# Who is the greatest improviser in jazz history?

> Speed, space, harmony, sheer nerve — no two of these players solved the same problem the same way.

*By YPB Team · Published September 3, 2026 · https://youpick.best/ranking/who-is-the-greatest-improviser-in-jazz-history*

---

## Current results (no votes yet)

1. **Django Reinhardt** — score 1000/1000
   Improvised with two working fingers on his fretting hand and invented a European jazz language in the process.
2. **Louis Armstrong** — score 898/1000
   Invented the extended jazz solo with the Hot Fives and Sevens, turning a collective music into a soloist's art.
3. **Sonny Rollins** — score 800/1000
   Builds solos as long thematic arguments, most famously across the unaccompanied stretches of his live sets.
4. **John Coltrane** — score 800/1000
   Practised obsessively and improvised in sheets of sound, then abandoned the harmony he had mastered.
5. **Charlie Parker** — score 800/1000
   Bebop's architect, whose solos moved so fast through harmony that musicians transcribed them as a curriculum.
6. **Miles Davis** — score 762/1000
   Improvised by subtraction, leaving space where other trumpeters crowded the bar.
7. **Ella Fitzgerald** — score 659/1000
   Scatted with the precision of a horn player, improvising lines that instrumentalists borrowed back.
8. **Art Tatum** — score 659/1000
   A pianist whose reharmonisations were so dense that other players assumed they were hearing two people.
9. **Ornette Coleman** — score 467/1000
   Improvised free of fixed chord changes, reorganising what a jazz solo could be built on.
10. **Bill Evans** — score 467/1000
   Improvised in conversation with his trio, treating the bass and drums as equal voices rather than accompaniment.
11. **Oscar Peterson** — score 467/1000
   Brought a virtuoso's technique to the piano trio, with a swing so consistent it became its own benchmark.
12. **Cecil Taylor** — score 467/1000
   Attacked the piano as percussion, improvising dense structures that dispensed with melody and metre entirely.
13. **Wayne Shorter** — score 343/1000
   Improvised as a composer does, shaping solos into structures across Blakey, Davis and Weather Report.
14. **Keith Jarrett** — score 343/1000
   Improvised full concerts from nothing, including a solo recital that became the best-selling piano album ever made.
15. **Clifford Brown** — score 343/1000
   Combined bebop fluency with a warm tone and flawless execution before dying at twenty-five.
16. **Dizzy Gillespie** — score 343/1000
   Combined bebop's harmonic speed with a rhythmic daring that reached into Afro-Cuban music.
17. **Herbie Hancock** — score 343/1000
   Reharmonises in real time, moving between acoustic post-bop and electric funk without changing his instincts.
18. **Lester Young** — score 190/1000
   Played behind the beat with a light tone that gave every later tenor player an alternative to Coleman Hawkins.
19. **Wes Montgomery** — score 190/1000
   Played with his thumb instead of a pick, building solos from single notes to octaves to block chords.
20. **Coleman Hawkins** — score 190/1000
   His 1939 'Body and Soul' solo barely states the melody and is still the most studied tenor recording of its era.

Tags: music, jazz, improvisation, soloists