# What is the most overrated fighting game?

> Reputations built on marketing, nostalgia, or one very good year. Every entry here has a defence worth hearing.

*By YPB Team · Published September 22, 2026 · https://youpick.best/ranking/what-is-the-most-overrated-fighting-game*

---

## Current results (no votes yet)

1. **Mortal Kombat**
   Remembered for the blood; its 1992 fighting engine was thinner than the games it outsold.
2. **Street Fighter**
   The franchise everyone names as the benchmark, which spent the V years losing that argument.
3. **Super Smash Bros. Melee**
   Twenty-five years of competitive devotion built on a 2001 game its own publisher keeps sidelining.
4. **Tekken 7**
   A long-running headline game whose rage-art comebacks split its own audience.
5. **Marvel vs. Capcom 2**
   Beloved as a spectacle, and a game where a handful of characters dominated everything.
6. **Mortal Kombat: Armageddon**
   Sold on a roster of every character ever, at the cost of any of them being balanced.
7. **Street Fighter V**
   Launched in 2016 without an arcade mode and spent years being rebuilt in public.
8. **Killer Instinct (1994)**
   Marketed on combo counters that ran into the dozens, which flattered the player more than it tested them.
9. **Soulcalibur II**
   Praised as the peak of weapon fighting, and remembered mostly for its guest characters.
10. **Virtua Fighter**
   Held up as the purist's choice by people who mostly did not play it.
11. **Dead or Alive**
   A genuinely fast counter-based fighter that spent two decades being marketed on everything else.
12. **Injustice: Gods Among Us**
   Carried by the DC licence more than by its own systems.
13. **Mortal Kombat vs. DC Universe**
   A crossover that had to drop the Fatalities to hold its rating.

Tags: games, franchises, classics, fighting