1414
    The Astonishing
    Spread across 34 tracks and some 130 minutes, this 2016 rock opera is set in a future empire where machines called NOMACs make all the music.
    0pts
  15. A View from the Top of the World — ranked #1515
    A View from the Top of the World
    Recorded at the band's own DTHQ studio during the pandemic, this 2021 album ends with a 20-minute title track and won a Grammy for the single The Alien.
    0pts
  16. Parasomnia — ranked #1616
    Parasomnia
    Mike Portnoy's first album back in the band since 2009, Parasomnia is a 2025 concept record about sleep disorders told across eight tracks and about 71 minutes.
    0pts

Photo credits

Comments