# Who is the best player in New York City FC history?

> Big-name signings who filled Yankee Stadium share these spots with the less heralded grinders behind the 2021 MLS Cup run. A young club, but the arguments are already loud.

*By YPB Team · Published November 12, 2026 · https://youpick.best/ranking/who-is-the-best-player-in-new-york-city-fc-history*

---

## Current results (no votes yet)

1. **David Villa** — score 1000/1000
   Spanish striker who was NYCFC's first-ever signing, played for the club from 2015 to 2018 and won the 2016 MLS MVP award.
2. **Maxi Moralez** — score 965/1000
   Argentine playmaker who joined NYCFC in 2017, won the 2021 MLS Cup and holds the club's appearance record.
3. **Sean Johnson** — score 774/1000
   American goalkeeper who played for NYCFC from 2017 to 2022 and was named MVP of the 2021 MLS Cup final after saving penalties in the shootout.
4. **Jesús Medina** — score 610/1000
   Paraguayan attacking midfielder who played for NYCFC from 2018 to 2021 and won the 2021 MLS Cup.
5. **Jack Harrison** — score 610/1000
   English winger who played for NYCFC in 2016 and 2017 and scored 10 MLS goals in 2017.
6. **Alexandru Mitriță** — score 529/1000
   Romanian winger who joined NYCFC in 2019 and scored 12 MLS goals in his first season.
7. **Alexander Ring** — score 529/1000
   Finnish midfielder who played for NYCFC from 2017 to 2020 and captained the side that topped the Eastern Conference in 2019.
8. **Keaton Parks** — score 433/1000
   American midfielder who joined NYCFC on loan from Benfica in 2019, signed permanently in 2020 and won the 2021 MLS Cup.
9. **Héber** — score 433/1000
   Brazilian striker who scored 15 MLS goals for NYCFC in 2019 and was part of the 2021 MLS Cup-winning squad.
10. **Valentín Castellanos** — score 317/1000
   Argentine striker who won the 2021 MLS Golden Boot with 19 goals and the MLS Cup with NYCFC that year.
11. **Thiago Martins** — score 317/1000
   Brazilian center back who has anchored NYCFC's defense since 2022 and won the 2022 Campeones Cup.
12. **Alonso Martínez** — score 317/1000
   Costa Rican striker who joined NYCFC in 2023 and led the team with 16 MLS goals in 2024.
13. **Alexander Callens** — score 0/1000
   Peruvian center back who played for NYCFC from 2017 to 2022 and won the 2021 MLS Cup.
14. **Maxime Chanot** — score 0/1000
   Luxembourg international center back who joined NYCFC in 2016 and won the 2021 MLS Cup.
15. **Anton Tinnerholm** — score 0/1000
   Swedish right back who played for NYCFC from 2018 to 2022 and was part of the 2021 MLS Cup-winning squad.
16. **James Sands** — score 0/1000
   Academy-produced defender and midfielder who became NYCFC's first homegrown signing in 2017 and won the 2021 MLS Cup.

Tags: soccer, players, new-york, mls, new york city fc