Bar-rail workhorses sit beside bottles that sell out in minutes, and wheated mash bills go up against high-rye ones. Some of these labels date to the 1800s; others started pouring barely a decade ago.
1Maker's MarkWheated bourbon from Loretto, Kentucky, created by Bill Samuels Sr. and first bottled in 1958 with its hand-dipped red wax seal.1000pts
2Jim BeamBourbon from Clermont, Kentucky, made by a distilling family whose bourbon-making traces back to Jacob Beam in the 1790s, now owned by Suntory Global Spirits.932pts
3Buffalo TraceKentucky straight bourbon launched in 1999 and named after the Frankfort distillery that makes it, owned by the Sazerac Company.847pts
4BulleitHigh-rye bourbon brand founded by Tom Bulleit in 1987 and owned by Diageo, which opened the Bulleit Distilling Co. in Shelbyville, Kentucky in 2017.793pts
5Four RosesLawrenceburg, Kentucky bourbon blended from ten recipes that combine two mash bills with five yeast strains.697pts
6LarcenyWheated Heaven Hill bourbon introduced in 2012, named after the tale of treasury agent John E. Fitzgerald secretly tapping barrels.697pts
7Blanton'sSingle barrel bourbon created by Elmer T. Lee and released in 1984, distilled at Buffalo Trace and topped with a horse-and-jockey stopper.657pts
8Woodford ReserveBrown-Forman bourbon introduced in 1996 and made at the historic distillery near Versailles, Kentucky; it is the official bourbon of the Kentucky Derby.612pts
9Old Grand-DadHigh-rye bourbon brand named in honor of 18th-century distiller Basil Hayden Sr., whose portrait appears on the label, now made by Jim Beam.612pts
10WellerWheated bourbon brand from Buffalo Trace named after William Larue Weller, a 19th-century Louisville whiskey merchant.612pts
11Wild TurkeyBourbon distilled in Lawrenceburg, Kentucky, owned by Campari Group, where father and son Jimmy and Eddie Russell have served as master distillers.560pts
12Evan WilliamsHeaven Hill bourbon introduced in 1957 and named after Evan Williams, an 18th-century Louisville distiller.560pts
13Booker'sUncut, unfiltered barrel-proof bourbon introduced in 1988 by Jim Beam master distiller Booker Noe.560pts
14Elijah CraigHeaven Hill bourbon named after the 18th-century Baptist preacher and distiller Elijah Craig, first released as a 12-year-old in 1986.560pts
15Pappy Van WinkleWheated bourbon line named after Julian 'Pappy' Van Winkle Sr., produced at Buffalo Trace since a 2002 joint venture with the Van Winkle family.500pts
16Eagle RareBourbon brand introduced by Seagram in 1975 and made at Buffalo Trace, best known for its 10-year-old expression.500pts
17Basil HaydenHigh-rye Jim Beam bourbon added to the Small Batch Bourbon Collection in 1992 and named after 18th-century Kentucky distiller Basil Hayden Sr.500pts
18WillettFamily-owned Bardstown, Kentucky brand whose Willett Distillery resumed distilling in 2012, known for its pot-still-shaped Pot Still Reserve bottle.500pts
19Baker'sJim Beam Small Batch Bourbon Collection brand named after distiller Baker Beam, bottled at 107 proof.500pts
20Angel's EnvyLouisville bourbon co-founded by Lincoln Henderson and his son Wes, released in 2011 and finished in port wine barrels.500pts
21Old ForesterBrown-Forman's founding bourbon, first sold by George Garvin Brown in 1870 exclusively in sealed glass bottles.451pts
22Jefferson'sBourbon brand founded in 1997 by Trey Zoeller, known for its Jefferson's Ocean series aged aboard ships at sea.451pts
23Knob CreekJim Beam bourbon introduced in 1992 by Booker Noe as part of the Small Batch Bourbon Collection.451pts
24Russell's ReserveWild Turkey's premium bourbon line named after father-and-son master distillers Jimmy and Eddie Russell.451pts
25Old CrowBourbon brand named after James C. Crow, the 19th-century Kentucky distiller credited with refining the sour mash process, now owned by Jim Beam.451pts
261792Sazerac bourbon made at the Barton 1792 Distillery in Bardstown, named for the year Kentucky became a state.394pts
27Garrison BrothersTexas bourbon distillery in Hye founded by Dan Garrison, whose first bottles were released in 2010.394pts
28Wilderness TrailDanville, Kentucky bourbon from the distillery Shane Baker and Pat Heist founded in 2012, in which Campari Group bought a 70% stake in 2022.394pts
29New RiffBourbon from New Riff Distilling in Newport, Kentucky, which opened in 2014 and releases its flagship bourbon as bottled-in-bond.394pts
30I.W. HarperBourbon brand created by Isaac Wolfe Bernheim in the 1870s and owned by Diageo, which relaunched it in the United States in 2015.0pts
31RebelWheated bourbon sold for decades as Rebel Yell and now made by Lux Row Distillers in Bardstown, Kentucky.0pts
32Very Old BartonSazerac bourbon brand made at the Barton 1792 Distillery in Bardstown, Kentucky.0pts
33Michter'sLouisville whiskey brand revived in the 1990s by Joseph Magliocco, whose Fort Nelson Distillery opened downtown in 2019.0pts
34Old FitzgeraldWheated bourbon brand once made at the Stitzel-Weller distillery and owned by Heaven Hill since 1999.0pts
Photo credits
- Buffalo Trace — Rick Audet, CC BY 2.0
- Four Roses — King4120, CC BY-SA 4.0
- Blanton's — Fortkeeper, CC BY-SA 4.0
- Weller — Craiglduncan, CC BY-SA 3.0
- Evan Williams — Kenneth C. Zirkel, CC BY-SA 4.0
- Booker's — Craiglduncan, CC BY-SA 3.0
- Elijah Craig — Dominic Lockyer, CC BY 2.0
- Pappy Van Winkle — Craiglduncan, CC BY-SA 3.0
- Eagle Rare — Craiglduncan, CC BY-SA 3.0
- Old Forester — Kellibauman524, CC BY-SA 4.0
- Jefferson's — Castle Brands Inc, CC BY-SA 3.0
- Knob Creek — Craiglduncan, CC BY-SA 3.0
- Old Crow — Craiglduncan, CC BY-SA 3.0
- 1792 — Sazerac, CC BY-SA 4.0
- Rebel — Craiglduncan, CC BY-SA 3.0






























