What is Peter O'Toole's best performance?

O'Toole played kings, madmen and fading matinee idols, and earned eight Oscar nominations without ever winning one. Decide which of those near-misses deserved the statue most.

1. 1
   Maurice (Venus)

   A late-career 2006 role as an aging actor drawn to a young woman, which brought his eighth and final Oscar nomination.
   1000pts
2. 2
   T. E. Lawrence (Lawrence of Arabia)

   O'Toole's star-making 1962 turn as the enigmatic British officer leading the Arab Revolt, earning his first Oscar nomination.
   999pts
3. 3
   Arthur Chipping (Goodbye, Mr. Chips)

   A tender 1969 musical turn as a shy public-school schoolmaster across decades, rewarded with a Golden Globe.
   999pts
4. 4
   Henry II (The Lion in Winter)

   A ferocious 1968 performance as the aging Plantagenet king sparring with Katharine Hepburn's Eleanor over the succession.
   958pts
5. 5
   Eli Cross (The Stunt Man)

   A gleefully manipulative 1980 performance as a godlike film director who hides a fugitive among his stunt crew.
   958pts
6. 6
   Alan Swann (My Favorite Year)

   A 1982 comedy role as a boozy Errol Flynn-style swashbuckler guesting on live 1950s television.
   789pts
7. 7
   Jim (Lord Jim)

   Richard Brooks's 1965 Joseph Conrad adaptation, with O'Toole as a disgraced sailor seeking redemption in Southeast Asia.
   684pts
8. 8
   Reginald Johnston (The Last Emperor)

   His 1987 supporting role as the Scottish tutor to Puyi in Bernardo Bertolucci's Best Picture winner.
   560pts
9. 9
   Jack Gurney (The Ruling Class)

   A wild 1972 black-comedy role as a paranoid schizophrenic earl who believes he is God, Oscar-nominated.
   559pts
10. 10
    Henry II (Becket)

    His first take on Henry II, a 1964 duel of wills with Richard Burton's Thomas Becket that won him a Golden Globe.
    410pts
11. 11
    Simon Dermott (How to Steal a Million)

    A breezy 1966 caper role opposite Audrey Hepburn as a society burglar helping steal a fake statue.
    410pts
12. 12
    Priam (Troy)

    A dignified 2004 supporting turn as the Trojan king who begs Achilles for the body of his son Hector.
    410pts
13. 13
    Don Quixote (Man of La Mancha)

    The 1972 musical adaptation with O'Toole playing both Cervantes and his deluded knight-errant.
    410pts
14. 14
    Anton Ego (Ratatouille)

    The 2007 Pixar voice role as a cadaverous food critic whose closing review became one of animation's great monologues.
    0pts
15. 15
    General Tanz (The Night of the Generals)

    A chilling 1967 role as a fastidious Nazi general suspected of murder, reuniting him with Omar Sharif.
    0pts

Comments