# Who is the best Nashville SC player of all time?

> Expansion-year originals line up against the side that ran away with a Supporters' Shield. Pick the one Geodis Park would cheer loudest.

*By YPB Team · Published October 28, 2026 · https://youpick.best/ranking/who-is-the-best-nashville-sc-player-of-all-time*

---

## Current results (no votes yet)

1. **Hany Mukhtar** — score 1000/1000
   German attacking midfielder who won the 2022 MLS MVP and Golden Boot for Nashville.
2. **Patrick Yazbek** — score 927/1000
   Australian midfielder who became a fixture in Nashville's midfield.
3. **Aníbal Godoy** — score 800/1000
   Panamanian midfielder who anchored Nashville's midfield from 2020.
4. **Dax McCarty** — score 709/1000
   Veteran midfielder who captained Nashville in its first MLS seasons from 2020.
5. **Randall Leal** — score 600/1000
   Costa Rican winger and creative outlet in Nashville's early MLS seasons.
6. **CJ Sapong** — score 600/1000
   Striker who scored the club's first goals in its debut MLS season in 2020.
7. **Dave Romney** — score 600/1000
   Centre-back who partnered Zimmerman in the league's stingiest defence of 2020-2022.
8. **Brian Schwake** — score 600/1000
   Goalkeeper who kept 15 clean sheets in the 2026 Supporters' Shield season.
9. **Sam Surridge** — score 600/1000
   English striker who became Nashville's main goal threat after arriving in 2024.
10. **Walker Zimmerman** — score 466/1000
   Centre-back and captain who won MLS Defender of the Year twice with Nashville.
11. **Daniel Lovitz** — score 466/1000
   Left-back who started for Nashville from its first MLS game and played for the US national team.
12. **Alex Muyl** — score 466/1000
   Versatile wide player who gave Nashville years of energy on either flank.
13. **Jeisson Palacios** — score 466/1000
   Colombian centre-back central to Nashville's build-up in the 2026 Shield campaign.
14. **Jack Maher** — score 466/1000
   Centre-back drafted in 2020 who grew into a regular starter in Nashville's back line.
15. **Jacob Shaffelburg** — score 466/1000
   Canadian winger whose pace made him a key attacker and a Canada regular.
16. **Shaq Moore** — score 0/1000
   US international right-back who joined in 2022 and starred down the right side.
17. **Andy Nájar** — score 0/1000
   Honduran full-back who brought experience to the 2026 Supporters' Shield side.

Tags: soccer, players, mls, nashville