# Who is the most overrated quarterback in NFL history?

> Reputation and production drift apart more often than highlight reels admit. This is the uncomfortable version of the list.

*By YPB Team · Published August 17, 2026 · https://youpick.best/ranking/who-is-the-most-overrated-quarterback-in-nfl-history*

---

## Current results (2 votes)

1. **Joe Flacco** — 50% (1 votes · score 1000/1000)
   Ravens quarterback whose 2012 postseason run ended in a Super Bowl MVP award.
2. **Mark Sanchez** — 50% (1 votes · score 927/1000)
   Jets quarterback who reached two AFC Championship games early and faded quickly.
3. **Jay Cutler** — 0% (0 votes · score 709/1000)
   Strong-armed Bears quarterback whose talent outpaced his team results.
4. **Baker Mayfield** — 0% (0 votes · score 709/1000)
   First overall pick who rebuilt his career in Tampa Bay after several stops.
5. **Tom Brady** — 0% (0 votes · score 709/1000)
   Seven-time Super Bowl champion who spent 20 seasons in New England before winning a seventh ring in Tampa Bay.
6. **Patrick Mahomes** — 0% (0 votes · score 600/1000)
   Chiefs quarterback with three Super Bowl titles and three Super Bowl MVPs before turning 30.
7. **Eli Manning** — 0% (0 votes · score 600/1000)
   Giants quarterback who beat unbeaten New England in Super Bowl XLII and won a second ring four years later.
8. **Andy Dalton** — 0% (0 votes · score 600/1000)
   Bengals quarterback who reached the playoffs repeatedly without winning a game there.
9. **Ben Roethlisberger** — 0% (0 votes · score 600/1000)
   Steelers quarterback who won two Super Bowls and was famously hard to bring down.
10. **Tony Romo** — 0% (0 votes · score 466/1000)
   Cowboys quarterback with strong numbers and no deep playoff run.
11. **Matt Ryan** — 0% (0 votes · score 466/1000)
   Falcons MVP who led a 28-3 Super Bowl lead that did not hold.
12. **Dak Prescott** — 0% (0 votes · score 466/1000)
   Cowboys quarterback and former fourth-round pick who became a long-term starter.
13. **Carson Wentz** — 0% (0 votes · score 466/1000)
   MVP front-runner in 2017 who never regained that form after injury.
14. **Kirk Cousins** — 0% (0 votes · score 300/1000)
   Long-time starter known for big contracts and strong regular-season numbers.
15. **Russell Wilson** — 0% (0 votes · score 300/1000)
   Seahawks quarterback who won Super Bowl XLVIII as a second-year starter.
16. **Philip Rivers** — 0% (0 votes · score 300/1000)
   Chargers quarterback with huge career numbers and no Super Bowl appearance.

Tags: football, nfl, quarterbacks