Every band here has a masterpiece somewhere else in the catalogue. These are the records their own fans skip.
1LuluThe 2011 Lou Reed and Metallica collaboration, routinely voted the worst record either made.1000pts
2St. AngerMetallica's 2003 album, remembered for a snare sound its own fans imitate as a joke.952pts
3Van Halen IIIThe 1998 album with Gary Cherone on vocals, the band's only one-off singer.800pts
4Dirty WorkThe Rolling Stones' 1986 low point, recorded while Jagger and Richards barely spoke.714pts
5Cut the CrapThe Clash's 1985 album, made without Mick Jones and disowned soon after.714pts
6LoadMetallica's 1996 blues-rock turn, still the dividing line in the band's fanbase.647pts
7Hot SpaceQueen's 1982 disco-funk experiment, which emptied arenas in the United States.571pts
8Never Let Me DownDavid Bowie's 1987 album, which he later called his nadir.483pts
9Music from The ElderKiss's 1981 concept album with an orchestra, abandoned live almost immediately.381pts
10ForbiddenBlack Sabbath's 1995 album, produced by Body Count's Ernie C and disowned by the band.381pts
11RiskMegadeth's 1999 pivot to radio rock, which cost them Marty Friedman.381pts
12It's HardThe Who's 1982 farewell, the record the band spent decades apologising for.260pts
13Cold LakeCeltic Frost's 1988 glam detour, a genre change nobody asked for.260pts
14GenerationsJourney's 2005 album, on which every member took a turn singing lead.260pts
15Night in the RutsAerosmith's 1979 album, cut mid-collapse with Joe Perry already out of the band.0pts




















