You Pick BestYouPickBest

The 34 Best Bourbon Brands

By YPB Team

Bar-rail workhorses sit beside bottles that sell out in minutes, and wheated mash bills go up against high-rye ones. Some of these labels date to the 1800s; others started pouring barely a decade ago.

  1. Maker's Mark — ranked #11
    Maker's Mark
    Wheated bourbon from Loretto, Kentucky, created by Bill Samuels Sr. and first bottled in 1958 with its hand-dipped red wax seal.
    1000pts
  2. Jim Beam — ranked #22
    Jim Beam
    Bourbon from Clermont, Kentucky, made by a distilling family whose bourbon-making traces back to Jacob Beam in the 1790s, now owned by Suntory Global Spirits.
    932pts
  3. Buffalo Trace — ranked #33
    Buffalo Trace
    Kentucky straight bourbon launched in 1999 and named after the Frankfort distillery that makes it, owned by the Sazerac Company.
    847pts
  4. Bulleit — ranked #44
    Bulleit
    High-rye bourbon brand founded by Tom Bulleit in 1987 and owned by Diageo, which opened the Bulleit Distilling Co. in Shelbyville, Kentucky in 2017.
    793pts
  5. Four Roses — ranked #55
    Four Roses
    Lawrenceburg, Kentucky bourbon blended from ten recipes that combine two mash bills with five yeast strains.
    697pts
  6. Larceny — ranked #66
    Larceny
    Wheated Heaven Hill bourbon introduced in 2012, named after the tale of treasury agent John E. Fitzgerald secretly tapping barrels.
    697pts
  7. Blanton's — ranked #77
    Blanton's
    Single barrel bourbon created by Elmer T. Lee and released in 1984, distilled at Buffalo Trace and topped with a horse-and-jockey stopper.
    657pts
  8. Woodford Reserve — ranked #88
    Woodford Reserve
    Brown-Forman bourbon introduced in 1996 and made at the historic distillery near Versailles, Kentucky; it is the official bourbon of the Kentucky Derby.
    612pts
  9. Old Grand-Dad — ranked #99
    Old Grand-Dad
    High-rye bourbon brand named in honor of 18th-century distiller Basil Hayden Sr., whose portrait appears on the label, now made by Jim Beam.
    612pts
  10. Weller — ranked #1010
    Weller
    Wheated bourbon brand from Buffalo Trace named after William Larue Weller, a 19th-century Louisville whiskey merchant.
    612pts
  11. Wild Turkey — ranked #1111
    Wild Turkey
    Bourbon distilled in Lawrenceburg, Kentucky, owned by Campari Group, where father and son Jimmy and Eddie Russell have served as master distillers.
    560pts
  12. Evan Williams — ranked #1212
    Evan Williams
    Heaven Hill bourbon introduced in 1957 and named after Evan Williams, an 18th-century Louisville distiller.
    560pts
  13. Booker's — ranked #1313
    Booker's
    Uncut, unfiltered barrel-proof bourbon introduced in 1988 by Jim Beam master distiller Booker Noe.
    560pts
  14. Elijah Craig — ranked #1414
    Elijah Craig
    Heaven Hill bourbon named after the 18th-century Baptist preacher and distiller Elijah Craig, first released as a 12-year-old in 1986.
    560pts
  15. Pappy Van Winkle — ranked #1515
    Pappy Van Winkle
    Wheated bourbon line named after Julian 'Pappy' Van Winkle Sr., produced at Buffalo Trace since a 2002 joint venture with the Van Winkle family.
    500pts
  16. Eagle Rare — ranked #1616
    Eagle Rare
    Bourbon brand introduced by Seagram in 1975 and made at Buffalo Trace, best known for its 10-year-old expression.
    500pts
  17. Basil Hayden — ranked #1717
    Basil Hayden
    High-rye Jim Beam bourbon added to the Small Batch Bourbon Collection in 1992 and named after 18th-century Kentucky distiller Basil Hayden Sr.
    500pts
  18. Willett — ranked #1818
    Willett
    Family-owned Bardstown, Kentucky brand whose Willett Distillery resumed distilling in 2012, known for its pot-still-shaped Pot Still Reserve bottle.
    500pts
  19. Baker's — ranked #1919
    Baker's
    Jim Beam Small Batch Bourbon Collection brand named after distiller Baker Beam, bottled at 107 proof.
    500pts
  20. Angel's Envy — ranked #2020
    Angel's Envy
    Louisville bourbon co-founded by Lincoln Henderson and his son Wes, released in 2011 and finished in port wine barrels.
    500pts
  21. Old Forester — ranked #2121
    Old Forester
    Brown-Forman's founding bourbon, first sold by George Garvin Brown in 1870 exclusively in sealed glass bottles.
    451pts
  22. Jefferson's — ranked #2222
    Jefferson's
    Bourbon brand founded in 1997 by Trey Zoeller, known for its Jefferson's Ocean series aged aboard ships at sea.
    451pts
  23. Knob Creek — ranked #2323
    Knob Creek
    Jim Beam bourbon introduced in 1992 by Booker Noe as part of the Small Batch Bourbon Collection.
    451pts
  24. Russell's Reserve — ranked #2424
    Russell's Reserve
    Wild Turkey's premium bourbon line named after father-and-son master distillers Jimmy and Eddie Russell.
    451pts
  25. Old Crow — ranked #2525
    Old Crow
    Bourbon brand named after James C. Crow, the 19th-century Kentucky distiller credited with refining the sour mash process, now owned by Jim Beam.
    451pts
  26. 1792 — ranked #2626
    1792
    Sazerac bourbon made at the Barton 1792 Distillery in Bardstown, named for the year Kentucky became a state.
    394pts
  27. Garrison Brothers — ranked #2727
    Garrison Brothers
    Texas bourbon distillery in Hye founded by Dan Garrison, whose first bottles were released in 2010.
    394pts
  28. Wilderness Trail — ranked #2828
    Wilderness Trail
    Danville, Kentucky bourbon from the distillery Shane Baker and Pat Heist founded in 2012, in which Campari Group bought a 70% stake in 2022.
    394pts
  29. New Riff — ranked #2929
    New Riff
    Bourbon from New Riff Distilling in Newport, Kentucky, which opened in 2014 and releases its flagship bourbon as bottled-in-bond.
    394pts
  30. I.W. Harper — ranked #3030
    I.W. Harper
    Bourbon brand created by Isaac Wolfe Bernheim in the 1870s and owned by Diageo, which relaunched it in the United States in 2015.
    0pts
  31. Rebel — ranked #3131
    Rebel
    Wheated bourbon sold for decades as Rebel Yell and now made by Lux Row Distillers in Bardstown, Kentucky.
    0pts
  32. Very Old Barton — ranked #3232
    Very Old Barton
    Sazerac bourbon brand made at the Barton 1792 Distillery in Bardstown, Kentucky.
    0pts
  33. Michter's — ranked #3333
    Michter's
    Louisville whiskey brand revived in the 1990s by Joseph Magliocco, whose Fort Nelson Distillery opened downtown in 2019.
    0pts
  34. Old Fitzgerald — ranked #3434
    Old Fitzgerald
    Wheated bourbon brand once made at the Stitzel-Weller distillery and owned by Heaven Hill since 1999.
    0pts

Photo credits

Comments