# Who is the best goaltender in NHL history?

> Butterfly pioneers, acrobatic shot-stoppers, iron-man legends, and modern fortress keepers — these netminders redefined the position in completely different ways. Who takes the top spot?

*By YPB Team · Published June 2, 2026 · https://youpick.best/ranking/who-is-the-best-goaltender-in-nhl-history*

---

## Current results (no votes yet)

1. **Patrick Roy** — score 1000/1000
   The two-time Stanley Cup winner with Montreal and two with Colorado who popularized the butterfly style and won three Conn Smythe Trophies.
2. **Martin Brodeur** — score 769/1000
   New Jersey Devils legend who holds the all-time records for wins and shutouts, winning three Stanley Cups with the Devils' defensive dynasty.
3. **Roberto Luongo** — score 385/1000
   Two-time Olympic gold medalist for Canada and a consistently elite netminder across 19 NHL seasons despite never capturing the Stanley Cup.
4. **Henrik Lundqvist** — score 385/1000
   New York Rangers icon and 2012 Vezina Trophy winner who anchored Broadway for 15 seasons and is considered the best goalie never to win a Cup.
5. **Jacques Plante** — score 384/1000
   Montreal Canadiens pioneer who won six Stanley Cups and seven Vezina Trophies while becoming the first goalie to regularly wear a mask.
6. **Grant Fuhr** — score 384/1000
   Edmonton Oilers dynasty goalie who won five Stanley Cups backing the most explosive offensive team in NHL history.
7. **Terry Sawchuk** — score 231/1000
   Detroit Red Wings icon who set the long-standing shutout record of 103 and won four Stanley Cups with a career .929 save percentage.
8. **Glenn Hall** — score 231/1000
   Nicknamed Mr. Goalie, he played 502 consecutive complete games — an unbreakable iron-man record — and won three Stanley Cups.
9. **Ken Dryden** — score 1/1000
   Montreal Canadiens cornerstone who won six Stanley Cups in just eight NHL seasons, retiring at his peak to pursue a law career.
10. **Dominik Hasek** — score 1/1000
   The acrobatic Czech known as the Dominator, winner of six Vezina Trophies and two Hart Trophies — the only goalie to win the MVP award twice.
11. **Ed Belfour** — score 1/1000
   Known as Eddie the Eagle, he won the Calder, two Vezina Trophies, and one Stanley Cup while posting 484 career wins.
12. **Marc-Andre Fleury** — score 1/1000
   Three-time Stanley Cup winner with Pittsburgh who amassed 573 career wins — second only to Brodeur — across a 20-year career.

Tags: sports, hockey, nhl, goaltenders